Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Marketing Strategy › Advanced

Setting a Strategic Marketing Budget for a Veterinary Group

An invented group of veterinary practices has always budgeted marketing as a fixed share of revenue, and its finance director wants a cut just as two new practices open. You compare what each budgeting method produces, build and defend a total, divide it on marginal returns, show what each level of cut removes and use share of voice against local rivals to show what a cut would risk.
ExerciseAdvanced levelModule 2: Funding the strategy5 minUpdated

Why this matters

A budget set as a share of revenue cannot answer finance's next question: what would we lose if it were smaller? The guide to budgeting methods shows how to build a total bottom-up and check it top-down. The advanced skill is turning that total into a set of choices, so that a cut removes a named objective rather than shaving everything, and showing the brand cost that a short-term return review cannot see.

The group and its fixed percentage

Pawsley Veterinary Group is an invented group of six veterinary practices, with two more opening next year. Its marketing goal is new pet registrations. Marketing has been set at the same share of revenue for years. The finance director, funding two fit-outs, wants it cut.

Illustrative example — not a real result

Pawsley Veterinary Group: the inputs

Last year's revenue £9.0m; marketing at 2% = £180,000. Next year's revenue forecast £9.8m. The finance director proposes £150,000, the figure left after the fit-outs and the owners' profit target.

Objectives: 3,500 new registrations at the six existing practices; 500 at each new practice.

Spend-response at the existing practices, from comparable periods, registrations counted in the practice system:

ChannelAnnual spendRegistrations
Local paid search£30,000 / £45,000 / £60,0001,200 / 1,500 / 1,620
Paid social£20,000 / £35,000 / £50,000500 / 830 / 1,100
Puppy and kitten partnerships£10,000 / £20,000 / £30,000400 / 700 / 900

Ceiling on marginal cost per registration, agreed with finance: £60. Contribution per registered pet over three years: £180.

New practices: launch awareness £12,000 each; cost per registration about £50, from the group's last opening. Fixed costs (website, booking integration, design): £21,000. Reserve: 5% of the plan.

Estimated paid advertising by all vet groups in Pawsley's catchments: £1.5m a year, plausible range £1.2m to £1.9m. Pawsley's share of registered pets in those catchments: 12%. A corporate chain is already advertising in both new towns.

From budgeting method to defended total

Run every method and keep the answers side by side. Percentage of revenue and the affordable figure say what the habit and the cash allow; competitive parity says what holding position costs; objective-and-task says what the plan costs. Build the plan's acquisition line from marginal, not average, cost, as the marginal returns and forecasting guide explains. Then read Share of Voice against share of market, as the share of voice guide sets out, using the range, not the midpoint.

Task

  1. Work out the marginal cost of each spend step and the existing practices' acquisition budget under the ceiling.
  2. Build the objective-and-task total, and set it beside the percentage, affordable and parity figures.
  3. Check the return on the plan, and say what that check cannot tell you.
  4. Write a cut menu from the full plan down to the finance director's figure, naming what each level removes.
  5. Calculate share of voice at each level, read it against share of market, and state the risk of the cut.
  6. Recommend a total and write the argument for finance in a few sentences.

Worked answer

Illustrative example — not a real result

Pawsley: marginal costs, the plan and the menu

StepExtra spendExtra registrationsMarginal cost
Search second step£15,000300£50
Search third step£15,000120£125
Social second step£15,000330£45
Social third step£15,000270£56
Partnerships second step£10,000300£33
Partnerships third step£10,000200£50

Existing practices: search £45,000 + social £50,000 + partnerships £30,000 = £125,000 for 1,500 + 1,100 + 900 = 3,500 registrations. Search's third step is above the ceiling and is left out.

Plan: £125,000 + launch awareness £24,000 + new-practice acquisition 1,000 × £50 = £50,000 + fixed £21,000 = £220,000; reserve £11,000; total £231,000, about 2.4% of forecast revenue.

Methods side by side: percentage of last year's revenue £180,000; affordable £150,000; parity at 12% of £1.5m £180,000; objective-and-task £231,000.

Return: blended cost per registration (£125,000 + £24,000 + £50,000) ÷ 4,500 ≈ £44. Three-year contribution 4,500 × £180 = £810,000; return on the full budget (£810,000 − £231,000) ÷ £231,000 ≈ 2.5.

BudgetRemovedRegistrations lostShare of voice, central (range)
£231,000Nothing015.4% (12.2% to 19.3%)
£205,000Reserve; social third step27013.7% (10.8% to 17.1%)
£180,000Also search second step and partnerships third step77012.0% (9.5% to 15.0%)
£150,000Also the second new practice's awareness, half its acquisition and part of the fixed spend1,02010.0% (7.9% to 12.5%)

Methods. Habit and parity agree and the affordable figure sits below both; the plan sits above all three because it opens two practices in towns where Pawsley's share of market is nil and a rival is already loud.

Return. The plan clears the bar comfortably on paper, which is what return on investment (ROI) is for. It cannot show that every registration was caused by marketing: some pets would have registered anyway, so treat the figure as an upper bound and the marginal ceiling as the real discipline.

Cuts. Each level drops the worst marginal step first and leaves the ceiling intact. The finance director's figure falls on strategy, not efficiency: it delays one new practice's launch, which is a board decision, not a marketing trim.

Share of voice. At the habit figure Pawsley spends at its weight; at the finance director's figure it falls below it across most of the range. Negative excess share of voice erodes memory slowly, so the cost would arrive next year in a higher cost per customer (CAC), not in this year's report.

Recommendation. Fund the full plan, phased so new-practice money is spent around each opening, which eases the cash pressure behind the cut. If finance holds firm, the second level of the menu is the floor that keeps both launches; below it the board is choosing to delay a practice. Allocation then follows the budget allocation guide, with reallocation on evidence each quarter.

Common mistakes

  • Presenting one number. Finance trusts a total that arrives with its own cut menu.
  • Shaving every line. Equal cuts keep every channel and every objective, all of them weaker.
  • Funding search's last step. Its average is fine; its marginal cost is more than twice the ceiling.

Check your judgement in the strategic budget checkpoint, or revisit annual planning at the intermediate marketing strategy level.

Pages this lesson applies

Terms used on this page

Also related

Related