Why this matters
A campaign can only treat products differently if the feed lets it tell them apart. The shopping and catalogue ads guide explains why one store-wide target subsidises thin-margin products with fat-margin ones, and the product feeds guide shows how custom labels carry the facts a campaign needs. Here you decide which facts matter, turn them into labels and pick a campaign type per segment with the Performance Max versus Standard Shopping comparison.
The store and its catalogue
Spokewright Cycle Parts is an invented online retailer selling own-brand consumables alongside branded drivetrain parts, wheels and tyres. Its feed is clean on the basics: identifiers, categories and product types are filled and disapprovals are rare. It has no custom labels, so its single Standard Shopping campaign bids on everything as one product group against one target return on ad spend (ROASRevenue generated per unit of ad spend.). Conversion tracking records real order values and has been verified, and the store has good packshots and a few workshop videos.
Spokewright Cycle Parts: last quarter by product line
Margin is gross margin after product cost, delivery, payment fees and expected returns.
| Product line | Products | Typical price | Margin | Orders | Shopping spend | Shopping revenue | Reported ROAS |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Own-brand inner tubes | 40 | £8 | 62% | 2,400 | £1,100 | £3,900 | 3.5 |
| Own-brand brake pads | 60 | £14 | 55% | 1,900 | £900 | £5,200 | 5.8 |
| Own-brand tools and workshop kit | 45 | £32 | 48% | 500 | £700 | £3,100 | 4.4 |
| Own-brand lights (launched last month) | 20 | £55 | 50% | 40 | £300 | £1,100 | 3.7 |
| Branded tyres | 150 | £38 | 30% | 1,100 | £2,500 | £11,000 | 4.4 |
| Branded wheels | 70 | £260 | 26% | 140 | £2,600 | £12,400 | 4.8 |
| Branded chains and cassettes | 180 | £45 | 22% | 1,300 | £4,200 | £17,600 | 4.2 |
| Branded groupsets | 25 | £420 | 14% | 60 | £3,000 | £9,800 | 3.3 |
| Clearance (discontinued models) | 300 | £20 | 9% | 200 | £1,000 | £3,600 | 3.6 |
| Products with no sales last quarter | 1,800 | mixed | about 35% | 0 from ads | £1,600 | £900 | 0.6 |
Total Shopping spend £17,900, revenue £68,600, blended ROAS 3.8 against a store-wide target of 4.0. Brake pads lose most eligible impressions to rank, not budget. The owner wants each segment to clear its own floor plus a profit of about 5% of revenue.
Choosing the segments
Start from the decisions the campaigns must make. Margin decides the target, so it is the first label. Sales history decides whether a segment has enough conversions for automated bidding, and separates proven lines from new launches and dead stock. Price tier matters because cheap and expensive items can cost the same per click while earning very different amounts. Stock status isolates clearance. Keep each label to a few documented values, populated from the stock and order systems rather than by hand.
Task
- Work out the break-even ROAS (Break-even ROASMinimum ROAS to avoid a loss.) for each product line from its margin, then mark which lines clear it today and which do not.
- Define the custom labels you would add, with their values, the rule that sets each value and the system it comes from.
- Group the product lines into campaign segments and set a target return for each, using break-even plus the owner's required profit.
- Choose Performance Max, Standard Shopping or no advertising for each segment, and give the reason from the comparison page.
- Explain how the segments avoid competing for the same products, and what you would read first.
Worked answer
Spokewright: break-even, targets and segments
Break-even is 1 ÷ margin. Target is 1 ÷ (margin − 0.05).
| Line | Break-even | Reported | Clears it? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Inner tubes | 1.6 | 3.5 | Yes, comfortably |
| Brake pads | 1.8 | 5.8 | Yes, and held back |
| Tools and kit | 2.1 | 4.4 | Yes |
| Lights | 2.0 | 3.7 | Yes, on little data |
| Tyres | 3.3 | 4.4 | Yes |
| Wheels | 3.8 | 4.8 | Yes |
| Chains and cassettes | 4.5 | 4.2 | No |
| Groupsets | 7.1 | 3.3 | No, by a wide margin |
| Clearance | 11.1 | 3.6 | No |
| No-sales products | 2.9 | 0.6 | No |
Labels:
- Margin band: high (45%+), mid (25% to 44%), low (under 25%), from the stock system's cost price.
- Sales velocity: best-seller, steady, new (listed within 60 days), no sales (none in 90 days), from orders.
- Price tier: under £15, £15 to £100, over £100.
- Stock status: core or clearance, from the buying team's discontinued flag.
Segments and targets:
- High margin (tubes, pads, tools): blended margin about 56%, target about 2.0. Performance Max.
- New launches (lights): target 2.2, own Standard Shopping campaign with a fixed budget until it has history.
- Mid margin (tyres, wheels): blended margin about 28%, target about 4.3. Standard Shopping.
- Low-margin best-sellers (top chains and cassettes): target about 5.9. Standard Shopping; rest of band excluded.
- Groupsets, clearance and no-sales products: no paid shopping this quarter. Clearance goes to email.
The £5,600 spent last quarter on groupsets, clearance and no-sales products is freed for the high band.
Why Performance Max for the high band. It has the most conversions, the widest room above break-even and strong inputs. Its Impression ShareShare of eligible impressions you received. lost to rank shows the store-wide target has been holding it back; a target from its own margin lets it bid for volume it can afford.
Why Standard Shopping for the rest. Mid and low bands have thin room above break-even, so the store needs search term reports and negatives to cut unprofitable queries. The new lights need the same visibility while they build history.
Keeping segments apart. Performance Max takes priority over Standard Shopping on shared products, so its listing groups hold only high-margin core products and each Standard Shopping campaign filters on labels the high band excludes.
The first month. Read profit after ad spend by margin band, impression share on the high band and whether the low-margin best-sellers clear their target. Check label values against the stock system after the first price changes.
Common mistakes
- Segmenting by category. Chains and tyres are both wear parts, yet their margins need different targets; split by what changes the decision.
- Rewarding revenue. Chains and cassettes earned the most Shopping revenue and still lost money.
- Overlapping campaigns. A product in both campaign types serves from Performance Max, so the Standard campaign's bids never run.
- Hand-keyed labels. Margin bands typed into a spreadsheet go stale at the next price change, and every campaign built on them drifts.
Next, take the feeds and shopping checkpoint or return to the intermediate e-commerce level.
