Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

E-commerce Marketing › E-commerce Acquisition

Wholesale vs Direct-to-Consumer Selling

Selling wholesale through retailers and selling direct to consumers compared: reach and margin, price control, customer data, cash flow, and running both.
Comparisonintermediate11 min readUpdated

Two routes to the same shopper

Selling wholesale means the brand's customer is a business. A shop, a chain or a distributor buys the product in quantity at a trade price, puts it on its shelves or its own website, sets the price the shopper pays within whatever the two parties have agreed, and keeps the relationship with the person who buys it. The brand makes one sale to the retailer; the retailer makes many sales to shoppers. Selling direct to consumers means the brand's customer is the shopper. The brand runs the store, pays for the traffic, packs the order, answers the questions and owns the record of who bought what.

This is not the same choice as the one in the marketplaces versus own store comparison. On a marketplace the brand still sells to the shopper, sets the price and pays a fee per sale; in wholesale the retailer buys the stock outright and resells it. It is also not retail media, which the retail media guide covers as advertising bought on a retailer's site and app; a brand may buy retail media to support a wholesale listing, but the route itself is the sale to the retailer. The acquisition hub places the brand's own store among its other sources of customers; this page compares it with the route through someone else's shop.

The difference that matters most is who the customer belongs to. In the terms of the marketing mix, wholesale hands much of place, price and promotion to the retailer: the retailer decides where the product sits, what it costs on the day and whether it gets a window, an email or a discount. Direct keeps all of those with the brand and gives it the work that goes with them.

Compare table

Wholesale through retailers vs Direct to consumers

Row labelWholesale through retailersDirect to consumers
ReachShoppers who already visit the retailer, in shops and on its site; places the brand could not reach aloneOnly the shoppers the brand attracts through ads, search, social, email and word of mouth
Margin per unitLower: the retailer's margin sits between the trade price and the shelf priceHigher per unit, but acquisition, delivery, returns and service are paid by the brand
Volume and order sizeOrders arrive in quantity, often ahead of the selling seasonOrders arrive one at a time, as shoppers buy
Price controlThe retailer sets the shelf price and its own promotions within what the parties agreeThe brand sets every price and every promotion
Customer dataUsually little: the retailer holds the shopper's details and historyFull order history, contact details and marketing consent where given
Repeat purchaseA repeat buyer may return to the retailer and buy something elseThe brand can bring buyers back with flows, loyalty and service
Cash and stock riskStock is made and shipped before payment arrives; unsold stock may come back or be discountedStock is held until shoppers buy; cash comes in order by order
Brand presentationThe retailer's shelf, page template and neighboursThe brand's own pages, story, photography and packaging
Marketing workloadSelling to buyers at retailers, supporting their listings, and generating demand that sends shoppers to themGenerating every visit and converting it, from first ad to second order
Learning speedSlow: sales data arrives late, in aggregate, from the retailerFast: every visit, basket and order is visible in the brand's own analytics
MeasurementOrders from retailers plus whatever sell-through data they shareEnd to end, by channel, product and customer cohort

Where wholesale wins

Wholesale wins on reach a young brand cannot buy. A shop that already has footfall, a loyal customer base and a reputation in its category puts the product in front of shoppers who would never have searched for the brand, and lends it the shop's trust at the moment of choice. For products people like to see, touch or smell before buying, and for categories where most buying still happens in shops, a shelf can do what no amount of advertising does. The retail guide, written for retailers rather than the brands that supply them, shows how much marketing a good shop runs for its own customers; a brand on its shelves benefits from that work.

It also wins on volume and on the shape of demand. A wholesale order is a large sale made to one customer, often placed ahead of the season, which lets the brand plan production, buy materials in larger quantities and forecast with more confidence than a store taking one order at a time. Some retailers add their own marketing: a place in a catalogue, a window display, a feature in their emails, or paid placements the brand can buy through retail media. And a listing with a respected retailer is a signal in its own right. Other retailers, journalists and shoppers read it as evidence that the product is worth stocking.

