Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Affiliate Marketing › Programme Management

Deciding What an Affiliate Commission Is Paid On

How to decide the order value an affiliate commission is paid on: discounts, delivery, tax, gift card sales and part returns, tied to margin and the terms.
Guideintermediate17 min readUpdated

Why the rate in the terms is not the price

A percentage commission is a rate applied to a value, and the rate is the easy half to state. The commission rate entry says the terms must name the value a rate is applied to and gives a safe starting rule. What it leaves open is the decision itself, part by part, and how to take it.

The reason it matters is arithmetic. The amount paid on an order is the rate times the base, and the business's cost is that amount plus the platform's share. The tracking guide notes that programmes capture an order value and a currency so that a percentage can be worked out; which figure the platform works the percentage from is a question for the platform. A gap between the base the terms describe and the value the platform receives is paid for by one side or the other: by the business, if partners are paid on a larger value than the margin can carry, or by partners, if they are paid on less than they were told.

This guide takes the model as chosen, a percentage of order value, and deals with what that value is. The commission structures guide covers the models, the tiers and the ceiling. The exclusions list in the terms, which names the orders that earn nothing, the rule for orders that carry a partner's code, and the accounting treatment of commission belong to other pages or to finance. What is decided here is the value of an order that does earn commission, so that the rate means one thing to the business, the platform and the partner. The programme manager decides it with a finance partner, the owner of the order system says what its value field holds, and the platform's contact says what it can receive.

The parts of an order and what each decision changes

Take a basket apart. For each part the programme has to say whether it counts towards the value commission is paid on, and each answer changes two things: what a partner earns on the order, and how much room the order leaves under the margin ceiling. The table lists the parts as choices. It is not a description of what is standard, or of how any platform treats a part. Whether the value that reaches the platform includes a part is read from the order system and checked with finance.

Part of an orderThe choiceWhat each answer changesWho settles it
Goods at their listed pricePay on the listed price, or on what the customer was charged for the goods after discountsA base before discounts pays partners on money the business does not receive and adds commission to the discount's own cost; a base after discounts follows the money receivedProgramme manager with finance
Discounts, sale prices and codesWhether each comes off the baseA discount that comes off the base lowers commission along with the price; one that does not leaves commission unchanged while the margin shrinksPromotion owner, with the code register
Delivery chargeIn the base, or outIn: partners earn on the charge as well as the goods, which fits the ceiling only if finance's margin counts the charge as revenue. Out: the base is goods only, and the same ceiling is a larger rate on a smaller baseFinance, to say how the margin counts it
TaxAs the order system sends it, or adjustedIf the margin is built on revenue net of tax, a base that includes tax is larger than the revenue it rests on, so the same rate costs more than the ceiling assumed; whether the system's figure includes tax is read from the system and confirmed with financeFinance and the order-system owner
A gift card soldIn the base, or outThe commission guide lists gift cards among products some programmes exclude. Whether a sale of one carries margin that commission can come out of is for finance to say; including it pays on a line whose margin is unconfirmedFinance
A gift card used to payThe value of the goods whatever the way of paying, or the amount paid by other meansA base on the goods keeps commission independent of how a customer pays; a base on money paid by other means falls when a card is redeemed. How a redeemed card appears in the order value is read from the order system and settled with finance, and this guide does not answer itFinance and the order-system owner
A free giftCarried at what the customer paid, which is nothing, or at a listed priceThe gift's cost belongs in the margin, not in the base; read from the order system how a free line appears, since a base taken before discounts would count a free line carried at a listed priceOrder-system owner
A bundleThe bundle price, or the sum of its partsPaying on the bundle price follows the money received, while the sum of the parts overstates it when the bundle is discounted. If one part is an excluded product or has its own category rate, decide whether the whole bundle earns at one rate, is excluded, or is splitProgramme manager with finance

A product bundle needs the closest care of the rows, because its parts can sit in different rate categories while it is sold at one price, and whatever the rule is, it has to be one that can be applied to an order without a person's judgement.

