Why this matters
The STP framework reads cleanly on the page: segment, then target, then position. Real notes are not: quotes overlap, analytics groups people by what is easy to count, and the loudest group is not always the one worth serving. Here you decide in order on untidy evidence.
Greenplate advertises a single message to a broad audience. Sign-ups look healthy at the top of the FunnelModel of the customer journey stages. and most subscribers leave within weeks: a message written for nobody attracts people the product does not suit, and the business keeps paying to replace them.
The research notes
The notes were gathered by the method in the audience research guide. Greenplate is invented.
Greenplate: who subscribes and who stays
Greenplate is a small meal-kit company delivering weekly boxes of recipes and pre-measured ingredients in England. Its current headline is "Fresh, easy dinners for everyone", run on broad paid social with a 50% first-box discount. Its marketing team is two people, and the kitchen can develop one new recipe range per quarter. Each box earns a contribution margin of 30% after ingredients, packing and delivery.
Last quarter's new sign-ups, grouped by the analyst:
| Group (analyst's label) | Share of new subscribers | Average boxes before cancelling | Cost to acquire one | Average box price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Families with young children | 22% | 19 | £48 | £62 |
| Under-30s learning to cook | 30% | 6 | £35 | £38 |
| People cooking to a health goal | 18% | 11 | £55 | £45 |
| First-box-only subscribers | 30% | 1.3 | £30 | £20 |
Interview and survey notes, in customers' words:
- Parents: "I need something the kids will actually eat on the table by half six." "Planning the week is the bit I hate, not the cooking." "We cancelled the other kit because half the recipes had chilli in them."
- Learners: "I wanted to learn a few dishes, and once I had, I didn't need the box."
- Health-goal cooks: "I count everything, so I need the portions to be exact." "The ready-meal services are easier."
- Cancellation survey, first-box-only group: the most common reason given was "only wanted the discount".
Competitors: national meal kits lead on variety and deep discounts; ready-meal services need no cooking.
Choosing a segment
First, notice that the analyst's groups mix bases: most are defined by need, the last by a behaviour that cuts across all of them. The segmentation guide asks what you would do differently for each group; sometimes the answer is a change to the offer, not a segment.
Second, the economics. A group that is cheap to win and quick to leave can still lose money. Estimate the lifetime value (LTVTotal value a customer brings over time.) of a subscriber in each group from the boxes they buy, the box price and the margin, and set it against the acquisition cost (CACCost to acquire one new customer.). Then weigh fit: what Greenplate can serve better than each group's alternatives.
Task
- Define the segments, each with a name, the defining need in customers' words, and how to find and reach members.
- Decide what the first-box-only group is, and what Greenplate should do about it.
- Estimate the value of a subscriber in each segment and compare it with the cost of acquiring one.
- Choose one segment to target, name the pattern, and say what happens to the others.
- Write a positioning statement for the chosen segment using every part of the template in the positioning statement framework.
- Run the substitution, recognition, evidence and exclusion tests and revise once.
Worked answer
Segments. The needs-based segments are weeknight family cooks (a reliable dinner children will eat, without planning), learning cooks (build skills, mostly at weekends) and portion-precise health cooks (exact quantities towards a goal).
The first-box-only group is not a segment. It is a behaviour produced by the offer: a deep discount attracts people who want the discount. The response is to change the offer, for example a smaller first-box discount, not to position for it.
Value against acquisition cost by segment
Lifetime value here is average boxes × average box price × 30% margin.
| Segment | Lifetime value | Cost to acquire | Value per pound of acquisition cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Weeknight family cooks | 19 × £62 × 0.30 = £353 | £48 | about £7.40 |
| Learning cooks | 6 × £38 × 0.30 = £68 | £35 | about £1.95 |
| Portion-precise health cooks | 11 × £45 × 0.30 = £149 | £55 | about £2.70 |
| First-box-only subscribers | 1.3 × £20 × 0.30 = £8 | £30 | about £0.26 |
The learning cooks lead the needs groups on sign-ups and trail them on value.
Targeting. Greenplate should run a concentrated pattern on weeknight family cooks. Their economics are the strongest, the need recurs weekly, and the national kits compete on variety, which is what parents complained about. A small team cannot serve several segments distinctly. Learning cooks get cheap content and a weekend recipe newsletter instead of paid acquisition. Health cooks are deferred: ready meals win on the effort they care about.
Positioning statement.
For working parents who dread planning weeknight dinners their children will eat, Greenplate is the meal kit that puts a family dinner on the table fast with no planning, because every recipe is tested with children and built around a fixed short cooking time. Unlike the large meal kits, which compete on variety, Greenplate keeps a smaller, child-tested menu so nothing in the box gets refused.
Tests. Substitution: a national competitor's name makes it false. Recognition: it repeats the parents' words. Evidence: child testing and cooking time can be shown on a landing page. Exclusion: it turns away learners and health cooks. An earlier draft said "quick, healthy family meals" and failed substitution.
Common mistakes
- Targeting the biggest group in the sign-up data. Volume at sign-up is not value; the learning cooks win on volume and lose on retention.
- Treating a behaviour created by the offer as a segment. Discount-only subscribers need a different offer design, not a position.
- Listing benefits. "Fast, healthy, varied and affordable" is a brochure. One benefit leads.
- Positioning against the wrong alternative. For family cooks it is the weekly shop as much as another kit.
Next, take the checkpoint on audience, segmentation and positioning and reread the positioning guide for how the statement reaches ads and pages. The intermediate level overview lists the module.
