Hiring starts with the role, not the advert
The most common hiring failure happens before any candidate applies. A vacancy appears, someone copies the last job description, adds a few channels that sound current, and posts it. The result attracts people who match a list of tools rather than people who can deliver what the team needs, and the interviews then test the list.
Start instead from the gap. What outcome is not being delivered, or will not be once this person leaves? What would the person in this role own at the end of their first year, and how would you know they had succeeded? Which decisions would they make alone, and which would they bring to you? Answering those questions often changes the role. A request to hire a "social media manager" can turn out to be a need for someone who owns the top of the FunnelModel of the customer journey stages. across channels, or for an agency rather than a hire at all. When the role is already empty, the tutorial on covering an empty role keeps the team's work moving while you recruit and shows what the gap reveals about the role before the scope is written.
Check the role against the team structure as well. If the team model puts this person in a pod, the role needs breadth; if it sits in a channel team, depth. If the role straddles two groups, decide which one it belongs to before you hire, because a new starter with two managers will spend their first months negotiating rather than delivering.
Scoping and writing the role
A scope is a short internal document that the advert, the assessment and the interview are all built from. Write it first and share it with the people who will interview.
| Element | What to write | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | One or two sentences on why the role exists and what changes if it is filled well | Stops the role drifting into a list of tasks |
| Outcomes | The few results the person will own, with the KPIA metric tied directly to an objective. or evidence that shows each | Gives interviews and the probation review a standard |
| Decisions | What the person decides alone, recommends, or is consulted on | Prevents a hire who expects authority the role lacks |
| Interfaces | Who they work with most, inside and outside marketing | Shows which collaboration skills matter |
| Must-have skills | The handful without which the person cannot succeed early | Keeps the shortlist honest |
| Can-learn skills | Skills you are willing to develop after hiring | Widens the pool and reduces copy-paste requirements |
| Level and growth | Seniority, reporting line and where the role can lead | Attracts people who want what the role offers |
The advert is then a translation of the scope for a candidate: the purpose, the outcomes, the team and the genuine must-haves. Long lists of tools deter good candidates who lack one of them and attract applicants who list everything. Be clear about working arrangements and the hiring process, including any assessment task, because candidates plan around them. How the advert, the careers pages and staff stories should look and sound as the same brand customers know is covered in the guide to employer brand basics.
Assessment: tasks, interviews and references
Interviews alone are weak predictors of marketing performance. They reward fluent talkers and people who have prepared well, which is why candidates read interview preparation guidance and why the manager should not rely on the conversation alone. The stronger signal comes from seeing how someone works.
Assessment tasks. Give a short task that mirrors the real work: critiquing an existing campaign, drafting a brief from a set of facts, prioritising a list of requests, or analysing a small data set and recommending a decision. Keep it proportionate, never use the output commercially, and say in advance how it will be judged. The discussion of the task in interview is often more revealing than the task itself, because it shows how the candidate reasons, takes challenge and handles what they did not know.
Structured interviews. Ask every candidate the same core questions, drawn from the scope's outcomes and decisions, and score answers against a simple agreed standard before comparing notes. Questions about what the candidate actually did, what they decided, what went wrong and what they would change are more useful than hypothetical ones. Ask how they judged success: a marketer who talks about activity rather than results such as ROIProfit relative to cost. or pipeline is telling you how they will report to you.
Panels. Include someone from an interface the role depends on, such as sales or product, because they will spot collaboration problems the marketing team misses. Keep panels small and give each interviewer a different area to probe.
References. Use them to test specific concerns that arose in the process rather than as a formality. Ask the referee what the candidate needed support with, not only what they did well.
Onboarding in the first weeks
A good hire can be wasted by poor onboarding. The new starter arrives keen and spends weeks waiting for access, guessing at priorities and learning the business from whoever happens to sit nearby. Treat onboarding as a plan with an owner. The plan is easier to write when the team keeps a reusable onboarding pack for new marketers with access by role, the rules that matter on day one and a safe first task.
Before day one, arrange access to the tools, data and documents the role needs, and set up introductions with the people on the role's interfaces. In the first week, cover the business, the customers and the plan: what the company sells and to whom, the current marketing plan and its objectives, how the team works, and where the role fits. Give the new starter a small, real piece of work early, so they contribute and learn the workflow at the same time. For someone in their first marketing job, the guide to making the most of a first digital marketing role covers the same period from the starter's side, including the work log that makes one-to-ones specific.