A discount and a commission add together, as the promotions guide points out. That guide asks for the sum to be priced before a sale starts, and the base chosen here is part of that sum. For a discount code issued to a partner, the code request SOP has the offer approved against the margin when the code is issued, so the discount a code gives is known before it reaches the base. Whether an order that carries a code earns anything for the code's owner is a separate rule, covered in the guide to crediting orders by code, and this guide leaves it there.

The answers sit with different people: the order-system owner says what its value field contains, finance says how the margin treats each part, and the platform says what it can receive. The programme manager lays the three beside each other and writes the base. Where an answer is not yet known, say so in the draft instead of assuming one.

Choosing the base from the margin

Start from the ceiling, not from the rate. The commission guide builds the ceiling from contribution margin, and finance supplies the margin. The guide to the marketing P&L adds that marketing's contribution view, built from finance's numbers, starts from revenue after returns and discounts. A base built on the same footing is easier to reconcile than one built on something else. The method below is this page's own, offered as general practice.

  1. Ask finance how the margin figure treats each part. Is it measured after discounts? Does it count delivery as revenue? Is it net of tax? Does it carry returns as an expected cost? Write the answers down.
  2. Give each part the same treatment in the base as in the margin. The base and the margin then describe the same money. A part counted one way in the base and the other way in the margin makes the ceiling's rate wrong.
  3. Work out the ceiling in money, then turn it into a rate. The break-even calculator and its worked page for affiliate programmes cover how a ceiling in money is reached and turned into a rate on validated order value, so the base chosen here is the denominator the worked page uses. Each part added to the base lowers the rate the ceiling can carry, and each part taken out raises it, while the money stays the same.
  4. Test the choice on past orders. Take an ordinary order and some unusual ones, with a discount code, a delivery charge, a bundle and a gift card. Work out the commission under each candidate base and compare it with the ceiling and with what is paid now.
  5. Treat a changed base as a changed price. At the same rate, a smaller base pays partners less per order. Keeping the rate and shrinking the base, or raising the rate to compensate, is a change to what partners are paid and goes through the change checklist described in the section on the terms.

The average order value on a dashboard depends on the same conventions, which that entry says differ between systems, so a dashboard's figure is not evidence of what the base is. Name the convention in the terms rather than borrowing the system's.

Part returns, exchanges and changes after approval

The exclusions in the terms deal with orders returned or cancelled as a whole. Some cases sit between that and a clean sale: part of an order is returned, an item is exchanged, and something changes after commission has been approved. Each is a choice with an effect on the ceiling and on the partner.

A part return. The options are to reverse the commission on the returned line, to reverse the whole order's commission and credit back what stayed, to leave the commission whole, or to hold approval until the returns window has closed so the amount is known. Leaving it whole pays on goods that came back. Reversing the line comes closest to paying on validated value, but needs a value for each line and a route for an adjusted amount. Reversing the order and crediting back needs a way to credit. Holding approval needs a validation period that runs past the end of the returns window, and it delays payment. The tracking guide says a postback can send an update when an order is returned or cancelled. Whether the platform accepts an amount adjustment or only a full reversal is a question for the platform. This guide names it and does not answer it.

An exchange. The options are to treat it as part of the original sale and reverse nothing, or to reverse and work the commission out again on the new item. Reversing nothing is simple, and it is neutral where the replacement is of similar value. If the new item is a product the programme excludes, or one with a different category rate, the commission then sits on something the terms would not otherwise pay, and recalculating needs line values and a platform route. An exchange that ends with a refund of the difference is a part return, and the part return rule applies to it.

A change after approval. A chargeback and a late refund can arrive after the validation period has closed and the commission has been approved. A clawback clause covers reversals after payment, and the subscription programmes guide sets out the same clause for refunds and cancellations on recurring payments. The clause says what reverses, from when and how the reversal appears in the partner's statement. The wording is for the business's legal adviser. At the month end, adjustments are among the items the close has to match.

Whether the base is held for the whole order or for each line is a choice that sits underneath each of them. An order-level base is simpler to send and check. A line-level base allows a part return, an exchange and a category rate to be handled exactly, but needs the order system to supply line values and the platform to accept them. Check both before promising partners anything line by line.

