Why an empty role is a planning decision as well as a hiring one
The marketing management pillar counts what happens when a role is empty among the things a manager manages, beside who is on the team and how each person grows. Two operations pages cover the edges of that period. The tutorial for handing over a leaver's work collects a leaver's tasks, open work, accounts, files, relationships and know-how while they are still in the building, and gives each item a new owner; where nobody can take an item on, it asks the team to say so and settle what becomes of it. The guide to reducing key-person risk builds cover for holidays and illness before they happen. Neither runs the period in between, when the work has nominal owners but the hours that used to do it have gone.
That gap is a planning problem before it is a hiring one. The team's capacity has dropped, while the requests arriving through Request IntakeThe single route through which every request reaches the marketing team, usually a short form, so work is triaged and checked before it starts. have not. If the manager does nothing, the absent role's work can drift to whoever sits nearest, with each person adding a little to an already full week, quality sliding and the plan carrying on as if the team were whole. The guide to prioritising work and capacity draws on writing in the Harvard Business Review for the point that organisations go wrong less through poor choices than through declining to choose, so that everything becomes a priority. A vacancy is a sharp case of it: absorbing everything is itself a choice, made by default and paid for by the people covering.
The manager's own time belongs in the same decision. The pillar describes the move into management, as the Chartered Institute of Marketing does, as a change from carrying out the work to directing it. Stepping back into the empty seat feels responsible and can be right for a named, short piece of work, but a manager who quietly takes on the whole role stops managing the rest of the team just when the team needs that attention. Treat any work the manager picks up as an item in the cover plan, visible and time-limited, like everything else.
Before you start
- The handover record, if the leaver's handover ran. It lists recurring tasks, open work, accounts, relationships and procedures, each with a new owner or a note that nobody could take it. If nobody handed over, build the list with the inventory for taking over marketing, which starts from accounts, live spend and what the calendar already promises. A handover recordOne document, kept by a coordinator, listing everything a departing marketer owns: tasks, open work, accounts, suppliers and know-how, each with a new owner. settles who owns each item; it does not restore the hours the leaver spent on them, which the cover plan has to find.
- The team's coverage matrix from the key-person guide, if there is one, showing who else can already do each task. Because a coverage matrixA table of a team's recurring tasks and the accounts behind them, recording who can do each one unaided today, so work only one person can do becomes visible. records what each person can do unaided today, it separates cover that is ready from cover that would need training first.
- The quarter's plan on a page and each person's objectives, so the cover can be tested against what the team committed to.
- Each remaining person's current load: their recurring work, their open items and the hours they genuinely have.
- The recruitment position: whether the role will be refilled, whether recruitment is approved and the earliest plausible start, from whoever owns hiring in the organisation. Treat every date as provisional until someone has started.
- Who can approve interim help: the budget holder for any freelance or agency cost, under the organisation's own rules.
The steps
List everything the role was carrying
Start from the handover record and turn it into one list of everything the role did or owned: routines, open projects, objectives and key results, accounts and admin rights, supplier and agency relationships, standing requests from other teams, and the informal jobs that never reached a job description, such as being the person sales asked for quick edits. For each item, note what depends on it and when it next falls due. Add the role's share of any KPIA metric tied directly to an objective. or key result in the quarter's plan, because a result with no hours behind it is an item too. Check the procedures the leaver owned: each procedureThe written way of doing one recurring task: who owns it, what starts it, the steps in order, checks and exceptions, so anyone qualified gets the same result. needs a named owner who keeps it current, as the SOP tutorial requires, even if nobody runs the task for a while.
Decide for each item: stop, pause, cover, buy in or wait
Take each item in turn and choose one of five outcomes. Stop it if it no longer earns its place; pause it if it might, with a date to look again; cover it inside the team if someone has the skill and can make room; buy it in from a freelancer or an agency if it is bounded, specialist or both; or let it wait for the new starter if nothing is harmed by the delay. Before stopping anything whose purpose nobody remembers, ask the people who receive it why it began, which is the test Chesterton's fence applies before anything is removed. The tutorial on reviewing recurring marketing work gives the method for judging a routine against evidence and trying a stop as a pause, and a vacancy is a natural moment to apply it to the absent role's routines first.
When choosing between covering and buying in, the guide to working with freelance writers is clear that a freelancer adds hours on bounded work with briefs ready, not review time or approvals, and that an agency fits work calling for sustained specialist attention, while weighing in-house staff against an agency sets out the specialist depth and surge capacity an agency adds. Give every item one accountable owner, as the RACI matrix insists, including the items that are paused or waiting, so that somebody notices if one needs to come back early.