Agree written goals for the first few months, drawn from the scope, and review them regularly. Early goals should mix learning (understand the customer research, meet each sales lead) with delivery (run a campaign, own a report). An experienced starter can bring a draft of their own, as the tutorial on planning your first months in a new marketing role sets out, so the written goals start from what they have already learned. Assign a buddy who is not the manager, someone the starter can ask the questions they would rather not ask their boss. At the end of the probation period, the review should hold no surprises, because the conversations have already happened in one-to-ones.
One-to-ones, feedback and performance conversations
The one-to-one is the manager's most important recurring meeting and the one most often cancelled. Hold it on a fixed rhythm, keep it even when busy, and make it the report's meeting rather than yours. A simple agenda works: what is on their mind, progress on priorities and blockers, development, and anything you need to raise. Status updates belong in the team's planning rhythm, not here.
Feedback is most useful when it is specific, timely and about behaviour rather than personality. Describe what happened, its effect and what you would like to see instead, and do it close to the event. Positive feedback deserves the same specificity, because it tells people what to repeat. Ask for feedback on your own management too, and act on it visibly, or the team will stop offering it.
Performance conversations should rarely be a surprise. If someone is falling short, say so early, describe the gap against the scope's outcomes, agree what good looks like and by when, and offer the support you can give. Document the conversation. Most performance problems improve when they are named clearly and early; the ones that become formal processes are usually those that were left too long. Where a formal process is needed, follow your organisation's policy and involve the people team, since the employment side is outside the scope of a marketing guide.
Skills matrices and development plans
A skills matrix lists the skills the team needs down the side and the people across the top, with a simple rating of each person in each skill. It shows two things at once: where the team as a whole is thin, and what each person could build next. It does not show who could run a specific recurring task tomorrow, which is what the coverage matrix in the guide to reducing key-person risk in a marketing team records. A high rating in a skill does not by itself put a name against a task in the coverage matrixA table of a team's recurring tasks and the accounts behind them, recording who can do each one unaided today, so work only one person can do becomes visible.; that takes having run the task itself. The skills themselves can be drawn from the digital marketing skills map and the marketing careers skills section, which describe the skills from the practitioner's side; the manager's job is to choose the ones the team needs and assess honestly. AI skills belong in the same matrix, and the guide to building AI skills in a marketing team covers assessing them from real work and training on the team's own tasks.
Development plans come from the matrix and from each person's ambitions. Keep each plan to a small number of skills, because a long list gets nothing done. For each skill, name a way to practise it in real work (a stretch assignment, owning a test, presenting to stakeholders), the support available (pairing, a course, time with a specialist or an agency) and how progress will be judged. Review the plan in one-to-ones, not once a year. The Chartered Institute of Marketing's emphasis on continuing professional development points the same way: growth comes from deliberate, recorded practice rather than occasional training days. Each quarter, one goal from the plan can sit beside the person's results on the objective sheet that the tutorial on setting objectives for each marketer from the team plan builds. The marketing team skills matrix template lays out the matrix and the plans as fields, from the rating scale and the evidence behind each rating to the gap decisions and review date.
Corbel Insurance rebuilds its hiring process
Corbel Insurance, an invented specialist insurer, hired 3 marketers in a year and lost 2 of them within 6 months. The head of marketing found that the job descriptions listed 15 tools each and that interviews were unstructured conversations. For the next hire she wrote a one-page scope with 4 outcomes, replaced the tool list with 5 must-have skills, and added a 90-minute task: prioritising 12 real but anonymised requests and explaining the choices. Each of the 3 interviewers scored the same 6 questions. The successful candidate passed probation, and the team used the same scope to agree her first-quarter goals and a development plan covering stakeholder reporting and paid social.
The structural side of growing a team, including when to add a layer of management, is covered in team models and organisation design, and the team structure hub maps common people problems to the right guide.
Common mistakes
- Advertising before scoping. A copied job description attracts the wrong pool and gives interviews nothing to test against. Write the scope first.
- Hiring for tools, not judgement. Tools can be learned in weeks; prioritisation and commercial judgement take years. Make the must-haves the hard-to-learn skills.
- Trusting the interview alone. Fluent candidates are not always effective ones. Add a realistic, proportionate task.
- Leaving onboarding to chance. Missing access and unclear priorities waste a new starter's best months. Plan the first weeks and assign an owner.
- Cancelling one-to-ones. Each cancellation tells the report they rank below everything else. Protect the slot.
- Saving feedback for the annual review. Late feedback is unfair and unhelpful. Give it close to the event.
- Development plans nobody reads. A plan reviewed once a year is a form. Keep it short and discuss it often.
