Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Digital Marketing › Planning & Budgeting

Marketing Budgeting Methods

Five ways to set a marketing budget (percentage of revenue, objective-and-task, parity, affordable, zero-based), when each fits and how to combine them.
Guideintermediate7 min readUpdated

Why the method matters

A budget set by habit (last year plus a little) cannot be defended when finance asks what it will deliver, and cannot be grown when the opportunity is larger than the habit. A budget set by method can be: it comes with the assumptions that produced it, so a challenge to the number becomes a discussion about assumptions. The method also decides what gets cut when money is tight — a budget built from objectives can show which objective is abandoned at each level of cut, which a percentage cannot.

Percentage of revenue

The budget is a fixed share of past or forecast revenue. Simple, predictable, and easy for finance to model. Its logic is backwards, though: it makes spending a consequence of sales rather than a cause, so a business whose sales fall cuts the marketing that would restore them, and a business growing fast under-invests relative to its opportunity. It also treats every pound of revenue as equally dependent on marketing, which is rarely true across product lines.

Fits: stable businesses with steady demand, as a planning ceiling; as a sanity check on other methods. Does not fit: launches, turnarounds, businesses where marketing drives most of the sale.

Affordable method

Spend what is left after other costs and the required profit. It guarantees the business can pay, and nothing else. Marketing becomes the residual, cut first and restored last, with no link to what the market offers.

Fits: businesses with hard cash constraints where survival outranks growth. Does not fit: any situation where marketing is the engine of revenue.

When the affordable sum is small, the guide to marketing on a small budget shows how to concentrate it on one segment and one paid channel and which owned channels cost time rather than money.

Competitive parity

Match competitors' spending, usually expressed as share of voice (Share of Voice) relative to share of market. The logic is that visibility relative to rivals drives share, which has some support in long-run brand research. The limits are practical: competitor spend is estimated, not known; their objectives, margins and efficiency differ from yours; and matching a rival who is wasting money wastes money.

Fits: mature categories where share of voice is a known driver and spend data is decent; as a check that a bottom-up budget is not wildly out of line. Does not fit: new categories, niche positions, businesses with a different model from their rivals.

Objective-and-task

Start from the objectives, list the tasks needed to achieve each, cost the tasks, and sum. For a direct-response objective the arithmetic is explicit: the target number of conversions multiplied by the expected cost per acquisition (CPA), plus a reserve for testing and for forecast error.

Budget = Target conversions × Expected CPA × (1 + reserve)

The marketing budget calculator implements this; the expected CPA comes from history, from the channel economics in the channel mix guide, or from the CPA calculator for a new channel. For awareness objectives the task is reach at a frequency, costed from exposure prices.

The method's strength is that every pound is attached to an outcome, so the budget can be defended, cut intelligently (by dropping objectives, not by shaving everything) and grown when the opportunity is shown. Its weakness is that it costs what the objectives need without asking whether the business can pay or whether the return justifies it — which is where the next checks come in.

Fits: almost every situation, as the primary method. Does not fit: businesses with no history and no way to estimate task costs, until a test provides them.

Zero-based budgeting

Every line starts from zero each period and must be justified again; nothing carries over because it existed. It is objective-and-task applied with discipline to the whole programme, including the always-on activity and the tools and people that habit protects. It is demanding — every item needs an owner and a justification — and valuable precisely for that reason: it surfaces the spend that no longer has a purpose.

Fits: periodic deep reviews (annually, or when strategy changes); organisations with budget drift. Does not fit: as a monthly process; the overhead outweighs the benefit.

