Why service economics differ from product economics
The site's unit economics guides are written around online orders. The contribution margin guide builds contribution from product cost, fulfilment, payment fees and returns, and derives a break-even cost per acquisitionHighest cost per acquisition at which a sale still covers its variable costs. from it. The logic carries over to services, but three things change.
First, the unit is a job, not an order, and jobs vary far more. A routine service and an emergency repair can differ in price, time and materials by a wide margin, so one average job hides most of what matters.
Second, the path from interest to revenue has more steps that can fail. An enquiry may need a call back, a site visit and a quote before it is booked; a booking may not happen because the customer is out or cancels; a completed job may need a return visit at the firm's cost. Each step loses some of the value marketing paid for.
Third, the business sells capacity it cannot store. An hour an engineer or practitioner is not working is gone, while a job that arrives when the diary is full may cost more to serve or not be served at all. The local ads guide puts it simply: treat the ad budget as a valve on the order book rather than a fixed monthly cost. That is a unit economics statement, and this page shows why.
Margin per job
Start with each main type of job and work out what it leaves after the costs that come with it. The comparison of gross margin and contribution margin explains why contribution marginRevenue left after every cost that varies with each sale., which subtracts every cost that rises with each sale, is the right base for marketing targets. For a job, the costs that rise with it are usually:
| Cost | Varies with each job when | Where the figure comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Labour | It is paid per job or per hour worked, as with subcontractors or staff paid for hours on jobs | Timesheets or job sheets and the pay rate |
| Materials and parts | Always | Job sheets and supplier invoices |
| Travel and vehicle | Fuel, mileage or time travelling are recorded per job | Mileage logs or vehicle costs per visit |
| Subcontractors | Work is passed on for a fee | Subcontractor invoices |
| Card and booking fees | A fee is charged per payment or booking | Payment and booking statements |
| Warranty and call-backs | Some jobs need a free return visit | Job records of return visits |
Whether labour belongs in this table depends on how the business pays for it, and that is a question to agree with whoever keeps the accounts rather than one to rule on here. Labour paid only for the hours worked rises with each job; salaried staff are paid whatever the diary holds, so in the short run their cost does not change with the next job. Some businesses have both. Write down the treatment and use it every time.
Work out margin per job for the job types that make up most of the work, and group the rest. Use the business's own job records over a period long enough to cover its seasonalityPredictable, repeating changes in demand tied to the calendar, such as months, holidays, weekdays or hours., and read small samples with care, as the guide to reading small numbers advises: with only a handful of jobs of one type, the average can be well off its true level.
From enquiry to booked job
Marketing pays for enquiries: calls, forms, messages, directory leads. The business earns from booked and completed jobs. In between sit the steps that lose value: an enquiry that is not answered in time, a site visit that does not lead to a quote, a quote the customer does not accept.
Count each step from the business's own records, for each main job type and source:
- Enquiries received, by source.
- Quotes or visits given, where the job needs one.
- Bookings made.
- Completed jobs invoiced.
The share of enquiries that become booked jobs is the service business's lead-to-customer rateShare of leads created in a period that became paying customers.. Some jobs, such as routine services, book straight from the enquiry; others, such as larger repairs or installations, need a quote and lose many enquiries at that step. The rates differ by source as well: a referral or a repeat customer usually books more readily than a first-time enquiry from a directory. Where the path is long and the job large, closer to a sales pipeline than a booking, the guide to valuing a lead by pipeline stage applies the same idea stage by stage.
No-shows, cancellations and rework
A booking is not yet revenue. Three things reduce what a booking is worth.
No-shows. The customer is out, or does not turn up for an appointment. The no-show rateThe share of booked appointments, demos, consultations or event registrations where the person does not attend. is the share of booked appointments that end this way, as the glossary entry on no-show rate defines it. A no-show earns nothing and often costs the travel and time of a wasted visit, or an empty slot that cannot be refilled at short notice.
Cancellations. The customer cancels in advance. A cancellation with notice may cost little if the slot can be refilled, and a lot if it cannot. Record cancellations separately from no-shows, because their cost differs.
Rework. The job needs a free return visit: a fault not fixed first time, a part that failed, a complaint. Rework uses labour, travel and sometimes materials without new revenue, so it lowers the margin of the job type it belongs to.
Build each into the value of a booking: the margin of a completed job, less the expected cost of the no-shows, cancellations and rework that come with that kind of booking. Read the rates from your own records by job type and, where possible, by source. Directory and marketplace leads often behave differently from referrals, and the difference matters when choosing where to spend.