Check the cover against each person's capacity
Add up what each person is now being asked to carry: their own role, the items they are covering and any extra coordination the gap creates. Compare it with the hours they actually have, using the method the prioritising guide applies to the team as a whole, and check by skill as well as in total, because one specialist can be overloaded while others have room. Where a person's list does not fit, go back to the previous step and move an item to stop, pause, buy in or wait; do not ask them to absorb it. Keep the number of items each person has open at once within what they can finish, as the work in progress guide explains, since a covering colleague with a growing queue finishes less, not more. Talk the list through with each person before it is final, and ask what in their own work could slip without anyone seeing. The colleague's half of that conversation, from agreeing what of their own work pauses to handing the items back and writing the period up, is the tutorial on stepping up to cover an empty role.
Set the authority that goes with each piece of cover
Covering someone's work without the authority that came with it produces a queue at the manager's desk. For each covered item, agree the level of authority the person holds, using the levels in the guide to delegating marketing work: whether they act and report afterwards, act and flag it straight away, recommend and proceed unless someone objects, or bring options for a decision. Choose the level by what a wrong call would cost. Changes that are cheap to undo can sit with the person covering; anything hard to reverse, such as a new commitment to a supplier or leaving a channel, stays at a lower level, the distinction drawn by one-way and two-way door decisions.
For a freelancer or agency taking on live accounts, run the agency onboarding checklist, which serves a freelance specialist as well, so access, baselines and the approval route are settled before they change anything. Grant that access through the team's review of access to marketing tools rather than by passing on the leaver's login.
Change the quarter's plan and objectives openly
A team that has lost a role cannot deliver the plan it agreed with that role in it. Revisit the plan on a page: which initiatives continue at full pace, which slow down, which wait for the new starter and which are dropped. Then rewrite the affected objectives the way the tutorial on individual objectives changes any objective mid-quarter: on the sheet, with the date and the reason, and a new BaselineAn estimate of what a metric would have done without a given change, campaign or promotion, against which the effect is measured. where the measure has moved. Objectives that belonged to the role either pass to someone covering, with their agreement and a measure they can influence, or are marked as paused until the new starter arrives. Record the cover decisions in the team's Decision LogA running record, one row per decision, of what changed and why, what was expected, who decided and when the result will be checked., or in the marketing decision log template if the team keeps none, so the reasoning survives a later question about why a result was not chased.
Tell requesters, stakeholders and agencies what changes
The people who send work to the team need to know before they find out by waiting. Tell each group what is changing, from when, and what they can expect instead: which requests the team is still taking, which will be slower, which are paused and who now handles what. If the team publishes service levels, revise them, since the tutorial on service levels for marketing requests reviews its catalogue whenever the team changes. Tell agencies and freelancers who worked with the leaver who their contact now is and what that person can approve. Give leadership the same message in one place, with the items stopped or paused, the objectives changed and the expected date the role is filled, so that the slower pace reads as a decision rather than as a team falling behind.
Scope the role again before it is advertised
A vacancy is a chance to change a role, because nobody's job has to move. Before anyone copies the old job description, use what the cover plan has shown. Items that stopped without complaint may not belong in the new role at all; items a colleague covered well may stay with them, if that suits their development and the people team agrees the change to their job; items bought in may be better left with a supplier. What remains is the gap the new role must fill. Write the scope from that gap, with its outcomes, decisions and interfaces, as the guide to hiring and developing marketers sets out before any advert is drafted. The recruitment process, its approvals, pay and contract terms stay with the people team under the organisation's own policy.
Hand the work to the new starter in stages
The new starter does not take on the whole role on their first day. Plan the order in which items return: first the work that was waiting and depends on nobody else, then the covered items, beginning with any the manager took on and then those that weigh heaviest on the colleague holding them, and last the arrangements with freelancers or agencies, which may continue for a while by design. Each colleague who covered an item passes it on the way the leaver should have: a short walk-through, a run done together and a run the new starter does alone. The team's onboarding pack for new marketers covers access by role and a safe first task, and the hiring guide covers the first weeks; the cover plan adds the list of items to take back and who to take each one from.