Combining the methods

A defensible budget usually comes from one sequence:

  1. Build bottom-up with objective-and-task: what will the year's objectives cost, with a reserve?
  2. Check the return. Does the implied cost per acquisition sit below what a customer is worth (CAC against LTV, or ROAS against Break-even ROAS)? The break-even calculator and the ROAS calculator answer this per campaign; the marketing ROI page covers the programme view. If the return does not justify the spend, the objectives are wrong, not the budget.
  3. Check affordability. Can the business fund it, including the timing (peaks need cash before revenue arrives)? If not, cut objectives explicitly rather than trimming everything.
  4. Check parity and percentage as sanity bounds: is the figure wildly out of line with the category or with the business's own history? Out of line is not wrong, but it needs an explanation. The comparison of top-down and bottom-up budgeting covers what to do when the two figures disagree, and how to turn the gap into named choices rather than an equal trim.
  5. Record the assumptions. Expected CPA by channel, reserve size, conversion rates, seasonality. These are what will be reviewed when results arrive.
Illustrative example — not a real result

A subscription service's annual budget

The business wants a set number of new subscribers next year. From last year's data, the blended cost per new subscriber by channel is known, and the mix for next year shifts slightly toward the cheaper channels, giving an expected blended CPA. Target multiplied by expected CPA, plus a reserve for testing two new channels, gives the bottom-up media figure. The implied CAC is compared with the margin a subscriber generates over an average tenure; it sits below it, so the objective stands. Finance confirms the cash timing works if the peak-season spend is phased. The figure is a larger share of revenue than last year, which is explained by the growth target rather than treated as a problem. People and tool costs are listed separately so the loaded CAC is also known.

The methods compared on one case

Illustrative example — not a real result

Four methods, four answers

A regional retailer is deciding next year's budget. Percentage of revenue, at the share it has used for years, produces a figure slightly above last year's spend. The affordable method, after the owners set the profit they want, produces a figure below last year's. Competitive parity, from estimated share of voice against the two nearest rivals, suggests a figure well above last year's. Objective-and-task — the target number of new customers multiplied by the expected blended cost per customer, plus a reserve — lands between parity and percentage, and comes with the assumptions that produced it. The return check shows the implied cost per customer sits comfortably below what a customer is worth; the affordability check shows the figure is fundable if the peak-season spend is phased. The budget proposed is the objective-and-task figure, with the other three shown as context: above the percentage habit because the growth target is above the historical rate, below parity because the rivals' spend includes markets the retailer does not serve.

Presenting the budget

A budget is approved on its reasoning, so the proposal shows the chain: the business goal, the objectives and targets, the expected cost per result by channel with its source, the total with its reserve, the return it implies, the affordability and the phasing. It also shows what each level of cut would remove — the objective that is dropped at each reduction — so that a smaller budget is a smaller plan rather than a weaker one. Finance tends to trust a budget that arrives with its own sensitivity analysis more than one that arrives as a number.

From total to allocation

Setting the total is half the job. The budget allocation guide covers splitting it across channels by marginal return, and the campaign calendar covers phasing it over the year so peaks are funded before they arrive. Each campaign's share then appears in its brief.

Common mistakes

  • Last year plus a percentage. No link to objectives, no defence when challenged, no case for growth.
  • Media-only arithmetic presented as the full cost. Flatters efficiency until finance adds the people and tools back.
  • No reserve. Forecasts are wrong; a budget with no slack cannot learn or respond.
  • Cutting evenly. When money is short, dropping a whole objective preserves the others; shaving everything weakens all of them.
  • Setting the budget before the measurement. If results cannot be attributed, next year's expected CPA is a guess again. The measurement plan is part of the budget's justification.

For the cycle in which budgets are proposed, approved and revised, see annual and quarterly planning.

Frequently asked questions

What percentage of revenue should go to marketing?

There is no correct percentage. The share varies by industry, growth stage, margin and how much of the sale depends on marketing. Percentage-of-revenue is useful as a sanity check against a bottom-up budget, not as the method of setting it.

What is the difference between a budget and an allocation?

The budget is the total; the allocation is how it splits across channels, campaigns and months. This page covers setting the total. Budget allocation across channels covers the split.

Should the budget include people and tools?

Decide explicitly and state it. Media-only budgets flatter cost per acquisition; fully loaded budgets (media, agency, tools, people) give the true customer acquisition cost. Finance usually needs the loaded figure; media planning needs the media figure.

Terms used on this page

Tools to try

Frameworks

Where this page is used

Part of these learning paths

Related