Brief
Coastline Holiday Lets is an invented agency that markets holiday cottages along one stretch of coast on behalf of their owners. Guests book and pay on its website; the agency keeps a commission on each booking and passes the rest to the owner, so its margin is the commission, not the booking value. Most bookings for the summer are made in the first months of the year, and that booking season starts soon.
The owner inherited the account from a freelancer who has left. There are no notes. The owner's questions are simple: is the account working, what should change first, and can it take more bookings without a bigger budget?
Constraints:
- One part-time marketer runs the account; a web developer is available for a few days a month.
- The total monthly budget stays where it is for the first month; money may move between campaigns.
- Nothing may break the booking flow during the season, so risky changes need a plan and a check.
The account and its data
Everything below comes from the account, the booking system and the owner, for a closed period long enough to cover the longest conversion window.
Coastline Holiday Lets: economics and conversion actions
Commission: 20% of booking value. The owner wants to keep at least 8 percentage points of booking value as profit after ad cost. Average booking value: £1,150.
| Conversion action | Source | Counting | Value | Primary |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Booking confirmed | Google Ads tag on the confirmation page | One | Booking value | Yes |
| Booking page view | Google Ads tag on the booking form page | Every | None | Yes |
| Enquiry form | Google Ads tag | One | None | Yes |
| Enquiry form (imported) | Google Analytics key event | One | None | Yes |
Booking system for the period: 410 bookings from all channels, £471,500 in booking value.
Coastline Holiday Lets: campaigns over the period
| Campaign | Set-up | Bid strategy | Spend | Conversions column | Bookings confirmed | Booking value | ROAS on bookings | Search lost IS (budget) | Search lost IS (rank) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Search – All | Brand and generic keywords together, phrase and broad match, Display Network opted in | Target CPA £18 | £16,200 | 1,480 | 120 | £138,000 | 852% | 0% | 48% |
| PMax – Cottages | Full asset groups, no brand exclusion, final URL expansion on with no exclusions | Target ROAS 900% | £8,100 | 96 | 96 | £110,400 | 1,363% | n/a | n/a |
| Search – Dog-friendly | Phrase match, own landing page | Maximise clicks | £2,700 | 22 | 22 | £24,200 | 896% | 41% | 12% |
| Display – Remarketing | Booking-page visitors, manual CPC | Manual CPC | £2,400 | 4 (plus 27 view-through) | 4 | £4,600 | 192% | n/a | n/a |
Further evidence:
- Search – All: brand keywords spent £1,100 and produced 70 of its 120 bookings; generic keywords spent £15,100 for 50 bookings. The Display Network took £1,900 of its spend for 1 booking.
- Search terms: about £2,300 went on job, caravan, camping and other-region queries.
- Quality Score on the highest-spend generic keywords is mostly 3 or 4, with landing page experience below average; every generic ad group sends traffic to the homepage.
- Location targeting on all campaigns: presence in the agency's own county only.
- PMax search terms insights: the largest search category is the agency's brand name.
- Change history: the target CPA on Search – All changed six times in the period, with no notes.
Task
Produce one document with the sections below, in this order. Use the site's tools and templates as named; do not invent uplifts, and state expected effects as direction with a way to check them.
- Score the account. Rate every row of the Google Ads account audit scorecard, gates first, and give the band. Use the Google Ads account audit checklist to gather the evidence for each row, and record anything you cannot see as missing evidence.
- Write the measurement verdict. Name every conversion fault, its effect on the reported figures and on Smart Bidding, and the fix. Check the corrected Google Ads bookings against the booking system using the method from the Google Ads and Google Analytics comparison, and say how the analytics import should be set following the integration tutorial.
- Derive the targets. Calculate the break-even and target ROASRevenue generated per unit of ad spend. from the commission with the break-even calculator and the ROAS calculator. Then split Search – All into its brand and generic parts and judge each against them.
- Fill the findings sheet. Use the scoring columns from the Google Ads audit walkthrough: finding, evidence, affected spend, impact, effort, type and verification. Order by priority with measurement first.
- Propose the structure. Say which campaigns to keep, split, merge or stop, and why each split serves a control need. Cover brand, generic themes, Performance Max exclusions and URL expansion, and the remarketing campaign.
- Plan keywords and negatives. List the negative themes, the location change and the landing page changes the developer should make, ordered by spend affected.
- Write the bidding plan. For each campaign in the new structure, give the strategy, the starting target, the steps towards the economic target and the budget, keeping the total unchanged.
- Schedule the first month. Lay out week by week what changes, in what order, and what is checked before the next change, using the cadence and decision log from the paid search account management playbook. Name the first entries of the decision log.
Evaluation criteria
| Criterion | What a strong answer shows | Common gap |
|---|---|---|
| Measurement first | Both conversion faults found and fixed before any performance verdict; the scorecard band reflects the failed gate | Judging the target CPA before noticing it optimises page views |
| Reconciliation | Corrected bookings checked against the booking system, with the remaining difference explained by cause | Treating the Conversions column as bookings |
| Economics | Break-even and target derived from commission, not booking value; brand and generic judged separately | Concluding Search – All is profitable from its blended return |
| Prioritisation | Findings ordered by spend affected and effort, each with evidence and a verification step | A long list of equal-weight findings |
| Structure | Splits justified by targets, budgets or control needs; brand excluded from Performance Max | Splitting by every cottage type for reporting |
| Keywords and pages | Negatives, location and landing page fixes tied to the low Quality ScoreGoogle's 1–10 keyword diagnostic. evidence | Adding negatives but leaving every ad on the homepage |
| Bidding | Strategy per campaign, targets moved in steps, one change at a time, total budget held | Setting the economic target everywhere on day one |
| Budget use | Money moved towards the campaign that is profitable and losing Impression ShareShare of eligible impressions you received. to budget | Raising budgets on campaigns limited by rank |
| First month | A dated sequence with checks between changes and a decision log | Every change scheduled for the first week |
| Communication | A summary the owner can read in a few minutes, with expected effects as direction | Invented percentage uplifts |
To check your arithmetic, the key figures are below. Work them out yourself first.
Reference figures for self-checking
- Break-even ROAS: 1 ÷ 0.20 = 500%. Target ROAS: 1 ÷ (0.20 − 0.08) = 833%.
- Brand within Search – All: 70 × £1,150 = £80,500 from £1,100 of spend, about 7,300%.
- Generic within Search – All: 50 × £1,150 = £57,500 from £15,100 of spend, about 381%, below break-even.
- Display – Remarketing on click-through bookings: 192%, below break-even.
- Search – Dog-friendly: 896%, above target and losing 41% of impression share to budget.
- Reported cost per conversion on Search – All: £16,200 ÷ 1,480 ≈ £10.95; cost per confirmed booking: £16,200 ÷ 120 = £135.
- Google Ads confirmed bookings across campaigns: 120 + 96 + 22 + 4 = 242 of the 410 in the booking system, a plausible share once other channels are allowed for.
A strong plan will read the Performance Max return with caution, because brand searches inflate it until the brand exclusion is in place, and will treat the target CPACost of each conversion. on Search – All as meaningless until page views stop counting as primary conversions.
Submission checklist
When you have finished, compare your plan with the reconciliation exercise for an accountancy firm and the bid strategy exercise, which practise two of its parts in isolation, and return to the intermediate Google Ads level to mark the level complete.
