What this checkpoint covers
Crumbworth Bakery Supplies is an invented wholesaler of flour, ingredients and packaging to independent bakeries and cafés in one region, taking orders by phone and through a trade website. The questions draw on the guide to budgeting methods, the marginal returns and forecasting guide and the share of voice guide.
Task
- Write a decision and a reason for every question before scrolling on.
- Compare with the explanations; a right decision with a wrong reason counts as a miss.
- Reread the linked section for each miss, starting with confident ones.
Questions
- The managing director sets marketing as a share of revenue, the finance director wants what is affordable, and the sales director wants to match the largest rival. What does each method get right and wrong here, and which should build the number?
- The sales director's parity figure is based on the rival's national advertising, although Crumbworth serves one region. What is wrong with it?
- The objective-and-task total comes in above what finance can fund. The managing director proposes trimming every line by the same share. What do you do instead, and how is the smaller total then divided?
- Using the example below, what does the gap between share of voice and share of market suggest, and what do you check before asking for more money?
- The finance director asks what the budget will deliver. What do you bring?
- At the quarterly review, trade-press and trade-show activity shows no attributable orders while paid search shows a strong return. A colleague proposes moving all brand money into search. What do you say?
- Margins collapse after a flour price rise and the board asks for a deep cut. When is cutting the right call, and what evidence shows it?
Crumbworth Bakery Supplies: voice and market in its region
| Supplier | Share of market (trade customers' spend) | Share of voice (estimated trade advertising) |
|---|---|---|
| Crumbworth | 15% | 9% |
| Largest rival | 30% | 38% |
| Second rival | 10% | 14% |
| All others | 45% | 39% |
Category advertising estimate for the region: £800,000 a year, plausible range £600,000 to £1.0m. Crumbworth's current advertising: £72,000.
Answers explained
- Objective-and-task builds it; the others check it. Percentage of revenue is predictable but makes spend follow sales; affordable guarantees payment and nothing else; parity keeps the budget in line with the category but copies a rival's objectives. Cost the objectives, then use the other three as bounds and explain any gap. See combining the methods.
- The denominator. Parity and Share of VoiceYour share of market visibility. must use the category as Crumbworth competes in it: the rival's spend in this region, not its national total. A flattering or inflated denominator produces a budget for a different business. See what share of voice means.
- Drop objectives, then allocate on the margin. Even trims weaken everything. Remove the objective, or the spend step, with the worst marginal cost first, and divide what remains so the next pound in each channel earns about the same. See where spend should stop.
- Negative excess share of voice, read with care. At the central estimate Crumbworth's voice sits well below its share of market, which the published evidence associates with slow decline. Check that the category estimate is regional, read the gap across the range, and look at whether awareness among trade buyers is falling before claiming cause. See excess share of voice.
- Scenarios with ranges and a cut menu. Show outcomes for holding, a modest rise and a larger rise, each built from marginal costs that worsen with spend, the assumptions behind them and what each lower level removes. Report return on investment (ROIProfit relative to cost.) on contribution, not revenue. See forecasting from spend scenarios.
- Judge brand spend on its own evidence. Brand effects build over longer periods and appear later in cheaper acquisition, so a short attribution window will always favour search. Protect a brand share in the plan and track trade awareness and share of voice beside it. Moving it all would raise cost per customer (CACCost to acquire one new customer.) later. See presenting the budget.
- Cut where the marginal return is below target, and say what is lost. A cut is right when the last steps of spend cost more than they earn, or when cash survival outranks growth. Cut those steps first, forecast the loss at their marginal rate, and record that falling voice will cost memory later. See modest decrease scenarios.
Question four worked through
Crumbworth's share of voice: £72,000 ÷ £800,000 = 9%, so excess share of voice is 9% − 15% = −6 points. Across the range it is £72,000 ÷ £1.0m = 7.2% to £72,000 ÷ £600,000 = 12%, negative throughout. Spending at its weight at the central estimate would take 15% × £800,000 = £120,000. A learner scoring six or seven moves on; four or five rereads the sections behind the misses.
Where to go next
If you missed questions three or seven, redo the strategic budget exercise for a veterinary group. Otherwise move to organising delivery with the operating model exercise for a holiday park operator, and keep the intermediate marketing strategy level to hand.
