Why audit before planning
The PR KPIs guide asks for targets set against a BaselineAn estimate of what a metric would have done without a given change, campaign or promotion, against which the effect is measured. and reviewed on a fixed cadence, and the media monitoring and coverage reporting guide sets up a coverage logThe consistent record of every piece of coverage, by title, tier, story, prominence, message, sentiment and link, from which PR measures are counted. from now on. Neither looks back. An organisation starting a new PR programme, hiring a PR lead or an agency, or rethinking one that has drifted, needs to know what the past actually produced before it can set targets that mean anything.
Without an audit, planning runs on impressions. People remember the big story and the embarrassing one, not the pattern. They assume the titles they would like to appear in are the ones that carried coverage, and that the media list is current. An audit replaces those impressions with a record: which titles covered the organisation and its competitors, on which themes, in what tone, carrying which messages, quoting whom. It also checks the machinery behind coverage, from the media list to the newsroom page to whether journalists' calls were answered, which is often where the cheapest improvements are found.
The audit feeds directly into the tutorial on writing a PR plan: its findings become the plan's situation section and its baseline becomes the starting point for the plan's measures. Other parts of the marketing estate have their own audits, such as the social media presence audit and the brand consistency audit; this one covers earned media.
Before you start
- Agree what the audit is for. Usually it is the baseline and the fixes for a new plan. Write that down, so the audit stays proportionate to the decision it informs.
- Find the records. Past coverage logs, monitoring reports, the media list, the enquiry log if there is one, past releases and the newsroom page. Gaps in the records are findings too.
- Read the measures guides. The PR KPIs guide sets the ladder from outputs to outcomes, the share of voice guide defines the measure, and the monitoring guide sets the coverage log's fields. The audit uses the same definitions, so that the baseline can be compared with what the new programme reports.
- Decide who runs it. Someone with time and access to the records codes the coverage; someone the journalists will speak to candidly holds the conversations. They can be the same person.
- Prepare to be honest. An audit that only confirms what the team hoped is not worth the time. Agree in advance that weak findings will be reported as plainly as strong ones.
The steps
Set the period and the competitor set
Choose the period the audit covers and write it down. It should be long enough to show a pattern and recent enough to reflect the organisation as it is; a major change, such as a rebrand or a new market, may be the natural start. Choose the competitors whose coverage will be compared; earned share of voice needs a defined set, as the monitoring guide explains, and the useful set is the organisations the audience actually considers, not every business in the sector. Choose the titles that count as target titles for the comparison, ideally those the audience reads, and keep the same period, competitors and titles throughout so the comparison is fair.
Gather past coverage
Collect every piece of coverage of the organisation in the period, from monitoring reports, past coverage logs, search, the titles' own archives, the newsroom's coverage links and colleagues' memories, checked against the source. Do the same for each competitor in the target titles. The monitoring guide lists the sources to cover, from online news and print to broadcast, trade titles and social platforms. Record where each piece came from, because gaps in monitoring are themselves a finding. Do not filter as you go; pieces that went badly belong in the audit as much as those that went well.
Code each piece for title, theme, tone and message
Give every piece the same set of codes, using the fields in the monitoring guide's coverage log: date, title and writer, tier, the story or campaign that produced it or whether it was unprompted, prominence, which message appeared, which spokesperson was quoted, tone, links and competitors mentioned. Add a theme code for what the piece was about. Write short rules for the judgement fields, tone and prominence especially, before coding, and have a second person code a sample to check the rules are applied consistently. The table under the steps sets out what to record.
Compare share of voice with competitors
From the coded pieces, calculate earned Share of VoiceYour share of market visibility. for the organisation and each competitor in the target titles over the period, as the share of voice guide defines it. Look beyond the total: share by title, by theme and by tone often says more. Where competitors dominate a theme or a title the organisation wants, note what kind of stories carried them there. If the business also tracks share of searchSearches for a brand as a share of searches for all the brands in its category, read as a trend beside the brand tracker and market share., the guide to tracking share of search shows how to read the two together. Counts in an audit are often small, so read them as the guide to reading small numbers advises: a difference of a few pieces may be noise.
Check the media list against where coverage came from
Compare the media list with the titles and writers that actually produced coverage. Three patterns are common. Writers who covered the organisation but are not on the list are relationships nobody is maintaining. Writers on the list who never covered the organisation or the subject may be the wrong writers, or may never have been pitched a story that fitted them. Titles the audience reads that carried competitors but not the organisation are the gaps the plan should close. Check the list's fields against the ones the media relations and pitching guide sets out, and note contacts that have moved or left.
Review the newsroom, releases and assets
Read the newsroom page as a journalist on deadline would: are the press contacts named and current, are the releases dated and findable, are the images usable, the facts correct and the spokesperson biographies up to date? Then read the releases issued in the period against the coverage they produced: which releases led to coverage in target titles and which produced nothing? The press releases and online newsroom guide sets out what each should contain. Note the fixes, such as a departed contact still listed or images too small to print, which can be made before the first pitch of the new programme.
Review spokespeople and how enquiries were handled
List who was quoted in the period, on which subjects, and how often the organisation appeared with no spokesperson or with "did not respond" or "declined to comment". Check the enquiry log, if there is one, for what was asked, how quickly it was answered and by whom; if there is no log, ask the people who answer the phones and the general inbox what journalists' calls they remember. Gaps here, such as no named expert for a subject the press asks about or calls that went unanswered, are often the cheapest problems to fix and the most damaging to leave.
