Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

E-commerce Marketing › Intermediate

Raising Average Order Value for a Coffee Roaster

You choose which order value levers an invented coffee roaster should try, set a free delivery threshold from its basket distribution and work out how the change moves the break-even return its ads must reach. The exercise practises judging a lever on contribution rather than on the average basket, and resetting ad targets when the economics of an order change.
ExerciseIntermediate levelModule 2: Order value and unit economics5 minUpdated

Why this matters

Average order value (AOV) multiplies everything a store spends on traffic, which is why the average order value levers guide treats it as the quiet lever. But every lever changes the cost of an order as well as its size, which shifts the break-even line the break-even ROAS glossary entry defines. Ad targets set before the change can be wrong after it.

The roaster and its baskets

Hearthbean Roasters is an invented small roastery selling coffee in bags online, with a few brewing accessories. The owner wants larger baskets without discounting away the margin.

Illustrative example — not a real result

Hearthbean Roasters: catalogue, baskets and ads last quarter

Catalogue: single-origin bags at £9.50, house blend bags at £8.00, paper filters at £4, a brewing scale at £22 and a hand grinder at £38. Contribution margin on product revenue, after beans, roasting, packaging and payment fees, is 55% across the mix.

Delivery: the roastery pays £3.40 postage per order. Customers pay £3.95 below the free delivery threshold of £40. Delivery charges are not counted as revenue and roughly cover postage.

Basket valueShare of ordersTypical basket
Under £1030%One bag
£10 to £19.9941%Two bags
£20 to £29.9918%Three bags, or two bags and filters
£30 to £39.996%Bags and the scale
£40 and over5%Bags and the grinder

Average order value: £17.20. Ads (Shopping and Meta catalogue ads): £4,000 spend, £9,600 attributed product revenue, reported ROAS 2.4.

The team's ideas:

  • A. 20% off when a customer buys four bags.
  • B. Lower the free delivery threshold to £25 and add a basket progress bar.
  • C. A tasting trio of three single origins at £25, against £28.50 for the bags bought separately.
  • D. A pop-up in the checkout offering the hand grinder.
  • E. Filters and the scale shown beside the brewing guide on each bag's product page and below the basket lines.
  • F. A pay-in-instalments option at checkout.

Choosing the levers

Judge each idea on three questions: does it fit how this catalogue is bought, what does it cost in margin or conversion, and what does it do to the next order. Coffee is a replenishment product, so a lever that raises this basket and delays the next one can lower revenue per customer while the average looks better.

Task

  1. Sort the six ideas into try, try later and reject, with a reason for each.
  2. Choose a free delivery threshold from the basket distribution and explain why the average is the wrong guide.
  3. Calculate the break-even ROAS (Break-even ROAS) before the change, and after it under a stated assumption about the new threshold's effect.
  4. Say what happens to the ad target, and to the cost an order can bear, once the threshold changes.
  5. Outline the test that would confirm or reject the threshold, naming the primary metric and the guardrails.

Worked answer

Try now. The threshold (B) and curated cross-sells (E). Both are cheap, reversible and aimed at the two-bag cluster. Filters and the scale complete a purchase the customer is already making.

Try later. The tasting trio (C). Its saving is modest and the fit is real, which makes it a good first order for new customers, but launching it during the threshold test would blur the result.

Reject. The four-bag discount (A) gives away a fifth of the price and pulls the next order forward, breaking the replenishment cycle. The checkout pop-up (D) interrupts the payment step; the grinder belongs on the product page or after purchase. Instalments (F) solve a problem these baskets do not have.

The threshold. The average says nothing about where shoppers can reach. The distribution shows most orders are one or two bags and the current threshold is out of reach for almost everyone. A threshold just above the two-bag cluster lets those shoppers qualify by adding a third bag or filters.

Illustrative example — not a real result

Hearthbean: break-even before and after a £25 threshold

Before: contribution is 55% of revenue, so break-even ROAS is 1 ÷ 0.55 = 1.82. Each order can bear up to 0.55 × £17.20 = £9.46 of ad cost. Ad orders: £9,600 ÷ £17.20 = about 558. Profit after ads: £9,600 × 0.55 − £4,000 = £1,280.

Assumption to test, not a result: with a £25 threshold, 40% of orders reach it and average order value rises to £22.00, with conversion unchanged.

After: the roastery now pays postage on 40% of orders, £3.40 × 0.40 = £1.36 per order on average. Contribution per order = £22.00 × 0.55 − £1.36 = £10.74, which is 48.8% of revenue. Break-even ROAS = 1 ÷ 0.488 = 2.05. Each order can bear up to £10.74 of ad cost.

If the same spend brings the same 558 orders, revenue is about £12,280 and reported ROAS about 3.1. Profit after ads: 558 × £10.74 − £4,000 = about £1,990.

Sensitivity: the change still beats the old profit unless ad orders fall below (£1,280 + £4,000) ÷ £10.74 = about 492, a fall of about 12%.

The ad target. The break-even line rose because the roastery now carries postage it used to recover, so a return on ad spend (ROAS) target set from the old line is too loose. Reset it from the new contribution, and read the higher reported return as the larger basket, not better advertising.

The test. Follow the free shipping threshold test design: randomise by visitor across sessions, show each arm's threshold consistently and run whole weeks away from the Christmas gift period. Judge on contribution margin per visitor, with checkout conversion and complaints as guardrails. Hold other levers unchanged, then launch the tasting trio once the threshold is decided.

Common mistakes

  • Celebrating the higher average. It rises almost by definition; the store is better off only if contribution per visitor rises.
  • Leaving ad targets alone. A lever that moves postage or discount onto the store raises the break-even line, and the old target quietly turns loss-making.
  • Volume discounts on a replenishment product. Customers stock up and the next order arrives later.
  • Testing several levers at once. A bundle launched mid-test makes the threshold result unreadable.

Next, take the checkpoint on order value, margin and break-even ROAS, or return to the intermediate e-commerce level.

Pages this lesson applies

Terms used on this page

Also related

Related