Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Marketing Careers & Professional Development › Progression

Coaching a Newer Marketer Before You Manage

How an experienced marketer can coach a newer colleague: agreeing the role with your manager, explaining decisions, reviewing work, feedback and escalation.
Tutorialintermediate10 min readUpdated

What coaching a newer colleague is, and what it is not

The career ladders and levels guide lists supporting a newer colleague among the stretch responsibilities that prepare someone for the next level, and its illustrative senior executive coaches a new executive through the team's processes on the way to a manager role. Management writers in publications such as the Harvard Business Review have long described careers, as that guide explains, as growth in responsibility and judgement rather than a march through titles. Coaching is one of the earliest places where that growth shows: your impact starts to flow through someone else's work.

The marketing management guide notes that the Chartered Institute of Marketing frames professional marketing competence around the shift from doing the work to directing it. Coaching is a small, safe version of that shift. You still do your own job, but part of your contribution is now measured by what another person can do because you helped. The guide to hiring and developing marketers adds that the CIM's emphasis on continuing professional development points to growth through deliberate, recorded practice rather than occasional training. A coach provides exactly that kind of practice, close to real work.

Coaching is not management. The hiring guide describes a buddy who is not the manager, someone the starter can ask the questions they would rather not ask their boss, and that distinction is the heart of this tutorial. A coach has no line authority: no say in objectives, priorities, pay, probation or performance decisions. Those belong to the manager, and any employment matter follows the organisation's own policy. The guide to delegating marketing work describes the manager handing over outcomes at a level of authority; a coach helps the newer colleague work well within whatever the manager has delegated, and does not hand out authority of their own.

It is not the move into management either. How the contributor and management tracks differ, and how to prepare for a manager role, are in the ladders guide. This tutorial teaches one practice inside your current role.

Before you start

  • Your manager's agreement, in a conversation rather than an assumption. Coaching that the manager has not asked for or agreed to can cut across their plans for the newer colleague.
  • The newer marketer's starting material. If the team keeps an onboarding pack for new marketers, read it, so your coaching builds on it rather than repeating or contradicting it. If the newer colleague is an experienced starter with their own written plan, as the tutorial on planning your first months in a new role describes, ask whether they are happy to share it.
  • The team's procedures and rules, such as the paid campaign launch SOP, the campaign launch QA checklist and the team's Naming Convention. You will be explaining them, so check you know the current versions.
  • Time protected in your own calendar. Coaching that only happens when you are not busy will not happen. Agree with your manager how it fits around your own work.
  • A place to keep notes: what you agreed, what you covered and what you noticed. They feed the conversation with the manager at the end.

The steps

  1. Agree the scope with your manager

    Start with the manager, not the newer colleague. Agree what the coaching is for (learning a channel, the team's processes, a kind of analysis), how long it will run before you review it together, how much of your time it may take and how it fits with your own work. Agree, too, what is not yours: objectives, priorities, workload, probation and performance stay with the manager, and anything you notice in those areas goes back to them. Ask the manager to tell the newer colleague about the arrangement themselves, so it is clear from the start that it is agreed and what it covers.

  2. Find out what the newer marketer wants to learn

    Ask before you teach. In a first conversation, find out what they already know, what they are working on, what they find hardest and what they want to be able to do on their own. Someone in their first marketing job may want the basics of working in live accounts, which the guide to making the most of a first digital marketing role covers from their side; an experienced starter may want the business's context more than any technique. Agree a short list of things to work on and a regular time to talk, and write both down.

  3. Walk through how work flows and the rules that matter

    Show them how a piece of work moves through the team: who briefs it, who builds it, who reviews it, what is checked before it goes live and who signs it off. Walk through the procedures that apply to their work, such as the launch SOP and the QA checklist, and the conventions that keep reports usable, such as the naming convention and the team's UTM rules, as the guide to naming conventions and UTMs sets them out. Point them to the written versions rather than re-explaining them each time; the aim is that they know where the rules live, not that they depend on you to recite them.

  4. Explain decisions, not only tasks

    The most useful thing an experienced marketer can pass on is not how to do a task but why it is done that way. When you show them a piece of work, explain the decision behind it: why this audience, why this KPI, why the A/B Test was set up this way, why a figure was left out of a report. Think aloud while you work on something real and let them watch. Then reverse it: ask them to explain their own choices on their next piece of work before you comment on it. Reasoning they can explain is reasoning they can reuse.

  5. Set which decisions they take alone

    Agree with the newer colleague, inside whatever the manager has delegated to them, which decisions they can make without checking with you. The one-way and two-way doors framework helps, in the way the delegation guide uses it: decisions that are cheap to undo, such as copy, scheduling or small bid changes, are good candidates for them to take alone; decisions that are hard to undo, such as anything that commits budget, changes what customers see at scale or goes outside the brand rules, stay with the usual reviewer and approval route. Write the list down. A short, explicit list removes the guesswork about when to ask.

  6. Review their work before it ships, then less often

    At first, look at their work before it goes live: a campaign build, an email, a report, a piece of analysis. Review it with them, not for them: ask them to walk you through it, point out what you see and let them make the changes. Check the things that would be expensive to get wrong, such as tracking, spend settings, audiences and the measures a report uses. As the work comes back right, review less: the summary rather than every line, a sample rather than every piece, and eventually only the higher-risk work. Tell them each time the review becomes lighter, so they know it is because their work has earned it.

  7. Give feedback close to the work

    Give feedback when the work is in front of you both, not saved for later. Be specific about what you saw in the work and what you would change, and be just as specific about what was good, so they know what to repeat. The guide to hiring and developing marketers sets out how feedback is most useful; as a coach you follow the same approach, applied to the work itself and never to judgements about how they are doing in the role. Ask for feedback on your coaching too, and change what is not helping.