Thresholds, tiers and bonuses on the same base

The commission guide describes tiers and bonuses. Each reads a figure, and the figure needs the same definition as the base.

  • A threshold on a different value. A tier reached on tracked value before returns, with commission paid on validated value, rewards a partner for orders that came back. Having the threshold read validated value on the written base keeps the two aligned.
  • When status is fixed. If a tier can be lost after validation, a partner sees its status move when returns land. If it is fixed at the close of the period, the business bears the returns that arrive later. Choose one, and say which.
  • An order-size bonus. Whether it reads the value after discount decides whether a discount can pull an order under the line. That choice affects partners who promote discounted offers more than the others.
  • The top of the ladder. Tiers and bonuses lift the effective rate above the contracted one. Check the ceiling against the highest rate a partner can reach on the written base, not against the entry rate.

Getting the value to the platform and checking it

The base in the terms is only as good as the value the platform receives. The method below is general practice, and each step that depends on the platform is a question for it.

  1. Find out what the order system's value field holds. Gross or net of discounts, with or without delivery and tax: read it from the system and confirm it with finance. Do not assume it.
  2. Decide where the base is worked out. The business can calculate a commission value and send it, or send the order's value and rely on the platform to take parts out. Ask the platform which it supports and which fields its postback can carry. Calculating on the business's side keeps the rule in one place the business can test, but the figure sent then differs from the order total, so keep a mapping between the two for reconciliation. Relying on the platform means its settings have to match the terms. If the programme sells in more than one currency, ask the platform how it handles the amounts. This guide says nothing about that.
  3. Send test orders through each payment route. The tracing tutorial replays a journey on the live programme through each payment method, including a discount code, and the same replay suits this check. Cover a plain order, an order with a code, a delivery charge, a bundle, a gift card sold, a gift card used to pay, and a part return and an exchange where the platform lets them be tested. Read what the platform records for each and compare it with the base in the draft. Test orders earn nothing under the terms, so mark them and keep them out of the commission run. A route that records a different value from the others is a fault in the postback or in a setting, and it is fixed before the terms are published.
  4. Check live orders. Take a sample of validated orders and follow each from the order system's value, through the commission value the written base gives, to the platform's value and the commission approved. Any gap needs a reason. The month-end close tutorial matches the platform's conversions to the order system by reference, which is where a difference between the base and the value the platform holds first shows.
  5. Watch the cost per order. After a change, the CPA calculator shows what each validated order is costing the programme. Hold that against the ceiling, with the effective rate beside the contracted one.

Writing the base into the terms

The terms tutorial asks for each payable outcome to be defined with its exclusions and each rate stated beside the outcome it pays for. Add the base to that definition. An order value for commission is defined part by part, one sentence for each row of the table above, so a partner can see which parts are in and which are out. Then add the rule for a part return and an exchange, the value that tiers and bonuses read, the clause for reversals after approval, and the record that governs if the platform's figure and the business's order record differ. The wording of that last item, like the rest, is for the business's legal adviser.

As general practice, put a worked order into the terms: a short invented basket taken line by line from the prices to the base to the commission, so that a partner can check a statement against it. Replace it whenever the base changes, and keep the earlier version in the version log.

Changing the base shifts what partners earn at an unchanged rate, so the affiliate commission change checklist applies.

None of this is tax, accounting or legal advice. Whether the figure the order system sends includes tax or delivery is read from that system and confirmed with finance, the accounting treatment of commission is for finance to decide, and what is lawful or enforceable in the business's markets is for its advisers.

A games room seller sets its base (illustrative)

Illustrative example — not a real result

Crezidin Game Rooms writes down its base

Crezidin Game Rooms, an invented online shop for table football tables and dart cabinets bought for game rooms at home, pays partners 8% of order value. Its orders carry a delivery charge and, for some buyers, a gift card or a bundle. Finance finds the effective rate on orders with a code, delivery and a gift card above what it expected, and the programme manager traces what the platform receives. The postback sends the listed prices of the goods before the code discount, plus the gift card and the delivery charge, so the platform has been paying on a figure that finance's margin does not recognise.

