Why this matters
A business that grows by acquisition inherits every habit of every business it buys, and the cost shows up as duplicated spend, competing offers and arguments about credit. The team models and organisation design guide covers how to group people and write decision rights; the comparison of centralised and decentralised operations covers who owns the standards, tools and data. Here both arrive at once, with agencies in between.
The operator and its inherited set-up
Dunlin Holiday Parks is an invented operator of coastal holiday parks. It earns from holiday bookings and from selling holiday homes to owners, who then pay annual pitch fees. Bookings run through one central booking system; holiday home sales are handled by a sales team at each park.
Dunlin Holiday Parks: the inherited set-up
Nine parks, acquired over six years. Central marketing team of four: head of marketing, digital manager, content executive, customer relationship executive. Five parks have a part-time marketing coordinator; four rely on the general manager.
| Agency | Monthly fee | Scope as written | What it actually does |
|---|---|---|---|
| Performance agency | £8,000 | Paid search and paid social for bookings | Also bids on the group brand name |
| Creative agency | £6,000 | Brand campaign and creative | Has run paid social for the summer campaign since last year |
| PR agency | £4,500 | Group press office | Also manages social channels for three parks |
Symptoms from the last season:
- Two agencies ran paid social to overlapping audiences; their reported bookings added up to 1.6 times what the booking system recorded from paid social.
- One park ran a 30% discount on its own social channels while the group offer was 15%.
- One general manager opened his own search account and bid on the group brand name.
- Holiday home enquiries arrive at parks by email and phone; no one can say which campaigns produce owners.
- Review replies range from same-day and personal to none at all.
Central, local and agency roles
Decide by activity, not by a single verdict. Work loses value when it varies (brand, data, pricing rules, media buying, measurement) belongs at the centre; work loses value when it is standardised (local relationships, replies, events, the offer chosen from a menu) belongs at the parks; the guide to central and local control in multi-location marketing sets out that hybrid. Agencies take work that needs depth the team lacks, with one owner per scope. Write the interfaces as decisions with one accountable role each.
Task
- Choose a team model for head office and give the reason, including how holiday home sales fit.
- Split the work between head office, the parks and the agencies, activity by activity.
- Rewrite the agency scopes so no two agencies do the same job.
- Write a responsibility matrix for the decisions that cause the arguments.
- Set a two-way agency scorecard and the review rhythm.
Worked answer
Team model. Hub-and-spoke, with the hub as two small pods around outcomes: holiday bookings, and holiday home sales, a sales-led line with a long enquiry cycle. Brand, content, customer data and reporting sit across both pods as shared functions. The parks are the spokes. A channel model would recreate the credit disputes; a park-by-park model would duplicate skills nine times.
The split.
| Activity | Head office | Parks | Agencies |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brand, templates, claims | Owns | Uses templates | Creative builds assets |
| Offers and discount levels | Sets the menu with revenue management | Chooses from the menu | None |
| Paid media buying, including brand terms | Owns budget and accounts | Requests local pushes | Performance agency runs |
| Customer data, naming, reporting | Owns | Feeds local facts | Read access |
| Reviews, local social, community | Monitors and trains | Owns, within guidelines | None |
| Holiday home enquiries | Owns tracking and lead routing | Sales teams own follow-up | None |
Agency scopes. The performance agency keeps all paid media, including paid social and brand search: one buyer, one account structure. The creative agency keeps brand campaign and creative and hands back paid social. The PR agency keeps the press office; park social returns to the parks with templates and training. Close the general manager's search account and move its budget into the central one with a campaign for that park.
Responsibility matrix. One accountable role per row.
| Decision | Accountable | Responsible | Consulted | Informed |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Promotion calendar and discount levels | Head of marketing | Bookings pod | Revenue manager, park managers | Agencies |
| Approving a park offer outside the menu | Head of marketing | Park manager | Revenue manager | Bookings pod |
| Paid media budget by park and month | Head of marketing | Performance agency | Finance, park managers | Board |
| Holiday home lead definition and handover | Holiday home pod lead | Customer relationship executive | Park sales managers | Finance |
| Review reply standard | Park manager | Park coordinator | Content executive | Head of marketing |
| Reporting definitions | Digital manager | Content and data functions | Finance | Agencies, parks |
Scorecard and rhythm. Judge every agency on the same measures from the booking system and the customer relationship system, never on its own platform figures, and let the agencies score Dunlin's briefing, feedback and access in return, as the guide to selecting, briefing and reviewing agencies recommends. Weekly working sessions, a monthly performance review against each KPIA metric tied directly to an objective., a quarterly two-way scorecard and an annual scope review.
Dunlin's agency scorecard
| Criterion | Weight | Measure |
|---|---|---|
| Results against plan | 40% | Bookings and owner enquiries from the booking and customer systems; cost per booking against target |
| Quality of thinking | 20% | Tests proposed and learning shared |
| Execution | 15% | Accuracy, naming rules followed, deadlines |
| Responsiveness | 10% | Against agreed service levels |
| Value for money | 15% | Fees and media against return on investment for the scope |
Scored 1 to 5 by both sides each quarter; two quarters below 3 on results triggers an improvement plan, not an exit.
The scorecard rewards return on investment (ROIProfit relative to cost.) and cost per customer (CACCost to acquire one new customer.) measured the same way for every partner, so no agency gains by claiming another's bookings.
Common mistakes
- Centralising execution with the standards. Head office becomes a queue for every park post.
- Two accountable owners. Shared accountability for offers is how the conflicting discounts happened.
- Leaving holiday home sales outside the model. The most valuable customers end up with no marketing owner.
- Scoring agencies on their own dashboards. Overlapping claims make every agency look good.
Bring this operating model into the multi-year marketing strategy capstone, or revisit planning rhythms at the intermediate marketing strategy level.