In some categories wholesale is simply where the sales are. The electronics guide describes a category in which most units sell through retailers chosen on price, delivery and trust, and in which a brand's own store sees only part of the picture. A brand in a category like that cannot treat wholesale as optional. The go-to-market plan template treats a first move into wholesale as a launch in its own right, with its own buyers, channels and gates, and that is the right weight to give it.

Where direct wins

Direct wins on margin per unit and on what happens after the first order. Every sale keeps the margin a retailer would have taken, though the brand pays for acquisition, delivery and returns itself, so the comparison has to be made on contribution margin rather than on gross margin. The contribution margin and break-even guide sets out the method. Every buyer becomes a contact who can be thanked, helped and brought back, which is where lifetime value (LTV) is built and how the cost of acquiring a customer (CAC) is earned back; the LTV and CAC guide shows how the two are read together, and the repeat purchase and loyalty guide covers the second order that a wholesale route hands to the retailer.

Direct also wins on control. The brand decides which products are on sale, how they are photographed and described, which ones are launched first and what the price is on any given day. It can put its whole range online, including lines no retailer would take, and tell its own story in its own words. And it wins on the speed of learning. A brand selling direct sees within days which products, prices and messages work, from its own analytics; a brand selling only wholesale learns from reorders that arrive weeks or months later and say little about who bought or why.

The cost is that every visit has to be earned, through the channels covered in the shopping and catalogue ads guide and elsewhere, and that the brand has to build the trust a retailer would have lent it.

Running both without channel conflict

Most brands that grow end up with both routes, and the risk is that each damages the other. The store discounts and the retailer, finding itself undercut, stops promoting the line. Or the retailer covers the shoppers in its area so well that the store never meets new customers there. Running both well is a set of deliberate decisions, made once and reviewed, rather than a series of reactions.

Range. Decide which products go where. A common pattern keeps the core range in wholesale, where it earns reach, and keeps exclusives, bundles, gift sets and new lines on the brand's store, where they reward the shopper who comes direct. The guide to choosing products to promote gives each product a role; the same roles help decide which products each route carries.

Price. Hold one headline price everywhere and give the store its advantage through things other than a lower sticker: exclusives, bundles, service, delivery and loyalty. A brand that undercuts its stockists teaches them to drop the line. Any agreement with a reseller about the price it charges raises legal questions that differ by country, so take advice before writing one; this page states no rule.

Product data. Retailers' listings and the brand's own feed should describe the same product in the same way, with the same names and identifiers, so that a shopper comparing them, and the shopping platforms indexing them, see one product rather than several. The missing identifiers troubleshooting page shows how identifier gaps arise and how to fix them at the source, which matters more once a product appears in other businesses' catalogues as well as the brand's own.

Launches. Agree with stockists when a new product goes to them and when it goes on the brand's store. A launch that appears on the store first can be part of the store's appeal, or can surprise a retailer that expected it at the same time; either way it should be agreed rather than discovered.

Signposting. The brand's own homepage can carry a route for shoppers who want to buy in person, alongside the route to buy online. The homepage guide treats the homepage as routing for visitors with mixed intent, and a stockist finder is one of those routes.

Trade and bulk orders on the brand's own site. Some brands take small retailers' orders through a separate trade area of their own store, with trade prices shown only to approved accounts. It keeps the paperwork light for small stockists, but the trade area must stay clearly apart from the shopper store, so that trade prices never reach shoppers and the two kinds of customer are counted separately. Selling surplus to other sellers is a different decision again, one of the routes the guide to clearing excess stock weighs.

Measurement. Judge both routes on contribution, not revenue. Read them together, as the channel mix guide reads channels as a system, to see whether the store's presence lifts retail sales or substitutes for them: the store's new customers by area, branded search and retailer reorders, side by side. A brand selling both ways has two kinds of customer, retailers and shoppers, each with its own funnel; the marketplace measurement guide makes the case for a funnel per side, and the same idea keeps retailer recruitment from being blended into shopper numbers.

