What this checkpoint covers
Lurehatch Tackle is an invented online tackle shop whose Shopping ads run against a single return on ad spend (ROASRevenue generated per unit of ad spend.) target. The questions draw on the contribution margin and break-even guide, the marginal returns and forecasting guide and the ROAS calculator walkthrough for discount promotions.
Illustrative example — not a real result
Lurehatch Tackle: the figures behind the questions
- Shopping runs one target ROAS of 4.0 across the range.
- Contribution margin before marketing: rods 40%, reels 33%, bait and terminal tackle 18%; blended about 30%.
- A typical reel order: £120 net, cost of goods £66, delivery £7, payment fees £2, expected returns £5. Finance reports the reel gross margin as 45%.
- Spring sale: 20% off reels for a fortnight, with the 4.0 target left in place.
- Budget step last autumn: £6,000 a month bought £30,000 of attributed revenue; £9,000 in a similar month bought £39,000.
- The founder wants 8 points of revenue kept as profit after ad cost.
Task
- Write an answer and a one-line reason for each question, working the arithmetic from the figures above.
- Count an answer as right only if the reason matches, and reread the linked guide for every miss.
Questions
- Over the winter, Shopping revenue grew at target return, mostly from bait and terminal tackle, and profit fell. How?
- Using finance's gross margin, the agency puts the reel break-even at a little over two. What is the right figure, and why is theirs wrong?
- The founder asks for one target per range. What should each be, and how would you build them into the account?
- During the spring sale the reel campaign reports a return of exactly four. The team calls it on target. Is it?
- After the reel sale, reel orders fell well below the same weeks last year while rod orders held level. The team blames the weather. How would you test that?
- The budget step raised average return above target, so the agency proposes a further step of the same size. What do you recommend?
- The agency wants to bid reels exactly at break-even to win share. What is the risk, and when could a lower target be justified?
Answers explained
Illustrative example — not a real result
Lurehatch Tackle: the arithmetic behind the answers
- Bait break-even: 1 ÷ 0.18 ≈ 5.6. At 4.0, ads cost 25% of revenue against 18% contribution: about £7 lost per £100 of bait revenue.
- Reel contribution: £120 − £66 − £7 − £2 − £5 = £40, or 33% of revenue; break-even 1 ÷ 0.33 ≈ 3.0. On gross margin, 1 ÷ 0.45 ≈ 2.2.
- Targets with 8 points kept: rods 1 ÷ 0.32 ≈ 3.1; reels 1 ÷ 0.253 ≈ 4.0; bait 1 ÷ 0.10 = 10.
- Reels in the sale: (0.333 − 0.20) ÷ (1 − 0.20) ≈ 16.7% margin, break-even ≈ 6.0. At 4.0, £100 of sale revenue earns about £16.70 and costs £25 of ads.
- Budget step: extra £3,000 bought £9,000, a marginal return of 3.0 against a blended break-even of 1 ÷ 0.30 ≈ 3.3, so about £2,700 of contribution for £3,000 of spend.
- The target rewarded the range that loses. A revenue target treats every pound alike, and bait cannot cover its ad cost at that return, so contribution after ads fell as revenue rose. See why revenue is not profit.
- About three, not two. Gross margin ignores delivery, fees and returns, so a target built on it approves orders that lose money. See from gross margin to contribution margin.
- Rods a little above three, reels about four, bait about ten. Put a margin label in the feed and split campaigns by target, not category. Bait may not justify ads beyond its place in larger baskets, so check its average order value (AOVAverage revenue per order.) before giving it a campaign that cannot gather enough orders. See margin by product, segment and channel.
- No. The discount raised the sale's break-even return (Break-even ROASMinimum ROAS to avoid a loss.) to about six, so four is a loss on every attributed order. See interpreting ROAS during a promotion.
- Compare against a control. Rods are an unpromoted range in the same weather, and last year gives a seasonal baseline. If reels dipped while rods held, the sale borrowed demand; count the shortfall as a cost of the sale and judge the next one over a longer window. See what the calculator cannot see.
- Do not take the next step. The average looks fine, but the last step returned less than break-even and the next will usually do worse. Settle between the two levels and move spare budget to a range with room. See where spend should stop.
- Break-even leaves no room for error. Attributed revenue overstates what ads caused, so break-even on paper is usually a loss. A lower first-order target needs evidence that reel buyers return, and a payback finance accepts. See targets above break-even.
Where to go next
If the promotion questions caught you out, redo the homeware store sale exercise. The catalogue segmentation exercise for a sports nutrition store puts per-range targets into campaign structure, and the intermediate e-commerce level covers the foundations.