Finance and the programme manager go through the parts of an order and settle each as the business's own choice. Items are paid after discount. Delivery is out, because finance's margin does not count the charge as revenue and the base should match it. Gift cards sold are out, as the commission guide's list of exclusions allows. A bundle is paid at the bundle price, with the whole bundle earning at one rate. The order system sends item values without tax and finance confirms it, so the base carries no tax to remove. How a redeemed gift card appears in the order value is read from the order system and settled with finance, and the worked order below leaves it out, with finance's wording going into the terms.

The worked order has a table football table listed at £500, a dart cabinet bundle at its bundle price of £300, a gift card sold for £50, a delivery charge of £40 and a 10% code discount on the goods. The code takes £50 off the table and £30 off the bundle, so the goods after discount come to £720. The platform was receiving £890: the listed goods of £800, the gift card and the delivery. At 8%, that is £71.20 on the old value against £57.60 on the written base.

Finance's ceiling for this kind of order is £62.00 of commission, once the platform's charge and the required profit are taken off. Divided by the order value, as the break-even calculator page does, that is about 7.0% of £890 but about 8.6% of £720, so the 8% in the terms fits the written base and did not fit the old value, and Crezidin checks the highest rate its quality tier can reach against the same ceiling. Crezidin decides, as its own choices to put to the platform, which may take only a full reversal, that a part return reverses the commission on the returned line and an exchange reverses nothing. A return of the bundle would reverse 8% of £270, which is £21.60. Until the platform answers, it holds approval until the returns window has closed. Its quality tier and its bonuses read validated value on the written base.

Crezidin sends three test orders through each payment route: one with a code, one with a delivery charge and a gift card in the basket, and one with a bundle. Each route is compared with the written base, and any route whose postback records a different value is fixed and tested again. The worked order goes into the terms, partners receive the notice the terms promise through the change checklist, and the next month's report shows the contracted rate of 8% beside the effective rate, tier uplift included.

The programme management hub places this guide among the other decisions the programme owner makes about economics, partners and rules.

Common mistakes

  • Quoting a rate without a base. The rate means nothing until the terms say what it applies to.
  • Letting the value the platform happens to receive define the base. It may include parts the business did not mean to pay on. Decide the base first, then make the value match.
  • Paying on the value before a discount without pricing it. Partners are paid on money the business did not receive, on top of the discount's own cost, and the ceiling has to carry that.
  • Setting the base and the margin apart. A base that treats delivery or tax differently from the margin makes the ceiling's rate wrong.
  • Assuming the platform can reverse part of an order. Ask it. It may take only a full reversal, and the plan has to work in that case too.
  • Thresholds that read another value. A tier reached on tracked value before returns pays more on orders that came back.
  • Testing one payment route. A route that records a different value only shows up when it is tried.
  • Changing the base without notice. A smaller base at the same rate is a price cut, and partners treat it as one.
  • Hiding the effective rate. Show it beside the contracted one, so the gap is visible.
  • Reading this as tax or legal advice. The order system, finance and the business's advisers answer those questions.

Frequently asked questions

Should commission be paid on the value before or after a discount code?

That is the business's choice, and each answer has a cost. A base taken after the discount follows the money the business receives, while a base taken before it pays partners on money that did not arrive and sits on top of the discount's own cost. Whichever is chosen, use the same treatment in the margin arithmetic that sets the ceiling, write it into the terms and show a worked order so a partner can check a statement against it.

Do delivery charges and tax belong in the commission base?

Neither is in or out by default. Delivery is a decision to take with finance, because the margin the ceiling comes from either counts the charge as revenue or does not, and the base should match it. What the order system's value includes is for its owner to say and finance to confirm. This guide draws no tax conclusion, and what is lawful in the business's markets is for its advisers.

What happens to commission when part of an order is returned?

The terms decide, within what the platform can carry, so ask the platform whether it accepts an adjusted amount or only a full reversal. The choice is between reversing the returned line, reversing the order, leaving the commission whole or holding approval until the returns window closes, and a clause for later reversals covers the rest.

Terms used on this page

Tools to try

Also related

Sources

  1. Performance Marketing Association — PMA

Related