Why this matters
The advanced growth level judged experiments, incremental growth and pricing. A marketplace asks a prior question, because each of its two sides is served by the other: an owner who finds no walker leaves, and a walker with no requests stops opening the app. The guide to growing a two-sided marketplace sets the operator's decisions in order, and the guide to measurement for marketplaces supplies the numbers they need. Here both meet a business buying the wrong side.
The marketplace and its unmatched requests
Hovquentis Walkers is an invented marketplace that matches dog owners with local walkers. Owners request a walk; verified walkers set their availability and accept; Hovquentis takes a commission. It launched in Area A, opened Area B last quarter, spends most of its budget on owner ads and plans to open Area C next month the same way.
Hovquentis Walkers: last quarter by area and time slot
A request counts as matched when a verified walker accepts it within 24 hours. A walk costs the owner £15, of which Hovquentis keeps £3. Spend last quarter: owner ads £11,700 in Area A and £4,500 in Area B; walker recruitment £1,800 on job board listings headed "Earn on evenings and weekends".
| Area and slot | Owner requests | Matched in 24 hours | Searches with no walker free | Walker slots booked |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Area A, weekdays 11:00 to 15:00 | 1,500 | 840 (56%) | 520 | 96% |
| Area A, other times | 900 | 790 (88%) | 90 | 55% |
| Area B, weekdays 11:00 to 15:00 | 500 | 390 (78%) | 60 | 74% |
| Area B, other times | 400 | 330 (83%) | 30 | 49% |
The monthly report shows 1,530 sign-ups, a site conversion rate of 3.1%, £4.91 of owner spend per request and a 71% match rate.
Two funnels and one matched outcome
Split by side, the funnels show where each one stops.
Hovquentis Walkers: the owner and walker funnels for the quarter
| Owner funnel | Area A | Area B |
|---|---|---|
| New owner sign-ups | 980 | 370 |
| Made a first request | 760 | 260 |
| First request matched | 470 | 220 |
| Booked again within a month | 300 | 150 |
Of owners whose first request went unmatched, 12% tried again within a month.
| Walker funnel | Area A | Area B |
|---|---|---|
| Applications | 110 | 70 |
| Verified | 58 | 38 |
| First walk within 30 days of verification | 30 | 11 |
| Of those, offering weekday midday slots | 6 | 7 |
Task
- Say how each person's side is recorded and what changes in the monthly report.
- Define the matched walk as the shared outcome, labelling transaction value and revenue apart.
- Mark each area and slot supply-limited, demand-limited or balanced, and name the limiting side.
- Plan acquisition for each side: who, message, channel, where, when and any incentive.
- Set how each side's channels get credit and how the cross-side effect is measured.
- Decide whether Area C opens next month and, if not, what evidence would open it.
Worked answer
Recording the side. Side becomes an analytics user property, owner, walker or both, since some walkers own dogs; the sign-up event carries it, requests and availability are separate events, and the CRM holds the same field. The report then counts sign-ups and conversion per side.
The shared outcome. The matched walk, recorded once with both parties, the request, area, slot, price and commission. Transaction value sizes the market; revenue is what Hovquentis keeps, and acquisition is judged on it.
The limiting side. The healthy average hides it: weekday middays carry most of Area A's requests, fail almost half of them and leave walkers fully booked, so walkers limit matches there. Area A at other times and Area B at other times are demand-limited, with walkers well short of fully booked; Area B at midday is close to balanced. The walker funnel agrees: few of Area A's new walkers offer middays, because the listing asked for evenings and weekends, while Area B's verified walkers wait for work. Unmatched owners rarely try again, so owner spend in Area A mostly buys requests nobody answers and owners who do not return.
Acquiring each side. Walkers and owners are separate segmentsDividing a market or customer list into groups that need different offers or messages.. Walker recruitment targets people free on weekday middays, through listings that name the waiting midday demand and a referral offer to current walkers. A time-limited first-walks guarantee for new midday walkers in Area A fits, with self-booking and duplicate-account checks and paid walks kept out of liquidity reports. Owner spend in Area A is held to what midday supply can serve, and Area A's remaining owner ads are scheduled and worded for evenings and weekends, where walkers wait; owner campaigns grow in Area B, using the guide to geo-targeted campaigns.
Channel credit. Owner channels earn credit for matched walks and revenue, never requests; walker channels for walkers reaching a first walk and the walks they serve where demand waited. CACCost to acquire one new customer. and LTVTotal value a customer brings over time. are worked out per side by sign-up CohortA group of customers who share a starting event and period, tracked together over time., as the LTV and CAC guide describes. No click path links a walker's sign-up to an owner's booking, so the cross-side effect is read on Area A's midday match rate with owner spend held still; the incrementality testing guide covers area tests once comparable areas exist.
Area C. Not next month. Area A has not shown what a working area needs at midday, and one quarter of Area B cannot rule out a good month. Area C opens when Area A's midday match rate has held at an agreed level and each side's costs and values are known, with midday walkers recruited before any owner spend. Liquidity by area and slot joins the pre-read of the weekly growth meeting.
Hovquentis Walkers: owner spend judged on requests and on matched walks
| Owner spend per | Area A | Area B |
|---|---|---|
| First request | £15.39 | £17.31 |
| Owner with a first matched walk | £24.89 | £20.45 |
| Owner who booked again | £39.00 | £30.00 |
Area A looks cheaper on requests and is dearer on every outcome that earns revenue. The plan cuts Area A owner ads by £4,500 a quarter: £3,000 goes to midday walker recruitment and the guarantee there, £1,500 to Area B owner ads.
Common mistakes
- One match rate for the whole market. Full middays and idle evenings cancel out.
- Judging owner campaigns on requests. An unanswered request cost as much as a booked walk.
- Recruiting for slots that already have spare walkers. The advert decides who applies.
- Subsidising without an end date or abuse checks. Paid activity is not liquidity.
- Opening Area C on owner ads. Recruit the side the first area lacked, first.
The growth operating system capstone asks for the same reading at a resale app.