End the cover and keep what the gap showed
Close the cover plan item by item, on a stated date, rather than letting arrangements fade. Return each covering colleague's authority and objectives to their own role, end or confirm each supplier arrangement, and decide about every paused item: restart it, stop it for good or keep it paused with a reason. Then look back at what the vacancy revealed. Work that nobody missed is evidence for the next recurring work review; tasks only the leaver could do are gaps for the coverage matrix; slower turnaround that nobody objected to may say something about the service levels. Share the outcome with each person who covered, including what they carried and for how long, so that it reaches their one-to-ones and development plan rather than fading from the team's memory.
The cover plan at a glance
Keep the decisions in one table that the whole team can see. The columns below are general practice; add or drop them to suit the team.
| Column | What it holds | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Item | A routine, project, result, account or relationship the role carried | Nothing stays assigned to someone who has gone |
| Depends on it | Who or what is affected if it slips, and when it is next due | Shows which items cannot wait |
| Decision | Stop, pause, cover, buy in or wait | Makes the choice explicit instead of letting it drift |
| Owner | One accountable person, even for paused or waiting items | Someone notices if the item needs to come back |
| Authority | The level the person covering holds for this item | Keeps decisions from queuing for the manager |
| Review or end date | When the decision is looked at again, or the cover ends | Keeps temporary arrangements temporary |
| Return to the new starter | When the item comes back and from whom | Turns the handover into a sequence |
The five decisions suit different kinds of work, and each has its own way of going wrong.
| Decision | Suits | Watch for |
|---|---|---|
| Stop | Work with no purpose anyone can state, or no evidence it earns its place | Stopping before asking who relies on it |
| Pause | Work that may matter but can be missed for a while | Pauses that are never reviewed |
| Cover | Work a colleague can do once room is made in their own list | Cover piled on top of a full week |
| Buy in | Bounded or specialist work with briefs ready | Buying drafting hours when review is the constraint |
| Wait | Work that can be delayed with nothing harmed | Waiting items with a deadline nobody checked |
The team structure hub maps the wider people problems, from handovers between teams to hires who take too long to contribute, to the guides that deal with each.
A climbing centre group covers its content lead's role (illustrative)
Tuskavarn Climbing covers its content lead's role
Tuskavarn Climbing, an invented group of 3 indoor climbing centres, had a marketing team of 5: a head of marketing, a content and social lead, an email specialist, a paid media marketer and a part-time designer. The content and social lead resigned with 4 weeks' notice, and a replacement was approved with an expected start 14 weeks after her last day.
The handover moved her admin rights and files before she left and produced a record of 12 items, which the head of marketing sorted. Two were paused: the weekly social round-up, after the centre managers confirmed it had been started for a competition that ended a year earlier, and the blog guides. Social posting was covered by the email specialist at 3 posts a week per centre instead of daily, and the members' monthly newsletter moved to her in a shorter format at the "act, then tell me straight away" level. Six course and taster pages were bought in from a freelance writer, working from briefs the lead had finished before she left. A partner video with a local mountaineering club waited for the new starter. The head of marketing considered writing the course pages herself and gave them to the freelancer instead, keeping her own time for the team's one-to-ones.
The quarter's key result for organic course enquiries, set at 450 against a baseline of 380, was rewritten on the sheet as "hold at 380" with the date and the reason. Centre managers were told that content requests would take 10 working days instead of 5. The role was re-scoped as a content lead owning organic enquiries; social stayed with the email specialist, whose objectives were rewritten to include it after the people team agreed the change. The new starter picked up the waiting partner video in her second week, took the newsletter back from the email specialist in her fourth and took over the course pages from the freelancer in her sixth, once the last of them had been delivered. At the close, the blog guides restarted and nobody had asked for the round-up, which was stopped for good.
Common mistakes
- Letting the work drift to whoever is nearest. Without a decision for each item, the gap lands on whoever says yes first and the plan carries on as if nothing had changed. List the items and decide each one.
- Covering everything. Absorbing the whole role means nothing was chosen. Stop or pause enough work that the cover fits the hours people really have.
- The manager filling the seat. A manager doing the absent role stops managing the rest of the team. Take on named items openly, if any, and hand them back first among the covered items.
- Cover without authority. A colleague holding the work but not the decisions sends every call back to the manager. Set the level for each item.
- Keeping the old plan. Objectives written for a full team turn into a list of misses. Change them on the sheet, with the date and the reason.
- Telling nobody. Requesters and agencies who discover the change by waiting can stop trusting the team. Say what is changing before it shows.
- Copying the old job description. The vacancy is the moment to change the role. Scope it from what the cover plan showed.
- Cover that never ends. Temporary arrangements left open become permanent overload. Close each item on a date and record what each person carried.