Ask a few journalists how they see you
Speak to a small number of journalists who cover the field, including some who have covered the organisation and some who have covered only competitors. Introduce the conversation honestly as research for the organisation's PR review, following the principles the site's research guides draw from the MRS, as the guide to interviewing industry experts and the research methods hub describe them: participation is voluntary and informed, people are told who is asking and why, and the conversation is never a disguise for a pitch. Ask how they see the organisation, what they would want from it, how it compares with competitors as a source, and what made it hard to work with. Do not pitch a story in the same conversation.
Write the findings and the baseline
Bring the findings together in a short report. A SWOT is a convenient frame: strengths and weaknesses from the coverage, materials and spokespeople; opportunities and threats from competitors' coverage and what journalists said. Then write the baseline: the figures from the coded coverage that the new programme's measures will be compared with, such as coverage in target titles, message inclusion, spokesperson quotes and earned share of voice, each with its period and definition. Pass the baseline to whoever sets each KPIA metric tied directly to an objective., as the PR KPIs guide describes. End with a short list of fixes, each with an owner, separating those that can be made at once from those that belong in the PR plan.
What to record for each piece
The fields follow the coverage log in the monitoring guide, with a theme field added for the audit. Using the same fields means the baseline and the new programme's reports can be compared directly.
| Field | What to record | What it reveals in an audit |
|---|---|---|
| Date, title, section and writer | Where and when the piece ran, and who wrote it | Which writers and titles actually cover the organisation |
| Tier | The title's agreed priority for the objective | Whether coverage reached the titles that matter |
| Source of the story | Which release, pitch or campaign produced it, or whether it was reactive or unprompted | Which activities earned coverage and which did not |
| Theme | What the piece was about | The topics the organisation is known for, and those it is missing from |
| Prominence | Headline, lead, substantial or passing mention | Whether the organisation was the story or a footnote |
| Message | Which key message appeared, if any | Whether coverage said what the organisation wanted said |
| Spokesperson | Who was quoted, or whether nobody was | Gaps in spokespeople and subjects |
| Tone | Positive, neutral or negative, by written rules | The balance of coverage and the themes that attract criticism |
| Competitors mentioned | Which competitors appeared in the same piece | Head-to-head coverage and comparative framing |
| Link | Whether the piece links, and to which page | Search and referral value already earned |
Beyond the coverage itself, the audit can draw on other evidence the organisation already holds. A brand health report shows whether awareness and consideration moved in the period, and social listeningMonitoring public conversation about a brand, its category, competitors and the problems it solves, away from the brand's own accounts., set up as the social listening guide describes, shows how coverage travelled on social platforms. Neither is required for a first audit, but both help explain what the coded coverage shows.
A café chain's PR audit (illustrative)
Ebruchane Cafes audits its PR before hiring a PR lead
Ebruchane Cafes, an invented chain of 9 neighbourhood cafés, plans to hire its first PR lead and wants the role to start from evidence. The marketing manager runs an audit of the past 12 months, comparing the chain with 3 competitors in 8 target titles: city lifestyle sections, 2 regional business titles and a hospitality trade title.
Gathering coverage from saved links, search and the titles' archives produces 31 pieces about Ebruchane Cafes. Coding them shows that 22 came from food bloggers and listings sites, 6 from city lifestyle sections and only 1 from a business title, a short mention of a new opening. In the same period the 3 competitors earned 14 pieces in the 2 business titles, mostly about sourcing and staff training. Earned share of voice in the 8 target titles is about 1 in 6 of the pieces that mention any of the 4 chains, and almost none in the business titles. Tone is mostly positive; the 2 negative pieces both concern a closure that was not explained.
The media list has 40 names, of whom 11 produced no coverage of any café brand in the period and 4 have moved jobs. The newsroom page still names a former operations manager as the press contact. A colleague who answers the general inbox recalls 2 journalists' emails that went unanswered.
The marketing manager speaks to 3 journalists, each told at the start that this is research for the chain's PR review and not a pitch. Two say they had tried to reach the company and heard nothing. One says the chain's sourcing story would interest business readers if someone could explain the numbers.
The report sets the baseline, lists 5 fixes (update the newsroom contact, route the general inbox to the press contact, clean the media list, name a spokesperson for sourcing, explain closures in advance) and gives the new PR lead a clear first objective: appear in the business titles where competitors already are.
Common mistakes
- Auditing only the good coverage. Pieces that went badly explain as much as those that went well.
- Changing definitions between the audit and the reports. Use the monitoring guide's fields and the share of voice definition, so the baseline can be compared with later figures.
- Comparing with every competitor. Use the set the audience actually considers.
- Reading small counts as trends. A difference of a few pieces may be noise; say so in the report.
- Ignoring the machinery. Outdated contacts, a stale newsroom and unanswered calls are often the cheapest fixes.
- Turning journalist conversations into pitches. Introduce them honestly as research and keep them that way.
- A report with no baseline. The audit's main output is the starting point for the new programme's measures.
- Fixes with no owner. Each fix needs a name and a date, or it will wait for the plan.
The PR measurement section sets the audit beside the KPIs and the monitoring that follow it.
