Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Growth Marketing › Intermediate

Calculating CAC Payback for a Fitness App Subscription

An exercise in building honest unit economics for an invented fitness app before anyone raises a budget. You rebuild acquisition cost with incentives and people included, compute lifetime value on contribution margin from cohort retention, read payback by plan and channel, and recommend where the next pound should go.
ExerciseIntermediate levelModule 1: Growth economics5 minUpdated

Why this matters

A channel report that shows cost per subscriber says nothing about whether those subscribers are worth buying. The guide to LTV and CAC sets the definitions that stop the two numbers flattering the business: margin rather than revenue, every acquisition cost rather than media alone, channel rather than blended. The retention and payback guide turns the cohort curve into a payback period, the figure finance asks about first because it decides how much growth the cash can fund.

The app and its plans

Pacebloom is an invented fitness app with guided running and strength plans. It sells a monthly and an annual subscription and acquires subscribers through two channels: paid social and app store search ads. Paid social offers new monthly subscribers their first month at half price. The founder wants to double paid social because its dashboard shows the lowest cost per subscriber. Finance has agreed a twelve-month window for every lifetime value figure and asks that anything beyond it be labelled as a projection.

Illustrative example — not a real result

Pacebloom's prices, costs and one month's acquisition

ItemMonthly planAnnual plan
Price£10 a month£72 a year, paid upfront
Store and payment fees (from finance)15% of each payment15% of each payment
Serving cost (coaching content, hosting)£0.50 a paying month£0.50 a month, £6 a year
Channel, one monthMediaAgency and creativeTeam timeNew monthly subscribersNew annual subscribers
Paid social£18,000£4,000—400100
App store search£9,000—£1,00018070

The paid social half-price offer is worth £5 to each new monthly subscriber.

Share of each monthly-plan cohort still paying at the start of each month, months zero to eleven:

ChannelM0M1M2M3M4M5M6M7M8M9M10M11
Paid social100%62%48%40%35%31%28%26%24%23%22%21%
App store search100%74%63%57%53%50%48%46%45%44%43%42%

Older annual cohorts renewed for a second year at about 45%.

Working through the numbers

Work in this order, because each figure feeds the next.

  • Contribution per paying period. Price less fees less serving cost, for each plan.
  • Acquisition cost by channel and plan. All channel costs over all paying subscribers, with any incentive charged only to the plan that received it.
  • Lifetime value in the window. For the monthly plan, contribution per month multiplied by the sum of the retention shares; for the annual plan, the year's contribution, collected upfront.
  • Payback. The first month in which cumulative contribution per original subscriber reaches acquisition cost.
  • Ratio and return. Lifetime value over acquisition cost, and ROI on contribution as the gain over that cost.

Task

  1. Calculate contribution per paying month for the monthly plan and per year for the annual plan.
  2. Calculate CAC for each channel, then split it by plan, placing the half-price offer correctly.
  3. Calculate twelve-month LTV for each plan and channel.
  4. Find the payback month for each of the four combinations.
  5. Show what the founder's dashboard figure would have been, and why it misled.
  6. Recommend where Pacebloom's next increase in spend should go, and what to change in paid social.

Worked answer

Illustrative example — not a real result

Contribution and acquisition cost

FigureWorkingResult
Monthly contribution£10 − £1.50 fees − £0.50 serving£8.00 a month
Annual contribution£72 − £10.80 fees − £6 serving£55.20 a year, collected in month zero
Paid social cost before the offer£18,000 + £4,000 = £22,000 over 500 subscribers£44
Paid social CAC, monthly plan£44 + £5 offer£49
Paid social CAC, annual plan£44, no offer£44
App store search CAC, both plans(£9,000 + £1,000) ÷ 250£40

The offer is an acquisition cost and is charged once, in acquisition cost; contribution is then counted at the full price so the discount is not subtracted twice.

Illustrative example — not a real result

Lifetime value, payback and ratio

CombinationSum of retention sharesTwelve-month LTVPaybackLTV ÷ CACReturn on contribution
Paid social, monthly4.60 paying months4.60 × £8 = £36.80Not within the window (£36.80 at month eleven, below £49)0.75−25%
App store search, monthly6.65 paying months6.65 × £8 = £53.20Month eight (£42.88 cumulative, past £40)1.3333%
Paid social, annual—£55.20Month zero1.2525%
App store search, annual—£55.20Month zero1.3838%

App store search monthly cumulative contribution: £8.00, £13.92, £18.96, £23.52, £27.76, £31.76, £35.60, £39.28, then £42.88 at month eight.

The founder's dashboard: media only, £18,000 ÷ 500 = £36 per subscriber; revenue value of a monthly subscriber, 4.60 × £10 = £46. That reads as a ratio of about 1.28. On honest definitions the paid social monthly ratio is 0.75.

The second-year annual renewal, 45% × £55.20 = £24.84, sits outside the window and is shown only as a labelled projection.

Paid social monthly is the problem, not paid social. Its subscribers churn fastest and cost the most because of the offer, so they never pay back inside the window. The same channel's annual subscribers pay back immediately.

Recommendation. Do not double paid social as it stands. Drop the half-price monthly offer, make the annual plan the default on paid social landing pages and judge the channel on its plan mix. Raise app store search spend first, since both plans clear the bar, but read its marginal acquisition cost as spend rises, because the average will not show saturation. Agree a payback ceiling with finance before scaling the monthly plan anywhere: its payback arrives late in the window, and every monthly subscriber is cash out for most of a year.

Common mistakes

  • Counting the offer twice. Charge it in acquisition cost or subtract it from contribution, never both.
  • Media-only acquisition cost. Agency, creative and team time are acquisition costs, as the guide to LTV and CAC insists.
  • Revenue lifetime value. Fees and serving cost are paid on every subscription month; the guide to contribution margin and break-even targets shows how to build the margin with finance.
  • One figure per channel. Plans with different schedules need separate rows.
  • Counting the annual renewal. It lies beyond the window and must be labelled as a projection.
  • Reading payback alone. Ratio and payback answer different questions; both belong on the table.

Next, take the growth economics checkpoint or return to the intermediate growth level.

Pages this lesson applies

Terms used on this page

Also related

Related