Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Marketing Strategy › Beginner

Checkpoint: Strategy, Tactics and the Marketing Mix

Scenario questions on the first module: which layer of a plan a decision belongs to, how the marketing mix exposes contradictions between levers, and what each SOSTAC section must contain before the next one can be written. Each answer explains the reasoning and links to the page behind it.
CheckpointBeginner levelModule 1: What marketing strategy is4 minUpdated

What this checkpoint covers

The questions draw on the guide to strategy versus tactics, the marketing mix framework and the SOSTAC planning framework. The bicycle repair shop exercise applied them to one plan; these questions test the same judgement on new businesses.

Task

  1. Write your answer to each question with a short reason, without looking at the explanations.
  2. Compare each answer with the explanation and mark it right, partly right or wrong.
  3. For each miss, reread the linked page and write the rule you will apply next time in one sentence.

Questions

  1. A florist's marketing document is headed "Strategy" and lists: weekly Instagram reels, a Mother's Day email, a new website and a stall at the farmers' market. What is wrong with it, and what is missing?
  2. A dog grooming salon sees its cost per booking from paid social rise for a month. The owner proposes repositioning the salon as a premium spa. How would you handle the meeting?
  3. An accountancy practice wants to be known as the careful, partner-led choice for owner-managed firms. It also offers a permanent half-price first year and answers enquiries through a call centre. Which framework catches the problem, and what does it find?
  4. A craft brewery writes its objectives as "launch a podcast, refresh the brand and post daily". Why can none of these fail, and what would you write instead?
  5. A meal-kit company has written tactics, owners and a budget, but no situation analysis. The founder says everyone already knows the market. What does the plan lose?
  6. A language school asks whether choosing to use search advertising for adult evening classes is a strategic or a tactical decision. What is your answer?
  7. A plan's control section lists every metric the analytics tool exports, reviewed "when there is time". What would you change?
  8. A team fills in all seven Ps for a new subscription before deciding which customers it is for. Why does the result not help?

Answers explained

  1. It is a tactics calendar with a strategy heading. Each item is an activity that could be swapped for another. Missing are the choices: which customers, what the shop stands for to them, which channel does which job and what success means. The test in the guide to strategy versus tactics separates them: would the decision survive if every campaign stopped?

  2. Answer the tactical question first. Find which diagnostic moved, such as reach, click-through or conversion, and fix that. Whether the position or the channel's job is right is a strategic question for the quarterly review, with more than a month of evidence. One tactical number should not reopen the strategy, as the strategy and tactics guide sets out in its section on keeping the layers apart.

  3. The marketing mix, read across. Price contradicts the position, because permanent discounting signals the opposite of careful partner attention, and people and process contradict it too, because a call centre is not partner-led. The marketing mix framework exists to catch two levers pulling against each other and against the position.

  4. They are activities, not outcomes. Each can be done and still change nothing. An objective names an outcome with a KPI, a target and a date, such as growing taproom visits or repeat online orders to a stated level by year end, and it traces back to something the situation analysis found. The SOSTAC framework treats activity objectives as the commonest gap.

  5. The evidence the objectives and strategy depend on. Without written conclusions, nobody can check why these tactics were chosen, the objectives float free, and next year's plan starts from scratch. SOSTAC writes the situation first so that every later section can be traced back to it.

  6. Strategic, if it assigns the channel a job. "Search captures demand from adults already looking for evening classes" follows from the segment and constrains many campaigns. How the campaigns are built, from keywords to bids and ads, is tactical. The strategy and tactics guide draws the same line for channels.

  7. Measure the objectives and set a rhythm. Control lists the few measures that map to the objectives, with owners, a review date and the change each result triggers. Read the Funnel stages that explain the result, and judge spend by its ROI over the plan period rather than week by week. SOSTAC's control section closes the loop back to the situation analysis.

  8. The mix executes a position; it does not choose one. Without a segment, each P records what the company happens to do and there is nothing to check consistency against. Choose the customers and the position first, then use the mix as a completeness check, as the marketing mix framework recommends.

Where to go next

If you answered most questions well, start the second module on situation analysis, which opens with the SWOT framework. If the layering questions caught you out, redo the bicycle repair shop exercise first. The beginner marketing strategy level page shows your progress through the level.

Pages this lesson applies

Terms used on this page

Also related

Related