Why this matters
The performance report in Search Console (GSCGoogle's search performance and indexing tool.) is the cheapest source of SEO opportunities a site has: it shows queries the engine already ranks the site for. The Search Console tutorial explains how to read it without being misled by totals, and the section on finding underperforming snippets gives the comparison method. The skill this exercise trains is diagnosis: a low click-through rate has several causes, and only one of them is fixed by rewriting the title.
The performance export
Copperfield Dental is an invented independent practice in a fictional town. The export below covers a recent quarter, filtered to non-brand queries in its home country, with each page shown against its main query.
Copperfield Dental: page-level export, non-brand, one quarter
| Page | Main query | Impressions | Clicks | CTR | Avg. position |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| /emergency-dentist | emergency dentist copperfield | 2,900 | 290 | 10.0% | 3.1 |
| /invisalign | invisalign copperfield | 1,500 | 195 | 13.0% | 2.4 |
| /hygienist | dental hygienist copperfield | 1,200 | 108 | 9.0% | 3.5 |
| /teeth-whitening | teeth whitening copperfield | 3,800 | 46 | 1.2% | 4.2 |
| /crowns | dental crowns copperfield | 700 | 49 | 7.0% | 4.5 |
| /root-canal | root canal treatment copperfield | 800 | 56 | 7.0% | 4.8 |
| /new-patients | dentist copperfield taking new patients | 2,100 | 21 | 1.0% | 5.2 |
| /fillings | white fillings copperfield | 600 | 36 | 6.0% | 5.5 |
| /blog/why-teeth-turn-yellow | why are my teeth yellow | 5,400 | 54 | 1.0% | 6.0 |
| /dentures | dentures copperfield | 500 | 30 | 6.0% | 6.8 |
| /dental-implants | dental implants cost | 6,200 | 37 | 0.6% | 8.5 |
| /children | kids dentist copperfield | 900 | 2 | 0.2% | 14.0 |
Copperfield Dental: current titles and results-page notes
| Page | Current title | Results-page notes for the main query |
|---|---|---|
| /teeth-whitening | Services | Copperfield Dental | Local practices; titles name the treatment, the town and home or in-chair options |
| /new-patients | New Patients | Copperfield Dental | Practices whose titles say they are taking new patients |
| /blog/why-teeth-turn-yellow | Blog | Copperfield Dental | Featured snippet listing causes; large people-also-ask block; health publishers rank |
| /dental-implants | Dental Implants | Copperfield Dental | Cost guides with price ranges; the practice's page lists no prices |
| /children | Children | Copperfield Dental | Local practices with dedicated children's pages |
Filtering for opportunities
Do not compare a page with published curves of click-through by position. Compare it with the site's own pages at a similar position, because they share the brand, the market and the kind of results page. Group the pages into position bands, find the typical (median) click-through rate for each band, and measure each page's shortfall against it.
Then, before writing anything, separate three kinds of shortfall:
- Snippet problems. Good position, intent matches, weak title or description. A rewrite fixes these.
- Feature problems. The SERPThe page of results a search engine shows. is crowded with a snippet or questions that answer the query before anyone clicks. A rewrite helps a little; the ceiling is lower.
- Position or intent problems. The page is too far down, or is the wrong kind of page for the query. The snippet is not the constraint.
Task
- Group the pages into a top band and a middle band by average position, and leave out pages beyond them.
- Work out the median click-through rate of each band.
- For each page in the bands, calculate the extra clicks it would have earned at the band's median rate.
- Classify each low performer as a snippet, feature, or position or intent problem, using the results-page notes.
- Write a fix list in priority order, naming the change for each page.
- Add the date and the old title to each row so the change can be measured later.
Worked answer
Bands, medians and shortfalls
| Band | Pages | Median CTR |
|---|---|---|
| Positions 1 to 3.9 | emergency, invisalign, hygienist | 10.0% |
| Positions 4 to 7.9 | whitening, crowns, root canal, new patients, fillings, blog, dentures | 6.0% |
Sorted rates in the middle band are 1.0, 1.0, 1.2, 6.0, 6.0, 7.0 and 7.0, so the median is 6.0%.
| Page | Shortfall in rate | Extra clicks at median |
|---|---|---|
| /teeth-whitening | 6.0% − 1.2% = 4.8 points | 3,800 × 0.048 ≈ 182 |
| /new-patients | 6.0% − 1.0% = 5.0 points | 2,100 × 0.050 = 105 |
| /blog/why-teeth-turn-yellow | 6.0% − 1.0% = 5.0 points | 5,400 × 0.050 = 270, but capped by features |
The top band has no underperformer. The implants and children's pages sit beyond the bands.
Copperfield Dental: prioritised fix list
| Priority | Page | Problem | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | /teeth-whitening | Snippet | Title "Teeth Whitening in Copperfield: Home and In-Chair | Copperfield Dental"; description naming both options and how to book |
| 2 | /new-patients | Snippet | Title "Copperfield Dentist Taking New Patients | Copperfield Dental"; description on how to register |
| 3 | /blog/why-teeth-turn-yellow | Feature | Title naming the causes; open the post with a short list of causes so it can compete for the snippet |
| 4 | /dental-implants | Intent | Add a costs section that explains what sets the price; retitle after the content changes |
| 5 | /children | Position | Not a quick win; review content and internal links later |
The reasoning:
- Whitening comes first because it has the largest clean gap: right intent, good position, a boilerplate title that does not name the treatment.
- New patients is second for the same reason on a smaller scale. The query asks a yes-or-no question, and the title should answer it.
- The blog post is third despite the largest raw gap, because a featured snippet and question boxes take many clicks before any listing. Leading with the answer, as the writing for the web guide teaches, is the realistic lever.
- Implants is not a snippet job. The query wants costs and the page has none, so a new title would promise what the page does not deliver.
- Children's is beyond the first results page. Click-through there says little.
To size a fix in visits before arguing for it, the CTR calculator turns a rate change into clicks. Record each change and set a review date, as the after-publishing items in the SEO page publishing checklist require.
Common mistakes
- Reading unfiltered totals. Brand queries would have hidden every row above.
- Using an industry curve. It ignores the site's own results pages and features.
- Rewriting titles on intent problems. The implants page needs content first.
- Chasing raw gaps. The biggest number was the most capped.
- No baseline. Without the old title and the date, nobody can tell whether the change worked.
Next, bring the whole level together in the service page capstone, or return to the beginner SEO level.
