Why this matters
A comment section is a public record of how a business treats people, and a reply's ReachUnique people who saw an ad. goes far beyond the person it answers. The community management guide sets response standards by message type and separates complaints from trolls and crises. The page optimisation guide warns that a message button to an unmonitored inbox is worse than none, and the social page optimisation checklist asks for a saved greeting and a response-time target. Here you apply all three to one weekend's backlog.
The comment backlog
Lantern House is an invented neighbourhood restaurant serving small plates, with Instagram as its primary platform and Facebook reviews switched on. Nobody opened the inbox over a busy weekend. Its voice is warm, plain and unhurried.
Lantern House: the Monday morning backlog
| Item | Where | What it says |
|---|---|---|
| A | Instagram comment | "Do you have gluten-free options on the new menu?" |
| B | Facebook review, 2 stars | "Waited over an hour for mains on Saturday and nobody told us why. Food was good when it came, but not at this price." |
| C | Instagram message | "My son had a reaction after the satay last night. He has a peanut allergy and we told the server. He is fine now but I am furious." |
| D | Instagram comment | "Best ramen in town, the broth is unreal." |
| E | Story tag | A customer's photo of the bao platter, tagged, no question |
| F | Instagram comment | "Win a free phone, click my bio" from an account with no posts |
| G | Comments on 6 posts | The same account: "Overpriced rubbish, everyone avoid." The team replied once last month offering to help; no reply, more insults since |
| H | Instagram message | A local food writer asking about the new head chef for a piece next week |
| I | Facebook comment | "Are you open on the bank holiday Monday?" |
| J | Facebook review, 1 star | "The waiter with the beard was rude to my mother and laughed at her." |
Sorting by urgency
Sort before you write, or a safety issue waits behind a question about opening hours. Use four bands: escalate now, reply today in public then private, reply today in public, and moderate without replying. Two tests help: does the item mention safety, a legal matter, a journalist or a named member of staff; and is this a person with a problem or a person who wants a reaction? Treat everyone as a customer until behaviour shows otherwise.
Task
- Place each item in an urgency band and name its type: question, complaint, praise, audience content, mention, spam, abuse or early sign of a crisis.
- Draft each reply in the voice and say whether it stays public, moves private or starts private.
- For each escalated item, name who it goes to; for each moderated item, say hide, remove or report, and why.
- Write an escalation rule short enough to pin above the till.
- Name the profile fix that would have stopped the backlog building up.
Worked answer
Escalate now: C, H and J. C is an allergy reaction, a safety matter whatever the outcome, so the reply waits until the owner has spoken to the server. H is a journalist and J names a member of staff; both go to the owner.
Reply today, public then private: B and, after escalation, J. These are complaints from people with problems.
Reply today in public: A, D, E and I. Questions and praise.
Moderate without replying: F and G. Item F is spam; item G has already been offered help and escalated anyway, which is the tell of a troll.
Lantern House: draft replies
| Item | Reply | Where it goes |
|---|---|---|
| A | "Yes, six dishes on the new menu are gluten-free and marked. Tell your server and the kitchen will take care with prep." | Public |
| B | "Thank you for telling us, and we are sorry. A wait like that with no explanation is not good enough. We would like to hear what happened, so we have sent you a message." | Public, then private |
| C | From the owner, after speaking to the team: "I am so sorry, and glad your son is all right. I would like to call you today to understand exactly what happened. Could you share a number?" | Private only; logged |
| D | "Thank you. The broth takes the kitchen two days, so that means a lot." | Public |
| E | Share to stories with a thank-you, then message: "Thank you for the photo. Could we repost it on our feed? We would credit you." | Story share, then private for permission |
| F | No reply. Remove and report as spam. | Moderated under the no-spam rule |
| G | No reply. Hide the comments and restrict the account; record each action in the moderation log. | Moderated under the no-abuse rule |
| H | Owner replies within the hour with a time to talk. | Private |
| I | "We are closed on the bank holiday Monday and open again on Tuesday from noon. Hope to see you then." | Public |
| J | From the owner: "We are sorry your mother was treated like that. Could you message us so I can look into it properly?" | Public, then private |
Item C stays private because the public record is not where a safety case is handled. Item G is hidden rather than argued with, because a public argument hands the troll an audience and extends its ReachUnique people who saw an ad. to everyone reading. Item B stays up and gets a reply, because criticism is never removed.
The escalation rule
Allergies, illness, injury or safety: call the owner and reply to nobody until the owner says. Journalists, creators or a named member of staff: to the owner within the hour. A conversation gone round twice: to the owner before the third reply. Everything else: reply within the working day in the voice guide's words, and log every hide or removal with the rule and the date.
The profile fix. The message button promised a reply nobody was there to give. Set a greeting that states the cover hours and a phone number for anything urgent, and publish the response window in the profile.
Common mistakes
- Deleting the bad review. It is noticed and costs more than the review did.
- Replying to a troll again. Once real help has changed nothing, moderate and log it.
- Reposting photos without asking. Ask first and credit the person. The beginner level overview brings community rules into the capstone plan.
