Why recurring payments change the calculator's inputs
The default calculator treats one order as the whole prize. A customer arrives, buys once, and the campaign must recover its cost from the margin on that purchase. That is a reasonable model for a shop selling furniture or a single course. It misdescribes a subscription, where the first payment is only the start of the value an acquisition brings and often a deliberately small one.
Enter a single monthly payment as the order value and the calculator returns a break-even cost per acquisition so low that almost every subscription campaign fails it. Teams that take that verdict at face value cut campaigns that would have paid back comfortably within a few months. Enter an open-ended lifetime value instead and the opposite happens: the ceiling rises to a level the business can only reach if subscribers behave exactly as a forecast predicts, and the cash to fund the gap has to come from somewhere in the meantime.
The middle course is a payback window. The business chooses how long it is prepared to wait to recover acquisition cost, then counts the revenue an average new subscriber pays within that period, allowing for the people who leave along the way. The guide to LTV and CAC explains the wider relationship between LTVTotal value a customer brings over time. and CACCost to acquire one new customer.; this page uses a bounded slice of it as the calculator's order value.
The inputs for subscription businesses
| Calculator input | On the default page | For subscription businesses | Where to find it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Average order value | Average order value of one order | Expected revenue per new subscriber over the payback window: monthly price × the average number of paid months a subscriber stays within the window | Billing data by acquisition cohort and its churn curve |
| Gross margin | Gross margin on an order | Gross margin per payment after product, fulfilment and payment fees, net of any introductory discount spread across the window | Finance margin per subscription plan |
| Campaign spend | Campaign spend | Acquisition spend for the cohort being judged | Ad platform spend for the acquisition window |
The value row needs a churnShare of customers at the start of a period who left during it. curve. Take a group of subscribers who joined in the same period, count how many are still paying in each month after joining, and add those counts up to the end of the window. Divide by the size of the starting group to get the average number of paid months per subscriber, then multiply by the price. The retention and payback guide shows the curve shapes to expect, and the churn and retention metrics guide covers customer and revenue churn definitions. Where the first month is discounted, either lower the value by the discount or reduce the margin across the window; do one, not both.
Entering the subscription inputs step by step
Choose and write down the payback window
Agree how many months the business can wait to recover acquisition cost. Record it before calculating anything, since every output depends on it and a window chosen afterwards tends to be the one that gives the answer people wanted.
Count paid months from a settled cohort
Use a cohort old enough to have lived through the whole window. Add up the subscribers still paying at each month, divide by the cohort's starting size and multiply by the plan price to get revenue per subscriber.
Set the margin per payment
Take the price of one payment, subtract the product, packing, delivery and payment-processing costs, and divide by the price. Adjust for any introductory offer that applies to new subscribers.
Enter the values with the campaign's spend
Type the window revenue as the order value, the margin per payment and the spend that acquired the cohort. Write the window next to the break-even CPA so the target is never quoted without its assumption.
A worked subscription with illustrative inputs
An invented coffee subscription sets its acquisition ceiling
Mossgill Roasters, an invented coffee-subscription service, charges $30 a month and offers no introductory discount. It chooses a twelve-month payback window. Its churn curve shows that the average new subscriber pays for about six months within that year, so revenue per subscriber over the window is $30 × 6 = $180. Each payment earns a 55% margin after coffee, packaging, postage and card fees. With $12,000 of acquisition spend, the calculator returns a break-even CPA of $99, a break-even ROAS of about 1.8 and 122 subscribers needed to recover the spend within the window. On the first payment alone, those 122 subscribers would bring in $3,660, a first-payment ROAS of about 0.3.
Campaign Break-even Calculator
Open the Campaign Break-even Calculator →Prefilled with the example's inputs: Average order value $180 · Gross margin 55% · Campaign spend $12,000 → Break-even CPA $99 · Break-even ROAS 1.82× · Sales needed to break even 122.
The roastery and its numbers are invented. Change the order value in the embedded calculator to a single month's price to see how a one-payment view shrinks the ceiling.
Interpreting the break-even outputs for a subscription
Read break-even CPA first. It is the most the business can pay to acquire one subscriber and still recover that cost from margin by the end of the window. It is not the most it can pay to break even on the first payment, and it is not a lifetime ceiling. A campaign whose cost per subscriber sits below it is on course to pay back within the window, assuming the cohort churns like the one used to build the value.
Then put break-even ROAS in context. The calculator derives it from margin alone, but the account will report ROAS on first-payment revenue, which compares one payment with a whole acquisition cost. That reported figure will sit far below the calculator's line even for a healthy campaign. Compare like with like: either compare cost per subscriber with break-even CPACost of each conversion., or compare revenue over the window, once it has accrued, with the Break-even ROASMinimum ROAS to avoid a loss..
Next, read sales needed to break even as subscribers needed. It is the number of new subscribers the spend must win for the cohort to recover its acquisition cost within the window. Comparing it with the subscribers a campaign actually produced is often the quickest check a team can run each week.
Finally, remember that the window carries risk. Lengthening it raises the value per subscriber and therefore the break-even CPA, but it also delays the point at which the money comes back and leans more heavily on the churn assumption holding. The calculator cannot see whether next quarter's subscribers will stay as long as last year's, whether a price rise will change cancellations, or how long the business can carry the cash gap.
Pitfalls when subscription numbers go into the calculator
- Using the first payment as the order value. The ceiling it produces is so low that profitable campaigns are switched off before their subscribers have paid a second time.
- Using lifetime value with no window or churn. An unbounded value lifts the ceiling to a level that only works if the forecast proves exactly right and the business can fund the wait.
- Ignoring the discount on the first box or month. Introductory offers cut the revenue a new subscriber pays, often in the very month the cohort is largest. Leave them out and the value is overstated.
- Judging a cohort before its churn curve has settled. Early months usually lose subscribers fastest. A cohort read too soon looks either worse or better than it will end up, depending on when the reading is taken.
- Mixing plans with different prices and margins. A blended value across monthly and annual plans hides which plan's subscribers actually pay back.
