Why this matters
Every performance campaign needs a number to aim at, and the platforms are happy to suggest one. Their suggestion describes what recent clicks have cost, not what the business can pay. Accept it and a school can run ads that look efficient while each new pupil loses money.
This exercise applies the performance economics guide: start at the bottom of the chain with the margin a result brings, decide how much of it to spend winning that result, and check the answer against payback. The glossary definition of cost per acquisition reminds you that a CPACost of each conversion. means nothing until the conversion is named: the ads will count enquiries while the school counts pupils. The complete guide to performance marketing sets out why the target must come from the business, and the brand vs performance guide is a useful reminder that referrals and reputation also bring pupils the ads should not claim.
The school and its pupils
Lanecraft Driving School is a fictional independent school in a market town with a handful of employed instructors and an online booking page. Most pupils arrive by recommendation. The owner wants to advertise on search and social to fill quieter months and has asked what a new pupil is worth paying for.
Lanecraft Driving School: prices, costs and pupil history
| Item | Figure |
|---|---|
| Single lesson (one hour) | £40 |
| Block of ten lessons, paid upfront | £380 |
| Instructor pay per lesson hour | £18 |
| Fuel, car lease and insurance per lesson hour | £6 |
| Card and booking system fees | 3% of the price paid |
| Test-day car hire, charged to the pupil | £80, costing the school £35 in instructor time and fuel |
| Blocks bought by a typical pupil, from last year's records | 3 |
| Pupils who book test-day car hire | Almost all |
| Enquiries that become a booked first block | About 1 in 2 |
| New pupils the instructors can take on each month | 12 |
| Owner's planned monthly ad budget | £1,200 |
- The owner pays instructors weekly and wants each pupil's ad cost covered by the first block's margin.
- The owner also wants to keep at least half of each pupil's total margin as profit.
- The ads will optimise for a completed enquiry form; block bookings are too few to learn from.
From margin to an affordable CPA
Work in three layers. First, the contribution margin a pupil brings across the bookings a typical pupil makes: a simple customer lifetime value (LTVTotal value a customer brings over time.) that sets one ceiling. Second, the cash limit: if the owner will only wait for the first block to pay back the advertising, that block's margin is a second ceiling, and the lower one binds. Third, the working target: below the ceiling, to absorb attribution error, then translated to the event the platforms optimise for. Across all channels the figure the owner should watch is the blended cost per new pupil, the school's CACCost to acquire one new customer., counted in its own diary rather than in any platform report.
Task
- Work out the contribution margin on one lesson hour bought within a block.
- Work out the margin on one block, on test-day car hire and on a typical pupil's whole relationship with the school.
- Apply the owner's profit rule to the whole-relationship margin to find one ceiling for a new pupil.
- Apply the owner's payback rule to find a second ceiling, and decide which of the two binds.
- Set a working target per new pupil, leaving room for error, and say why you chose the gap you did.
- Convert that target into a target per enquiry, the event the ads will optimise for.
- Check the budget against instructor capacity.
Worked answer
Lanecraft's affordable CPA, step by step
| Step | Working | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Price per lesson hour in a block | £380 ÷ 10 | £38.00 |
| Fees per hour | 3% of £38 | £1.14 |
| Margin per lesson hour | £38 − £18 − £6 − £1.14 | £12.86 |
| Margin per block | £12.86 × 10 | £128.60 |
| Margin on test-day car hire | £80 − £35 − fees of £2.40 | £42.60 |
| Margin per typical pupil | (£128.60 × 3) + £42.60 | £428.40 |
| Ceiling from the profit rule | Half of £428.40 | £214.20 |
| Ceiling from the payback rule | Margin on the first block | £128.60 |
| Binding ceiling | The lower of the two | £128.60 |
| Working target per new pupil | About 80% of the ceiling, rounded down | £100 |
| Working target per enquiry | £100 × 1 in 2 enquiries becoming pupils | £50 |
| Pupils the budget buys at target | £1,200 ÷ £100 | 12, matching capacity |
The payback rule binds, not the profit rule. On paper a pupil is worth far more, because most buy several blocks, but the owner cannot wait that long for the cash. A target can be economically sound and still unaffordable.
The gap below the ceiling is deliberate. Some pupils who enquire after an ad were recommended by a friend and would have come anyway, and platforms count conversions under their own rules. A target at the ceiling leaves nothing for that error; revisit the gap once the diary shows how many pupils the ads really brought.
The enquiry target carries an assumption. It holds only while the enquiry-to-pupil rate holds. If follow-up slows or the ads attract price shoppers, a cost per enquiry that looks on target buys pupils above the ceiling. The owner should log which enquiries came from ads and how many booked, and recalculate monthly.
Capacity caps the budget. At target the budget brings in as many pupils as the instructors can take, so the next step after a good month is a check on diaries, not a bigger budget.
Common mistakes
- Using revenue instead of margin. Treating the block price as the value of a pupil sets a ceiling several times too high, and every pupil bought near it loses money.
- Using lifetime margin when cash is the constraint. The repeat blocks are real but arrive after the wages.
- Setting the target at break-even. Normal attribution overlap then turns break-even into a loss.
- Giving the platform the pupil target as an enquiry target. The ads would then buy enquiries at twice the affordable cost per pupil.
When your figures reconcile with the worked answer, try the performance marketing foundations checkpoint, or return to the beginner performance marketing level to see the module in order.