Capacity and the value of the next job
The value of the next job depends on the diary. With spare capacity, the next job uses time that would otherwise be idle; it is worth its full margin, and arguably more if the labour is salaried, because the labour cost is already paid. With the diary full, the next job is worth much less: it pushes another job back, needs overtime or a subcontractor at higher cost, or is not served at all.
The local ads pages describe what happens when that is ignored. The guide to Local Services Ads notes that when the diary is full, more leads become missed callbacks, which become poor reviews and lower ranking, and advises lowering the budget or pausing rather than letting leads go unanswered. The healthcare industry guide makes the same point for practitioners' time, which is fixed in the short run, so the marketing plan is a capacity plan first. And the diagnosis of ad spend up with sales flat lists demand the business could not serve as one cause of spend that rose without results.
In unit economics terms, the break-even cost per booked job is not one number but two: one for weeks with room in the diary and a lower one, or none, for weeks without. The marginal returns and forecasting guide makes the general case that spend should be judged on the return of the next unit, not the average; for a service business, capacity is often what makes the next unit worth less.
Repeat and follow-on work
Some service customers come back: an annual service, a regular appointment, a client who returns with new work. A first job may also lead to a larger one, such as a repair that becomes a replacement. That later value is real, and it can justify paying more than one job's margin to win a customer.
Treat it with care. Count only repeat and follow-on work your records show actually happens, from customers won through each source, over a period you can observe. Lifetime value method belongs to the guide to lifetime value and acquisition cost, which explains how to estimate it and the payback period finance will accept. The professional services industry guide makes the matching point for firms: cost per new client only makes sense next to the fee value and expected length of the relationship.
A simple and conservative approach is to set break-even on the first job alone, and treat repeat work as a buffer that makes the target safer, rather than as a reason to pay more. Raise the target only when the repeat rate is well measured and stable.
Setting break-even and target cost per booked job
Bring the pieces together for each main job type:
- Margin per completed job, after the variable costs agreed with whoever keeps the accounts.
- Value per booked job, after the expected cost of no-shows, cancellations and rework for that type of booking.
- Break-even cost per booked job: the value per booked job. Paying more than this loses money on the first job.
- Break-even cost per enquiry: the break-even per booked job multiplied by the share of enquiries that book, by source where the rates differ.
- Target: below break-even by a margin the owner wants to keep, and lower again, or paused, in weeks when the diary is full.
The break-even calculator and the CPA calculator do the arithmetic. Refresh the inputs when prices, pay rates, material costs or booking rates change, and check the result against actual cost per booked job each month.
A plumbing firm's cost per booked job (illustrative)
Wendlemay Plumbing sets break-even cost per booked job
Wendlemay Plumbing, an invented plumbing and heating firm, pays its engineers for the hours they work on jobs, so it agrees with its bookkeeper to count labour as a variable cost. It works out two job types from six months of job sheets.
A boiler service is priced at £95 and takes about an hour at £30 of labour, with £10 of parts and £12 of van and travel cost: £43 of contribution. A repair averages £240, with 2.5 hours of labour at £75, £55 of parts and £15 of van cost: £95 of contribution.
Bookings lose some of that. 10% of booked services end as no-shows, each costing about £25 in wasted travel and time, so a booked service is worth 0.9 × £43 − 0.1 × £25, about £36. Repairs have 5% no-shows: 0.95 × £95 − 0.05 × £25, about £89. Break-even cost per booked job is therefore about £36 for a service and £89 for a repair.
Enquiries convert differently. 80% of service enquiries book directly, so break-even per service enquiry is about £29. Repairs need a quote: 60% of repair enquiries get one and half of those book, so 30% of enquiries become bookings and break-even per repair enquiry is about £27. The owner wants to keep at least half of each booking's value, so the targets are £18 per booked service and £45 per booked repair.
In weeks when the engineers' diaries are full a fortnight ahead, an extra repair needs overtime at time and a half, which cuts its contribution to about £58, and an extra service pushes a paying job back. Wendlemay lowers its search and directory bids in those weeks and raises them when the diary opens up. It counts repeat annual services as a buffer, not as part of the break-even.
Common mistakes
- One average job. Services and repairs, or short and long appointments, have different margins and need different targets.
- Leaving out travel and rework. Both are paid on many jobs and both lower the margin per job.
- Counting enquiries as bookings. Quotes that never book and enquiries never answered are part of the cost of each booked job.
- Ignoring no-shows and cancellations. A booking is not revenue until the job is done and invoiced.
- The same target in full and quiet weeks. The next job is worth less when the diary is full; the budget should move with capacity.
- Paying for repeat work you have not measured. Count only the repeat and follow-on work your records show, or keep it as a buffer.
- Ruling on labour without the bookkeeper. Whether labour is variable depends on how it is paid; agree it and keep it consistent.
