Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Marketing Strategy › Beginner

Separating Strategy from Tactics for a Bicycle Repair Shop

A practice exercise in telling the layers of a plan apart. You take an invented bicycle repair shop's plan, which is really a list of activities, sort each line into objective, strategy or tactic, write the missing sections as a short SOSTAC outline and cut the activities that serve no strategic choice.
ExerciseBeginner levelModule 1: What marketing strategy is5 minUpdated

Why this matters

Most small business plans are calendars: posts, offers and leaflets, with the choices behind them never written down. The guide to strategy versus tactics gives the test: a decision is strategy if it would still be true if every current campaign stopped tomorrow. The SOSTAC framework gives the order: situation, objectives and strategy before tactics, action and control. Lines that turn out to be decisions about price or service belong to the marketing mix framework, which checks they agree with each other.

The shop and its plan

Chainring Cycle Repairs is a fictional independent workshop near a commuter railway station in a mid-sized town. It services and repairs bicycles and sells parts, not bikes. The owner works alongside one other mechanic. A chain sports store in an out-of-town retail park also offers servicing.

Illustrative example — not a real result

Chainring Cycle Repairs: the business last year

FactDetail
Servicing and repair revenue£84,000
Average service or repair job£75
Jobs from commuters (riding to the station or to work)46%
Workshop bookings, April to SeptemberFull; customers wait up to 8 days
Workshop bookings, October to MarchAround 60% of capacity
Commuter customers who return within a year71%
Leisure customers who return within a year32%
Reviews on its map listing41, most praising speed
Chain store servicingCheaper; customers report waits of 2 to 3 weeks

The owner's plan for next year, as written:

Illustrative example — not a real result

Chainring Cycle Repairs: the plan as the owner wrote it

LinePlan item
AGet more customers
BPost on Instagram three times a week
CSpring offer: £10 off a full service in March and April
DBecome the repair shop commuters rely on to keep them riding
EStart a TikTok account
FAsk every customer for a review on the map listing
GGrow servicing and repair revenue to £100,000 by December
HLeaflet drop to 5,000 homes across the town
ISponsor the local road club's racing kit
JSame-day repairs for bikes dropped off before 8.30am
KPaid social ads to cycling-interest audiences across the region
LBe cheaper than the chain store
MEmail service reminders six months after each job

Sorting objectives, strategy and tactics

Ask three questions of each line. Is it an outcome with a measure and a date? Then it is an objective; without a measure it is an aspiration to rewrite. Does it choose who the shop serves, what it stands for or how the offer is shaped, so that many activities inherit it? Then it is strategy. Could it be swapped for another activity without changing anything else? Then it is a tactic. Lines that change the offer, such as a service promise or a price stance, are strategic even when they look like activities, and two of them can pull against each other.

Task

  1. Sort every line of the plan into objective, aspiration, strategy or tactic, with a one-sentence reason.
  2. Rewrite the aspiration as a measurable objective, and add a second objective the situation calls for.
  3. Write the missing situation and strategy sections of a SOSTAC outline in a few lines each.
  4. For each tactic, name the strategy line it serves, or mark it as serving none.
  5. Cut or park the tactics that serve no strategy, and resolve any strategic lines that contradict each other.
  6. Add action and control in brief: owners and monthly measures.

Worked answer

Illustrative example — not a real result

Chainring Cycle Repairs: the sorted plan

LineLayerReason
A Get more customersAspirationNo measure, no date, no segment
G Revenue to £100,000 by DecemberObjectiveOutcome, measure and date
D Commuters rely on usStrategyChooses a segment and a position; true whatever campaigns run
J Same-day repairs before 8.30amStrategy (mix: process)Shapes the offer; many activities would promote it
L Cheaper than the chain storeStrategy (mix: price)A position, but it contradicts D and J
B, C, E, F, H, I, K, MTacticsSingle activities that could be swapped

The arithmetic behind the objectives: the gap is £100,000 − £84,000 = £16,000, or about 16,000 ÷ 75 ≈ 213 extra jobs. Summer is full, so the extra jobs must come mostly from October to March.

Objectives. Keep the revenue objective and rewrite "get more customers" as raising winter workshop use to a stated level by March. Each objective gets a KPI: revenue against target monthly, and winter bookings as a share of capacity.

Situation. Commuters return far more often than leisure riders and ride all year. Reviews praise speed. The chain store is cheaper but slow. The constraint is summer capacity; the opportunity is the winter gap.

Strategy. Serve commuters first and position on keeping them riding: fast, reliable, honest repairs near the station. The same-day promise is the offer that proves the position. Weight effort to the winter months. Drop "cheaper than the chain store": price competition contradicts a speed promise that costs mechanic time, and customers already choose Chainring for speed.

Tactics kept. Reviews (F) and service reminders (M) serve the commuter position and repeat visits. Instagram (B) stays only if it shows same-day turnarounds. Add what the old list missed: a presence at the station and a winter check-up offer timed for autumn.

Tactics cut or parked. The spring discount (C) fills a workshop that is already full and cuts revenue per job. The town-wide leaflets (H) and regional paid social (K) reach people far from the station; any later paid test needs a tight radius and a CAC ceiling set from a commuter's repeat value. TikTok (E) serves no line, and the road club (I) reaches racers who service their own bikes; park both.

Action and control. The owner runs reviews, reminders and the station presence. Each month, review revenue against target, winter bookings against capacity, and the commuter Funnel from reminder sent to booking made. Tactics are swapped monthly; the commuter strategy is questioned only quarterly.

Common mistakes

  • Treating the offer lines as tactics. The same-day promise is a strategic choice about process; it decides what every message says.
  • Keeping both positions. "Fastest" and "cheapest" cannot both lead, and the shop's costs favour speed.
  • Filling the busy season. A discount where demand exceeds capacity loses money.

Take this sorting habit into the strategy and marketing mix checkpoint, or return to the beginner marketing strategy level page.

Pages this lesson applies

Terms used on this page

Also related

Related