A soap maker weighs a stockist's order (illustrative)

Illustrative example — not a real result

Lathervine Soap Co. works out what a chain's order is worth

Lathervine Soap Co. is an invented handmade soap brand that has only ever sold through its own store. A chain of 40 gift shops offers to stock six of its scents, starting with an order of 4,800 bars at a trade price of £3.20 each.

On its own store a bar sells for £7.00. After £1.60 of ingredients and wrapping, £0.90 of picking, packing and delivery and £1.70 of advertising per bar sold, each bar leaves £2.80 of contribution. On the chain's order, after the same £1.60 of product cost and £0.20 per bar to deliver to the chain's warehouse, each bar leaves £1.40. Half the contribution per bar, but on 4,800 bars sold at once, paid within 60 days, with no advertising spend: £6,720 in one order, against the store's £2,600 or so in a typical month.

The brand says yes on three conditions it sets for itself. The chain gets the six core scents; the gift sets and every new scent stay on Lathervine's own store. One shelf price of £7.00 everywhere, with the store's advantage in gift wrapping, a subscription box and its loyalty points rather than a lower price. And the brand will watch, month by month, how many of its own store's new customers come from the towns where the chain has shops. Six months in, the store's new customers in those towns have risen by about a fifth while the chain has reordered twice, which the brand reads as the shelves introducing shoppers who later come direct for the gift sets.

Common mistakes

  • Comparing wholesale and direct on revenue or gross margin. Direct carries acquisition, delivery and returns costs that wholesale does not; compare contribution per unit after them.
  • Undercutting stockists on the brand's own store. A retailer that is undersold by the brand drops or buries the line.
  • Putting everything everywhere. With the whole range in shops, the store has no reason to exist; with the whole range only online, retailers have nothing worth stocking.
  • Accepting a large order without checking cash and capacity. Stock is made and shipped before payment arrives, and an order the brand cannot fulfil damages the relationship it was meant to start.
  • Letting product data drift between routes. Different names, descriptions and identifiers for the same product confuse shoppers and the platforms indexing retailers' listings.
  • Surprising stockists with launches and promotions. Agree launch order and sale timing in advance.
  • Reading each route on its own. Only reading store sales, retailer orders and branded search together shows whether one route is helping or replacing the other.
  • Signing pricing terms without advice. Agreements about what a reseller charges can raise legal questions; take advice in each market.

Frequently asked questions

Should a small brand say yes to its first wholesale order?

Only after working out what the order leaves. Compare the contribution per unit at the wholesale price, after product, packing, delivery to the retailer and any marketing support the retailer asks for, with the contribution per unit on the brand's own store after its acquisition cost. Then check the cash: whether the brand can make the stock before it is paid, and what happens to unsold units. A first stockist can be worth a thinner margin for the reach and credibility it brings, but that should be a decision made with the figures, not a reflex.

Can a brand sell more cheaply on its own store than its stockists do?

It can, but it usually damages the wholesale route. A retailer that sees the brand undercutting it has little reason to keep the line on its shelves or to promote it. Most brands that run both hold one headline price and give the direct store its advantage through exclusives, bundles, service and loyalty instead. Pricing agreements with resellers can raise legal questions that differ by country, so any agreement about what a retailer charges should be checked with someone qualified; this page gives no legal advice.

How does a brand know whether its own store is taking sales from its stockists?

By reading both routes together rather than each on its own. Watch the store's new customers, branded search and orders by area alongside retailer orders and any sell-through data stockists share. If store sales grow in the areas a retailer covers while that retailer's reorders fall, the store may be substituting; if both grow, the presence of one is helping the other. The channel mix guide covers the general method of reading channels as a system.

Terms used on this page

Frameworks

Where this page is used

Also related

Related