Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

E-commerce Marketing › Advanced

Judging a Sale on Contribution Margin for a Homeware Store

An invented homeware store calls its last sale a success because revenue and return on ad spend both rose. You rebuild the result on contribution margin across the sale and the weeks after it, set the break-even return for discounted orders, separate genuinely new orders from discounted orders the store would have taken anyway, and decide whether the next sale should run and on what terms.
ExerciseAdvanced levelModule 1: Profit-based targets and promotions5 minUpdated

Why this matters

A sale changes the economics of every order it touches, including orders that would have arrived at full price anyway, and reports built on revenue and return on ad spend (ROAS) see only the extra volume. The contribution margin and break-even guide builds the margin; the ROAS calculator walkthrough for discount promotions shows why break-even rises as the price falls. Here you judge the sale over a window long enough to see what it borrowed.

The store and its last sale

Wynnstow Home is an invented online homeware store. Twice a year it runs a sitewide sale, doubles its paid budget for the sale fortnight and celebrates the result. The founder asks whether the next one should go ahead.

Illustrative example — not a real result

Wynnstow Home: order economics and the last sale

Per orderFull priceSale (25% off)
Basket at full price£80£88
Price paid, excluding VAT£80£66
Cost of goods (35% of full price)£28.00£30.80
Packing and delivery£8.00£8.00
Payment fees (2% of price paid)£1.60£1.32
Expected cost of returns£4.00£7.00
FortnightStore orders, all channelsFirst-time customersPaid spendAttributed ordersAttributed revenue
Typical full-price fortnight1,400500£12,000560£44,800
Sale fortnight3,0001,050£24,0001,500£99,000
First fortnight after1,000410£12,000400£32,000
Second fortnight after1,320480£12,000530£42,400
  • The same sale a year earlier, at the same discount, spent £16,000 and recorded 1,300 attributed orders.
  • Last year's sale customers placed 0.3 further full-price orders each within twelve months.
  • The founder wants £5 of contribution kept as profit on every order after ad cost.

From revenue to contribution margin

Work per order first. Contribution margin before marketing is the price paid less cost of goods, delivery, fees and expected returns, and it is the only pool ad spend can come from. The sale basket is bigger at full price yet smaller in cash, so average order value (AOV) falls while the store ships more goods.

Then judge the period, not the fortnight. The sale's orders hold three groups: orders the store would have taken at full price anyway, now discounted; orders pulled forward from the weeks after; and genuinely extra orders. Only the last group earns anything. A typical full-price fortnight is the baseline for all three.

Task

  1. Calculate contribution per order and the break-even return at full and sale prices.
  2. Set a target return for discounted orders that keeps the founder's profit per order.
  3. Estimate the orders pulled forward and the genuinely extra orders.
  4. Compare six weeks of contribution after ad cost with and without the sale.
  5. Check whether the extra sale budget paid at the margin.
  6. Decide whether the next sale should run, and on what terms.

Worked answer

Illustrative example — not a real result

Wynnstow Home: the sale rebuilt on contribution margin

Contribution per order. Full price: £80 − £28 − £8 − £1.60 − £4 = £38.40, which is 48% of the price. Sale: £66 − £30.80 − £8 − £1.32 − £7 = £18.88, which is 28.6% of the price paid.

Break-even return. Full price: 1 ÷ 0.48 ≈ 2.1. Sale: 1 ÷ 0.286 ≈ 3.5. The calculator page's shortcut, (0.48 − 0.25) ÷ (1 − 0.25) ≈ 30.7%, gives about 3.3; the fuller rebuild is higher because sale returns cost more. Target for sale orders with £5 kept: £66 ÷ (£18.88 − £5) ≈ 4.8.

Reported return. Typical fortnight £44,800 ÷ £12,000 ≈ 3.7; sale £99,000 ÷ £24,000 ≈ 4.1. The sale clears its break-even of 3.5 on attributed orders and misses its target of 4.8.

Orders. Shortfall after the sale: (1,400 − 1,000) + (1,400 − 1,320) = 480 pulled forward. Genuinely extra: 3,000 − 1,400 − 480 = 1,120.

Six weeks, contribution after ad cost. With the sale: (3,000 × £18.88 − £24,000) + (1,000 × £38.40 − £12,000) + (1,320 × £38.40 − £12,000) = £32,640 + £26,400 + £38,688 = £97,728. Without it: 3 × (1,400 × £38.40 − £12,000) = 3 × £41,760 = £125,280. The sale cost £27,552 of contribution.

Check by component: extra orders 1,120 × £18.88 ≈ £21,146; discount on baseline orders 1,400 × £19.52 ≈ £27,328; on pulled-forward orders 480 × £19.52 ≈ £9,370; extra spend £12,000. Net −£27,552.

Future value of the extra new customers: (1,050 − 500) × 0.3 × £38.40 ≈ £6,336, leaving the sale about £21,000 short.

Marginal budget: last year £16,000 bought 1,300 attributed orders; this year £24,000 bought 1,500. The extra £8,000 bought 200 attributed orders, about £40 each, against £18.88 of contribution per sale order.

What the numbers say. The sale looked healthy on the measure the team watched and lost money on the one the business lives on. Most of the damage is the discount handed to customers who were coming anyway, which no ad report shows. The new customers recover less than a third of the loss. The extra budget ran well past the point where the marginal returns and forecasting guide would stop it: each extra attributed order cost about twice its contribution, and attributed orders overstate caused ones.

Recommendation. Do not repeat the sitewide sale at this depth. If the founder wants an event, write its terms first:

  • Limit it to overstocked and seasonal lines, where the full-price baseline is low.
  • Set the depth so sale contribution stays above the founder's profit per order, and bid to the sale's own break-even and target, not the everyday ones.
  • Keep the budget near last year's level unless a budget step shows the extra spend clears the sale target.
  • Prefer value-led offers from the average order value levers guide, such as a bundle or a delivery threshold, which do not discount every order.
  • Judge the event on six weeks of contribution after ad cost against the baseline, including the pulled-forward check.

Common mistakes

  • Judging the sale fortnight alone. The dip afterwards is part of the result.
  • Counting every sale order as extra. Baseline orders pay the full discount and add nothing.
  • Bidding to the everyday break-even. The bar rises with the discount.
  • Doubling the budget on the average return. The last pound bought far less than the first.

Next, take the profit targets and promotions checkpoint or revisit the intermediate e-commerce level.

Pages this lesson applies

Terms used on this page

Also related

Related