  8. Step back as they gain confidence

    The aim of coaching is that they no longer need it for the things you worked on. As each item on your list becomes something they do well unaided, take it off the list and stop checking it. Move from answering their questions to asking what they think the answer is. Let them make small, reversible mistakes and learn from them, rather than stepping in at the first sign of trouble. Coaching that never loosens tells the newer colleague they are not trusted, in the same way the delegation guide describes for a manager's check-ins.

  9. Tell your manager what you saw, without assessing

    At the review point you agreed in the first step, tell the manager what the coaching covered and what the newer colleague now does unaided that they did not before. Keep it to observations about the work: what they can now do, what they are still learning, what you would suggest they work on next. Do not rate them, compare them with others or offer a view on their performance in the role; that judgement is the manager's, made with information you do not have. Agree with the manager whether the coaching continues, changes focus or ends.

What a coach does and what stays with the manager

The line between coaching and managing is easier to hold when it is written down. Use the table to agree the split with your manager at the start, and come back to it whenever a question arises about which side something falls on.

AreaThe coachThe manager
What to work onHelps with the work the newer colleague has been givenSets objectives, priorities and workload
How work is doneExplains processes, rules and the reasons behind decisionsOwns the processes and any change to them
DecisionsAgrees which reversible decisions the colleague takes alone, within the manager's delegationSets the level of authority and remains accountable
ReviewReviews work before it ships, then less oftenDecides what is reviewed by whom in the team's process
FeedbackGives feedback on the work, close to the workGives feedback on performance in the role
ProgressReports observations about the workJudges performance, probation and development
Pay, terms and policyNot involved; refers questions to the managerResponsible, with the organisation's policy and people team

Two practical rules follow. When the newer colleague asks you something from the right-hand column, send them to the manager rather than answering. When you notice something that belongs in the right-hand column, such as a problem with workload or a pattern in their work that concerns you, tell the manager and let them decide what to do with it.

A senior analyst coaches a new reporting executive (illustrative)

Illustrative example — not a real result

Grevolynn coaches a new reporting executive for a quarter

Grevolynn is a senior analytics specialist at an invented holiday cottage agency. Her manager asks her to coach a new reporting executive for one quarter, at about 30 minutes a week, while the manager keeps the executive's objectives and their probation review. In the first session the executive says the hardest part of the job is the monthly report, especially explaining why a figure moved. For the first 2 reports, Grevolynn reviews every line with the executive before it is sent, asking them to explain each comment on a KPI rather than correcting it herself. By the third, she reads only the summary. They agree 3 decisions the executive can take alone: which week-on-week movements to leave out of the commentary, when to add a data note, and how to label a chart. Booking enquiries and anything touching spend stay with the usual reviewer. At the end of the quarter she sends the manager a short note: the executive now writes the report's commentary unaided, still asks about seasonal comparisons, and might next learn the team's test readouts. She does not rate the executive, and the manager holds the probation review as planned.

The example shows the shape rather than the figures: the scope is agreed with the manager first, the review moves from every line to the summary as the work comes back right, the decisions taken alone are few and reversible, and the note to the manager describes the work, not the person's performance.

Common mistakes

  • Starting without the manager's agreement. Coaching that the manager has not agreed can cut across their plans. Agree the scope, the time and the limits first.
  • Teaching tasks instead of decisions. Showing someone which buttons to press teaches a single task. Explaining why teaches the tasks that follow.
  • Doing the work for them. Fixing their work yourself is quicker once and slower forever. Review it with them and let them make the changes.
  • Never stepping back. Reviewing every piece of work indefinitely signals distrust. Lighten the review as the work earns it, and say so.
  • Drifting into management. Setting priorities, judging performance or answering questions about pay and probation are the manager's. Send them there.
  • Assessing instead of observing. A rating from a coach carries weight it should not. Report what the colleague can now do and leave the judgement to the manager.
  • Letting it lapse. Coaching squeezed in only when you are free does not happen. Protect the time and review the arrangement at the agreed point.

Frequently asked questions

What should I do if the newer marketer's work is consistently below the standard?

Keep coaching the work itself: explain what good looks like, review it with them and help them improve the next piece. Then tell your manager what you have seen, as observations about the work rather than a verdict on the person, and leave any judgement about performance to them. You are not the person who decides whether someone is meeting the role's expectations, and taking on that judgement without the authority to act on it puts both of you in a difficult position. Your manager may ask for your observations; give them factually and let the manager decide what happens next.

Does coaching a colleague count as management experience?

It counts as evidence of something a management role needs, which is helping other people do better work, but it is not the same as managing. A coach has no authority over priorities, objectives, pay or performance, and the hardest parts of management sit exactly there. Describe it accurately: what you agreed with your manager, what the newer colleague could do unaided at the end that they could not before, and what you learned about explaining and stepping back. That is a credible piece of evidence for a next step without overstating it.

What if the newer marketer asks me about something that is the manager's to decide?

Say plainly that it is a question for the manager, and help them work out how to raise it if that is useful. Questions about objectives, workload, pay, probation, leave or how they are being assessed all belong there. Do not speculate about the answer, and do not pass on what you think the manager might say. You can still listen, and you can still help them prepare for the conversation, but the answer has to come from the person with the authority to give it.

Terms used on this page

Frameworks

Where this page is used

Also related

Sources

  1. Chartered Institute of Marketing — CIM
  2. Harvard Business Review — Harvard Business Review

Related