Brief
Saltmere Coffee Roasters is an invented speciality roaster that sells coffee subscriptions online and supplies a growing number of cafés. It grew on paid social and a generous first-bag subscription offer. For several quarters its cost per new subscriber has risen, while café owners keep getting in touch without being asked, and a distributor has offered to take the coffee into a neighbouring country.
The owner wants one strategy for the year. It must pick a direction, fund that direction from evidence rather than habit, and say how the team will know by mid-year whether it is working. The team is the owner, a marketing manager and a part-time freelancer for content and social. There is no data analyst, and the owner has said she will not hire one this year.
The annual planning guide sets the frame: decisions placed at the rhythm where they belong, with the annual plan deciding direction, segments and the total, and the quarterly review correcting allocation and targets on evidence.
Inputs and constraints
Saltmere Coffee Roasters: channel response and retention
| Channel | Monthly spend | New subscribers | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Paid social | £8,000 | 320 | Comparable months, last year |
| Paid social | £12,000 | 420 | |
| Paid social (current) | £16,000 | 470 | |
| Paid search | £3,000 | 150 | Mostly brand and "coffee subscription" terms |
| Paid search (current) | £4,500 | 205 | No history above this level |
Affordable cost per new subscriber, agreed with finance from cohort retention and contribution: £45.
| Cohort | Still subscribed at month six |
|---|---|
| Joined in months when social spend was £8,000 to £12,000 | 52% |
| Joined in months when social spend was £16,000 | 38% |
Saltmere Coffee Roasters: wholesale, the distributor and the market
Wholesale: about 6 unprompted café enquiries a month, roughly 1 in 3 becoming an account; an account earns about £250 a month in contribution; no marketing spend on wholesale today; the marketing manager estimates a day a week would be needed to run a proper café programme.
Distributor offer: the distributor buys at wholesale price less 20%, sets shelf prices and presentation itself, and asks for a minimum first order worth about £30,000 of stock.
Category share of brand search for coffee subscriptions: Saltmere about 4% against an estimated subscription market share of about 3%; the two largest subscription brands about 30% and 22%.
Budget envelope for the year: £260,000 of marketing cost, including any test budget.
Constraints you must work within:
- No analyst, so every method must be one the marketing manager can run and explain.
- The budget envelope is fixed; any new direction is funded by moving money, not by adding it.
- The distributor wants an answer within the first quarter.
- The owner wants a mid-year verdict, so the measurement design must produce evidence within two quarters.
Task
- Make the growth choice. Compare at least three options, including the subscription channel as it stands, a café wholesale programme and the distributor offer. Score each on demand, competition, cost to serve and risk, with the evidence beside every score, using the method from the outdoor kit growth options exercise. Use share of voice (Share of VoiceYour share of market visibility.) as part of the competition score. Run two weightings, state the recommendation and the trade-offs the owner accepts.
- Build the budget on marginal returns. Calculate the marginal cost per new subscriber for each paid social step, following the marginal returns and forecasting guide and the tea merchant reallocation exercise. Adjust for the weaker retention of the cohorts bought at the highest spend: say what that does to the true cost of a retained subscriber. Split the envelope across channels and the chosen growth direction, with a test reserve and a stop rule for every line. Check the implied outcomes with the marketing budget calculator and the CPA calculator.
- Design the measurement. List the decisions the year will require and match each to a method, as in the sofa brand measurement exercise, using the decision table in the guide to choosing an attribution approach. Include one IncrementalityConversions caused by marketing. test on the largest paid line, attribution for within-channel choices, and simple trend reading for share of brand search and café enquiries. Say why a mix model is not on the list this year.
- Write the test agenda. Name the assumptions the strategy depends on, rank them by how badly the plan fails if they are wrong, and assign a test or a check to each, in quarter order. Write the first test up with the experiment hypothesis template, and keep the learning log described in the experimentation programme playbook.
- Set the rhythm. Lay out the year using the quarterly marketing planning playbook: the quarterly reviews with their decision points, the monthly reallocation rules, and an owner for every objective, channel and test. Name the mid-year verdict and the evidence it rests on.
- Fill the one-page plan. Summarise the strategy in the one-page marketing plan template, with no more than three objectives, each with a KPIA metric tied directly to an objective., a target and a date, and a risks and assumptions row that says what would change the plan.
Evaluation criteria
| Criterion | What a strong answer shows | Common gap |
|---|---|---|
| Growth choice | Compares the options on demand, cost and risk and states the trade-offs accepted | Picks the most exciting option without scoring the alternatives |
| Budget on marginal returns | Splits spend using marginal cost per order by channel, with a stop rule for each | Allocates on blended or average returns |
| Measurement design | Matches attribution, an incrementality test and simple trend reading to named decisions, within the team's capacity | Proposes mix modelling the data volume cannot support |
| Annual plan and rhythm | Sets quarterly corrections, owners and a test agenda tied to the strategy's riskiest assumptions | A calendar of activity with no decision points |
| Risks and assumptions | States what evidence would change the plan and when it will be reviewed | Treats forecasts as commitments |
A strong submission also notices what the averages hide. The top paid social step buys subscribers at a marginal cost above the affordable ceiling, and those subscribers also stay for less time, so the true cost of a retained subscriber at that level is worse again. Cutting back to where the marginal cost of a retained subscriber meets the ceiling frees money for whichever growth direction wins the scoring. A good answer says how the customer acquisition cost (CACCost to acquire one new customer.) target will be read for cafés, where the relevant cost is the time of the marketing manager as much as media.
The distributor offer deserves a direct answer inside the first quarter, even if the answer is "not this year". A strong plan states the conditions under which Saltmere would reconsider, using the pilot and gate logic from the market entry and prioritisation guide.
Submission checklist
When you have finished, compare your strategy with the evaluation table, then return to the intermediate digital marketing level if any channel role or KPI tree needs revisiting before you mark the level complete.
