Hypothesis
If new sign-ups get a shorter free trial, the share who become paying customers within a fixed horizon from sign-up will hold or rise, because a nearer deadline prompts the decision sooner, provided most users reach the product's value within the shorter trial. The decision behind it is plain: shorten, lengthen or keep the product's free trial.
The proviso carries the risk. A shorter trial helps only when the people who will ever pay have usually reached the product's core value early, and the remaining days of a long trial are spent idle, waiting for the reminder that the trial is ending. When setup is slow, data takes time to import, or the value appears only after a full working cycle, a shorter trial cuts people off before they see what they would pay for. Teams also run the hypothesis the other way round: if trial users regularly ask for extensions, a longer arm tests whether more time converts more of them. The pricing and packaging guide covers where a trial sits among free plans, demos and money-back offers; this test takes the trial model as given and changes only its length. Write the direction, the arms and the activation event you expect to matter in the experiment hypothesis template before any account is assigned.
Metrics and guardrails
The primary metric is paid conversions per sign-up, counted at a fixed horizon from sign-up: of the accounts assigned to each arm, the share that is paying when the horizon is reached. The horizon is the same for both arms and longer than the longer trial, with room for the people who convert after a reminder or a grace period. The familiar Trial-to-Paid Conversion RateShare of free trials that became paying subscriptions. read at each trial's own end is not the same thing. It is measured at different moments in the two arms, and it changes meaning when one arm loses people before the trial has even started properly.
Three guardrails protect the decision. Activation rate during the trial, using the activation event defined before launch, shows whether the shorter trial still gives people time to reach value; a fall here predicts weaker retention even when paid conversions hold. Early churn after the first paid period catches people who paid under deadline pressure and then left, which turns a win in the primary metric into a loss in LTVTotal value a customer brings over time.. Support contacts per trial show whether one arm generates requests for extensions, setup help or billing complaints that cost the team time. The academy exercise on designing trial experiments for a podcast hosting service practises choosing this metric, its horizon and these guardrails for a shorter trial, then deciding whether it runs before a card-at-sign-up test.
Design
Randomise at account level, at sign-up, and keep each account in its arm. The control is the current trial length; the challenger is one alternative length. Everything else stays identical: the sign-up form, the plans and prices offered at conversion, the in-app guidance and the payment step. Store the arm on the account record, so that billing, analytics and support can all see it.
| Design element | Choice | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Unit of randomisation | Account, assigned once at sign-up | A trial is one experience from start to finish |
| Arms | Current length versus one alternative length | Each extra arm stretches an already long test |
| Read point | One fixed horizon from sign-up, the same for both arms | Puts both arms on the same clock |
| Onboarding emails | Timed by product behaviour or rescaled to each arm's length | Prevents one arm missing its reminders |
| Plans and prices | Identical in both arms | Isolates length from offer |
| Cohorts | Grouped by sign-up week and read together at the horizon | Separates seasonality from the arm |
Onboarding messages need particular care. If the welcome series and the trial-ending reminders are scheduled by day number, the shorter arm will end before some of them are sent, and the test will compare two trials and two email programmes at once. Either rescale the schedule so each arm receives the same sequence relative to its own end, or trigger messages by behaviour; the onboarding email cadence test is the design for that separate question. Read the results by sign-up CohortA group of customers who share a starting event and period, tracked together over time., using the method in the cohort analysis guide, so each weekly group is followed to the same horizon.
Sample size reasoning
Each sign-up takes the full horizon to resolve, so the sample accumulates slowly and the test is long. The inputs are the current paid conversion rate per sign-up, the smallest change that would justify altering the trial, and the confidence the team requires; the sample size and significance guide shows how they combine into the number of sign-ups each arm needs. Because the outcome is a rate per sign-up, it behaves better than revenue, but paid conversion is still a minority outcome, so modest differences take many sign-ups to see.
The smallest change worth detecting is a business figure, not a statistical one. A shorter trial brings revenue forward and reduces the cost of serving non-payers; a longer one delays revenue. The break-even calculator set up for subscription businesses helps translate those costs and the value of a paying customer into the change in conversions that would make the switch worthwhile. If the sign-up volume cannot detect that change in a reasonable time, test a larger difference in length rather than running a test that can only return a shrug. The academy checkpoint on trial and save offer experiments tests this sample size reasoning beside reading trial length at a fixed horizon and judging a card-required trial.
Duration
Enrol until the planned sample is reached, across full weekly cycles, then wait the full horizon for the last cohort, plus one paid period to read early churn. That makes the calendar length of this test far longer than its enrolment period, and the end date should be written down at the start. Avoid enrolling across a price change, a major release or a seasonal peak in sign-ups, because the arms would then contain different mixes of people at different moments, even though randomisation keeps them balanced overall.
Reading the results and the decision rule
Read once, when the last cohort has reached the horizon and passed its first paid period. Compare paid conversions per sign-up between arms with the confidence interval, then check activation, early churn and support contacts. Only then look at segments named before launch, such as company size or acquisition source. The rule, written into the plan before enrolment starts:
| Result | Decision |
|---|---|
| Alternative length has higher paid conversions per sign-up and early churn does not rise | Adopt the alternative length |
| Alternative length converts more but early churn rises or activation falls | Keep the current trial; the gain is borrowed from retention |
| No reliable difference in paid conversions per sign-up | Keep the current trial, or adopt the shorter one only if it clearly lowers cost and churn holds |
| Alternative length converts fewer | Keep the current trial |
The retention and payback guide shows how to carry the result forward: a length that converts the same share sooner shortens payback, which can matter even when the primary metric does not move.
A manuscript software firm tests a shorter trial
Quillfeather, an invented manuscript-planning tool for novelists, offers a 30-day trial and receives about 4,000 sign-ups a month. Product data shows that most writers who later pay create their first outline within five days. The team tests a 14-day trial against the current 30 days, assigning 6,000 sign-ups to each arm, and reads both at 45 days from sign-up. Paid conversions per sign-up are 9.1% for the 30-day arm and 9.6% for the 14-day arm, a difference whose 95% interval runs from roughly −0.5 to +1.5 points. Activation is level and churn after the first month is 11% in both arms, so the result is no reliable difference. Because the shorter trial halves the cost of hosting non-payers and brings revenue forward, Quillfeather adopts it under the rule's third row.
Pitfalls
Comparing at different horizons is the classic error: reading the shorter arm at its own end and the longer arm at its own end mixes timing with effect. Onboarding emails timed to one trial length are the second, as described above. The third is reading the trial-to-paid rate when sign-ups differ. If the trial length is shown on the landing page, it can change who signs up, and a per-trial rate would then compare different populations. Either assign after sign-up so both arms come from the same form, or count from the visitor rather than the sign-up.
Billing systems can also leak. If the trial length is set by a plan code, check that upgrades, plan changes and reactivations keep the account in its arm, and that the trial-ending charge fires on the right day in both. Support teams may grant extensions informally; agree a single extension policy for both arms before launch, and log every exception.
Common mistakes
Trial tests fail on their clock far more often than on their statistics. The pricing page layout test changes how plans are presented rather than how long people can try them, and the experiment library lists every design.
- Reading each arm at its own trial end. Use one fixed horizon from sign-up for both.
- Leaving day-numbered emails unchanged. The shorter arm then misses its reminders.
- Judging on conversions alone. A win bought with early churn loses value later.
- Stopping when the shorter arm looks good. It always looks good first, because it resolves first.
- Moving existing trials into the new length. Assign new sign-ups only, once.
- Letting support extend trials freely. Informal extensions blur the two arms.
