Brief
Starling Lane Pet Foods is an invented maker of dog and cat food, profitable and well known in its home region. It sells through grocers, through its own website and through a subscription. Supermarket own labels are taking shelf space and price-conscious buyers, and grocery sales are slipping. The subscription is growing fast. A distributor abroad has offered a listing in pet shop chains. The marketing team grew one hire at a time around two agencies, and nobody owns the subscription numbers end to end.
The owners want a strategy that makes clear choices, says what the business will not do and gives the board measures to hold the team to. You are the incoming head of marketing.
Inputs and constraints
Sales, margins and the subscription
| Channel | Revenue last year | Change on prior year | Contribution margin before marketing |
|---|---|---|---|
| Grocers, home region | £9.8m | −4% | 28% |
| Grocers, two neighbouring regions | £4.2m | −1% | 28% |
| Own site, one-off orders | £2.2m | +6% | 45% |
| Subscription | £3.8m | +22% | 48% |
Subscription: 9,500 active subscribers; average monthly order £33, contribution £16; 70% still subscribed after three months and 48% after twelve; average paying months in the first year 7.5, so first-year contribution about £120 per new subscriber.
Spend, response and share of voice
| Line | Current annual spend | Marginal cost per new subscriber now | At the next £50,000 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Paid social | £300,000 | £70 | £95 |
| Paid search | £180,000 | £55 | £80 |
| Vet and breeder partnerships | £40,000 | £35 | £45 |
| Brand: regional radio and outdoor | £160,000 | Not measured | Not measured |
| Grocery trade promotion | £420,000 | Judged on grocer sales uplift | Not tested |
Agency fees £204,000 a year; content and tools £60,000. Total marketing about £1.36m.
Category advertising in Starling Lane's regions: about £6.0m a year, plausible range £4.5m to £7.5m. Its paid advertising (brand, social, search) is £640,000. Share of grocery pet food sales in the home region: 14%. Own labels advertise little and compete on price and shelf.
Team, agencies, the offer abroad and the ceiling
Team of seven: head of marketing, brand manager, social specialist, search specialist, trade marketing manager, content executive, customer relationship manager. The subscription's pricing and churn sit with an e-commerce manager in operations.
Media agency (£10,000 a month): radio, outdoor and paid social buying. Creative and digital agency (£7,000 a month): website, search, email design, and paid social creative, so two agencies touch social.
Distributor offer: listing in pet shop chains in Belgium; buys at 40% of retail; asks for £150,000 of marketing support over two years; wants exclusivity for the country.
Board ceiling: total marketing no more than £1.5m next year, then rising no faster than revenue; operating profit must not fall. One new hire is possible.
Task
Write one strategy document with these sections, in order, and give a reason for every choice.
- Strategic choices. Decide where Starling Lane competes over three years: which channels and regions lead, whether to accept the distributor, whether to take the subscription beyond the home regions, and what it will stop doing. Score the options with the weighted model from the market entry and prioritisation guide, run it under two weightings and say which choice is robust. Revisit the export markets exercise for the distributor terms.
- Budget. Build next year's total with objective-and-task and check it against percentage of revenue, the affordable figure and parity, as the guide to budgeting methods sets out. Divide it on marginal cost per new subscriber against first-year contribution, using the marginal returns and forecasting guide, and check the arithmetic with the marketing budget calculator. Present low, central and high scenarios with ranges and a cut menu, as in the veterinary group budget exercise. State the return on investment (ROIProfit relative to cost.) on contribution.
- Brand ambition. Calculate current Share of VoiceYour share of market visibility. and excess share of voice across the range, set a target for each year linked to the grocery share goal, cost it, and protect a brand share from short-term return reviews, following the share of voice guide.
- Operating model. Choose a team model from the team models and organisation design guide, decide where the subscription is owned and how the one hire is used, rewrite both agency scopes so no work overlaps, write a responsibility matrix for the contested decisions and set a two-way agency scorecard, as in the holiday park operating model exercise.
- Measures of progress. Build a KPI tree from operating profit to channel measures. Name each KPIA metric tied directly to an objective. on the board page, split into leading measures (share of voice, trial, cost per new subscriber, or CACCost to acquire one new customer.) and lagging ones (grocery share, subscriber numbers, contribution).
- Review. Set the annual strategy review and the quarterly cycle from the quarterly marketing planning playbook, placed in the rhythm the annual planning guide describes. For each strategic choice, write the evidence that would change it and the review at which that evidence is read.
- Board page. Summarise the strategy on the one-page marketing plan template.
Evaluation criteria
Assess your strategy against each row, or ask a peer to. A strong answer meets every row.
| Criterion | What a strong answer shows | Common gap |
|---|---|---|
| Strategic choices | Explicit market, segment and motion choices, scored under two weightings, with a written list of what the business will not do | Every option listed as a priority |
| Budget | A total set by combining methods, inside the ceiling or with the trade-off stated, allocated on marginal returns with ranges and a cut menu | A single method used without testing it |
| Brand ambition | Share of voice goals linked to the grocery share target, costed across the range, with long-term spend protected | Brand investment ignored or treated as optional |
| Operating model | Central, agency and shared roles assigned, the subscription given one owner, overlaps removed, a matrix and a scorecard | The organisation left unchanged |
| Progress and review | Leading and lagging measures and an annual review that can change the choices on stated evidence | The strategy treated as a fixed three-year plan |
Submission checklist
When you have finished, check that every choice has a review point and every budget line a stop rule. If the strategy changed how the team is organised as well as where the money goes, the level has done its job. Return to the intermediate marketing strategy level for the annual planning foundations this capstone builds on.
