Why this matters
An account that bids towards form fills buys the cheapest form fills, and with a long sales process those are rarely the ones that pay. The fix is a better signal, not a better strategy. The guide to connecting a CRM to ads and analytics covers how outcomes travel back, and the comparison of target CPA and target ROAS explains why a return target only works once values mean something.
The installer and its lead pipeline
Sunvale Solar Fitters is an invented installer of solar panels, batteries and car chargers. A web form creates the lead, a coordinator books a home survey, the surveyor recommends a system and the customer accepts or rejects the quote. The CRM records every stage. Three search campaigns run under a target CPACost of each conversion. on the form enquiry, the only primary conversion.
Sunvale Solar Fitters: paid search pipeline over one closed quarter
| Stage | Count | Typical time after the click |
|---|---|---|
| Form enquiry | 900 | Same day |
| Survey booked | 360 | Within a week |
| Survey completed | 300 | One to three weeks |
| Quote accepted (sale) | 90 | Three to six weeks |
| System recommended | Surveys completed | Sales | Margin per sale |
|---|---|---|---|
| Panels only | 130 | 45 | £1,600 |
| Panels and battery | 110 | 32 | £3,200 |
| Panels, battery and charger | 60 | 13 | £5,000 |
| Campaign | Spend | Enquiries | Cost per enquiry | Surveys completed | Sales | Margin from sales |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Solar panels | £30,000 | 520 | £58 | 150 | 44 | £96,800 |
| Solar batteries | £18,000 | 200 | £90 | 120 | 40 | £129,000 |
| Solar grants | £6,000 | 180 | £33 | 30 | 6 | £13,600 |
The owner will spend up to a third of a sale's margin to win it, so the floor for a return measured on margin values is 300%. The CRM stores the click identifier from a hidden field; nothing has been uploaded yet. A maintenance plan sold after installation is not in these figures.
From lead stages to conversion values
A stage's value is the margin of the sale it leads to multiplied by the chance that a lead at that stage becomes a sale. Use margin, not revenue, so bidding chases what the business keeps. Bid on the latest stage that still arrives soon and often enough to learn from, and let its value vary wherever the stage reveals something about the likely sale.
Only one stage should be primary; the rest are secondary, so one lead is not counted several times with stacked values. Stages can be matched by the stored click identifier or by hashed email through enhanced conversions for leads.
Task
- Value each stage, and value a completed survey by recommended system.
- Recalculate each campaign's return on margin and compare the ranking with cost per enquiry.
- Choose the primary stage and say what happens to the others.
- Write the import plan: identifiers, consent, upload rhythm and the monthly check against the CRM.
- Sequence the bidding changes from today's set-up to a value-based strategy, with a condition for each step.
- Decide whether the maintenance plan belongs in the values yet.
Worked answer
Sunvale's stage values and campaign returns
Average margin per sale: £239,400 ÷ 90 = £2,660.
| Stage | Chance of a sale | Value |
|---|---|---|
| Form enquiry | 90 ÷ 900 = 10% | £266 |
| Survey booked | 90 ÷ 360 = 25% | £665 |
| Survey completed, panels only | 45 ÷ 130 ≈ 34.6% of £1,600 | £554 |
| Survey completed, with battery | 32 ÷ 110 ≈ 29.1% of £3,200 | £931 |
| Survey completed, with charger | 13 ÷ 60 ≈ 21.7% of £5,000 | £1,083 |
Return on margin: Solar panels ≈ 323%, Solar batteries ≈ 717%, Solar grants ≈ 227%. The cheapest enquiries come from the only campaign below the 300% floor. Account return on survey values ≈ £239,400 ÷ £54,000 ≈ 443%. Cost per completed survey: £54,000 ÷ 300 = £180.
Primary stage. The completed survey, valued by recommended system: it arrives within weeks, in enough volume to learn from, and is the first stage that knows what the customer will probably buy. Enquiries and booked surveys stay secondary; the sale is imported as secondary with its quoted margin, to check that survey values still predict sales.
Import plan. Keep the stored click identifier and add hashed email capture as a second match key. Store consent with the lead and upload nothing for anyone who declined. Upload completed surveys nightly and sales weekly, with conversion time and value. Each month compare uploads with CRM counts by stage and track the unmatched share; each quarter refresh the close rates behind the values.
Sequence. First change only the goal: make the completed survey primary and hold a cost target near the observed cost per survey. Once it has settled and a month of uploads reconciles, move to maximise conversion value with a target ROASRevenue generated per unit of ad spend. near the achieved return. That return sits well above the floor, so later steps loosen the target towards it to buy volume, one step at a time, as the Smart Bidding strategies guide describes. The value-based strategy will bid the grants campaign down if its surveys stay poor.
Maintenance plan. Not yet. Lifetime value (LTVTotal value a customer brings over time.) belongs in the values once the CRM can show which customers take the plan and keep it.
Common mistakes
- Valuing revenue instead of margin. Installation cost vanishes from the decision.
- Making every stage primary. One lead becomes several conversions with stacked values.
- Bidding on the sale alone. Too few and too late to learn from.
- Changing the goal and the strategy together. Two learning triggers, one unreadable result.
- Moving to a return target before uploads reconcile. Bidding learns whatever the values say.
Next, take the conversion signals checkpoint, or revisit the intermediate Google Ads level for the target arithmetic.
