Brief
Ravensmere Building Society is an invented mutual with branches across its home region and a growing online savings business. At home it is trusted and well known; elsewhere almost nobody has heard of it, and its online savings accounts compete with national banks on comparison sites, where the cheapest way to win an account is the best rate that week. Most of the marketing budget goes to comparison sites and paid search. Branches run their own local promotions, some of them memorable for the wrong reasons.
The board has asked for proof before it funds brand work outside the home region. The marketing director needs a plan that sets the balance, says how it will be judged and when, and stops branch marketing from undermining the brand or breaching financial promotion rules. She has a small team, one compliance officer and a board that meets quarterly.
Inputs and constraints
Ravensmere Building Society: spend and outcomes last year
| Channel | Annual spend | Online savings accounts opened |
|---|---|---|
| Comparison sites, paid per account | £520,000 | 6,100 |
| Paid search, brand and generic savings terms | £380,000 | 3,300 |
| Paid social | £120,000 | 600 |
| Regional radio and press, home region only | £60,000 | Not tracked |
| Branch local promotions, run by each branch | £90,000 | Not tracked |
| Total | £1,170,000 | 11,200 including 1,200 direct |
Branded search index by half-year, home region: 100, 102, 101, 103. Rest of the country: 100, 96, 93, 90. Comparison-site cost per account rose from £72 to £85 over the same period.
Tracker, share of voice and branch examples
Brand tracker, two waves six months apart:
| Measure | Home region, wave one | Home region, wave two | Rest of country, wave one | Rest of country, wave two |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Unaided awareness among savers | 34% | 33% | 2% | 2% |
| Prompted awareness | 71% | 72% | 11% | 12% |
| Would consider for savings | 29% | 27% | 4% | 4% |
Samples: 500 savers at home and 1,000 elsewhere per wave.
Estimated paid share of voice among savings providers in the home region: Ravensmere 9%, a national bank 31%, a neighbouring building society 12%. Ravensmere holds about 14% of home-region savings balances.
- One branch printed "Best rates in town!" posters with no rate, date or basis.
- One branch sponsors a youth football club with the logo retired three years ago.
- One branch still displays a leaflet for a fixed-rate bond withdrawn last month.
Constraints: the total budget is flat in the first year, with up to a tenth more in the second if the board's review points are met. All promotions, including branch material, must be fair, clear and not misleading and must be approved by the compliance officer before use, with records kept. Branches keep their local relationships, and the society will not buy national television.
Task
Produce one plan with these sections, in order. Give a reason for every decision and say which input it rests on.
- Diagnosis. Read the inputs against the signs of a tipped balance in the brand versus performance guide. Separate the home region, where the brand exists, from the rest of the country, where it barely does, and say what the comparison-site cost trend means.
- Strategy and investment case. Confirm the positioning and audience with the brand strategy guide, then set the brand and performance split for each year and where the money comes from. Use the share of voice guide for the home region and the marketing budget calculator for the arithmetic. Say whether the brand should spread nationally or concentrate on a few regions it can afford to reach properly.
- Long-term measurement. Set the tracker design and cadence with the brand awareness and lift guide, branded search and comparison cost as lagged measures, a regional test design for the first brand flight, and the point at which a mix model (MMMStatistical model of channel impact.) becomes worth building, using the mix modelling basics guide. Define the board's review points and what result at each would change the plan.
- Reach and quality rules. Write the reach and FrequencyAverage times a person saw an ad. goal per flight for the chosen regions, how platform figures will be deduplicated following the cross-platform reach and frequency guide, and the inventory rules: measurability, viewability, brand safety for a financial brand and attention measures. Check the goals with the reach and frequency calculator and record them in the media plan template.
- Governance. Apply the element-by-element split from the standardisation and adaptation guide to branches and online products: what branches may adapt, what needs approval and what never changes, with templates, an approval turnaround and a route for exceptions. Brief creative with the creative brief template.
- Compliance and review. Build financial promotion approval into every workflow above, including branch material and comparison-site listings, check launches with the campaign launch QA checklist, and set dated reviews for rates, offers and live materials.
- Board summary. One page in the shape of the one-page marketing plan template: the decision asked for, the evidence it will be judged on and the review dates.
Evaluation criteria
| Criterion | What a strong answer shows | Common gap |
|---|---|---|
| Investment case | Sets a brand and performance balance with reasoning the board can test | Asks for brand budget without evidence |
| Long-term measurement | Combines tracking, branded search and mix modelling as data allows | Judges brand spend on last-click results |
| Reach and quality | Sets deduplicated reach, frequency and inventory quality rules | Buys the cheapest impressions available |
| Governance | Defines what branches may adapt, what needs approval and what never changes | Either locks everything centrally or leaves branches free |
| Compliance and review | Builds financial promotion rules and review dates into the plan | Leaves compliance to the end |
A strong plan treats the two geographies as two problems. At home the brand is known but quiet against its share of balances, so the case is about defending memory with Share of VoiceYour share of market visibility. closer to market share. Elsewhere the brand has almost no memory to defend, so every account is bought on rate through comparison sites, and the case is for building ReachUnique people who saw an ad. among savers in a small number of adjacent regions first, where a staggered launch also creates the regional comparison the board wants. It funds the brand line from the least efficient search and comparison spend, and it commits to review points rather than to a return figure. It treats the branch examples as a governance failure, not as bad behaviour: branches lacked templates, an approval route and a list of retired assets.
Reference figures for self-checking
- Cost per account: comparison sites about £85, paid search about £115, paid social about £200.
- Home-region share of voice 9% against 14% share of balances: about 5 points below.
- Rest-of-country branded search down 10% over the period while home-region search rose 3%.
- Brand activity is about 5% of total spend (£60,000 of £1,170,000), all in the home region.
- Tracker movements between waves sit within the noise for samples of this size.
Submission checklist
When you have finished, compare your investment case with the brand investment exercise for a mortgage broker and the brand investment checkpoint, your media rules with the cross-platform reach exercise for a cider brand and the reach and attention checkpoint, and your governance with the localisation exercise for a skincare brand. For the brand plan foundations this builds on, revisit the intermediate brand marketing level.
