Why this matters
A supplier that markets to one role is planning as if a business purchase were a consumer one. The business-to-business marketing guide explains why that fails: several people decide, the purchase takes months and each of them carries personal risk. The comparison of business and consumer marketing shows the same difference from the buyer's side. Deals that start well and then stall are usually a sign that someone on the committee was never reached, and their question arrived late with nothing to answer it.
This exercise applies See-Think-Do-Care for lead generation, which reads intent account by account and accepts that one organisation has people in different clusters at the same moment.
The supplier and its buyers
Calloway Scientific is a fictional supplier of benchtop laboratory equipment: centrifuges, incubators and an automated sample-preparation system that is its most expensive product. It sells to independent testing laboratories, university departments and small biotech firms. Its marketing is an email newsletter to lab managers, a stand at a regional laboratory show, product specification sheets and a "request a quote" form.
Calloway Scientific: last year's sample-preparation deals
| Measure | Last year |
|---|---|
| Quote requests for the sample-preparation system | 46 |
| Quotes sent | 41 |
| Deals won | 7 |
| Deals lost to a competitor | 9 |
| Deals stalled with no decision | 25 |
| Typical time from quote to decision, won deals | five to eight months |
| Where stalled deals stopped, from sales notes | Deals |
|---|---|
| "Finance asked for a payback case; lab manager could not produce one" | 9 |
| "Procurement sent a supplier questionnaire; we took weeks to answer" | 6 |
| "Quality manager asked how the system would be validated" | 5 |
| "Estates raised power and bench-space questions at installation planning" | 3 |
| "IT asked whether the software connects to the lab's data system" | 2 |
The newsletter goes to lab managers only. Nobody at Calloway owns content for anyone else.
Mapping the committee
Start with roles, not job titles, because a small lab may have one person doing two jobs. For each role ask three questions. What do they need to be true before they agree? What would embarrass them if it went wrong? When in the purchase does their question come up?
Then place each role in a See-Think-Do-Care cluster for a typical stalled account. Remember that Do means asking for a sales conversation, and that the roles who never visit the website still decide. Finally choose content and a channel for each role at the stage its question arrives, and say who at Calloway would write it.
Task
- List every role in a typical committee for the sample-preparation system, including roles who never contact Calloway directly.
- For each role, write what they need to be true, what they fear and when their question appears.
- Place each role in a See-Think-Do-Care cluster for a typical account at quote stage.
- Choose the content and the channel that reaches each role, and name the Calloway author.
- Decide which two gaps to close first, using the sales notes, and say what Calloway should measure instead of quote requests alone.
Worked answer
Calloway Scientific: the committee map
| Role | Needs to be true | Fears | Cluster at quote stage | Content and channel | Author |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lab manager (champion) | Throughput rises and the team will use it | Backing a purchase that sits unused | Do | Demo at the lab; workflow comparison; peer lab visit, via sales and newsletter | Applications scientist |
| Bench scientists (users) | It is easy to load, clean and trust | Extra work and failed runs | Think | Short how-it-works videos; user guide preview, sent by the lab manager | Applications scientist |
| Finance lead (budget holder) | It pays back and fits the capital plan | Approving spend that cannot be justified | See | Payback calculator and a one-page business case, sent via the lab manager and at proposal | Sales lead with finance input |
| Procurement | The supplier is sound and the terms are standard | A supplier failure or non-compliant contract | Not yet visible | Supplier pack: company details, insurance, standard terms, questionnaire answers, on a supplier page | Operations manager |
| Quality manager | The system can be validated and calibrated for accreditation | An audit finding | Think | Validation and calibration guide; service plan detail, ungated | Service manager |
| Estates and safety | It fits, has the right power and is safe to install | Installation delays and safety incidents | Not yet visible | Installation requirements sheet | Service manager |
| IT | Data exports cleanly and the software is supported | Unsupported software on the network | See | Software and data integration note | Product manager |
Where it stalls. The sales notes point at the same place the map does: every stalled deal waited on a role that Calloway never addressed. Finance is the largest gap, followed by procurement and quality. Those roles do not read the newsletter and will not attend the show, so the content has to travel through the lab manager and the salesperson, and be ready before the quote is sent rather than written in response.
First two gaps. Build the finance pack first: a payback calculator and a business case template the lab manager can forward. Then build the supplier pack, so a procurement questionnaire is answered in days. Both are reusable on every deal and aimed at the most frequent stall reasons.
What to measure. Quote requests are a Do count, not the KPIA metric tied directly to an objective. that matters. Track quotes that reach a decision, time from quote to decision and the share of deals where the finance pack and supplier pack were sent. Over a longer period, read customer acquisition cost (CACCost to acquire one new customer.) per won deal, since shortening stalled deals lowers it without any new media spend. Read the FunnelModel of the customer journey stages. per account, not per contact.
Common mistakes
- Mapping job titles, not roles. One person may hold two roles; both sets of questions still need answers.
- Leaving out roles who never visit. Procurement and estates rarely contact a supplier, yet either can stop a deal.
- Writing late-stage content after the deal stalls. Supplier and validation material has to exist before the question is asked.
- Counting quote requests as success. A request that stalls for months is not a win.
Test yourself next in the checkpoint on business buying and buying committees, or return to the beginner business-to-business marketing level page.
