Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Digital Marketing Foundations › Intermediate

Checkpoint: Channel Mix Decisions

Scenario questions on building and correcting a channel mix: when to lean on paid search or organic search, how to balance creating and capturing demand, and how to give each channel a job. Every answer carries its reasoning and a link to the page that teaches it.
CheckpointIntermediate levelModule 2: Designing the channel mix4 minUpdated

What this checkpoint covers

The questions draw on the channel mix guide, the comparison of SEO and PPC and the distribution channels guide. They test judgement on timing (what can work this quarter and what pays back later), balance (creating demand against capturing it), roles (one job per channel) and sequence (which channels must be live before others start).

Task

  • Read each scenario and write your decision and a one-line reason before reading the answers.
  • Mark each decision as a timing, balance, role or sequence call.
  • Compare with the explanations and note where your reasoning differed, not only your answer.
  • Finish by writing one rule of thumb in your own words that you will apply to your own mix.

Questions

  1. A start-up has created a new product category. Almost nobody searches for the category yet. The founder wants the whole budget in paid search because "it converts best". What do you advise?
  2. A retailer ranks first organically for its brand name and also bids on it. The finance director wants the brand ads switched off to save money. How do you respond?
  3. A small business runs one social campaign that does prospecting and retargeting together, judged on cost per sale. Results are mediocre and nobody can say why. What would you change?
  4. A new online shop needs sales this quarter and has no organic visibility. Should it start with SEO or PPC?
  5. A mature retailer sees paid search cost per sale rising, brand search volume flat and the share of new customers falling. What has probably happened to the mix, and what would you watch to confirm it?
  6. A content team publishes a strong guide, posts it once on social media, and is disappointed by the traffic. What was missing?
  7. A brand plans to launch a video awareness campaign this month and set up its paid search campaigns the month after, once the budget is approved. What is the risk?
  8. Two campaigns in different teams target overlapping audiences in the same auction. Both report rising costs. What is going on?

Answers explained

  1. There is little demand to capture, so create it first. Paid search can only harvest searches that already happen. A new category needs demand-creation channels, paid social, video, creators, PR, with a small paid search presence to catch what they generate. The channel mix guide covers the creation-capture balance; "converts best" is a property of capture channels, not evidence that they can grow.
  2. Test before deciding. Some brand clicks would arrive organically anyway, but the effect varies, and competitors may be bidding on the brand name. Run a pause test and compare total brand clicks and sales with and without the ads. The SEO versus PPC comparison explains why cannibalisation is found by testing rather than assumed.
  3. Split the jobs. Prospecting and retargeting want different audiences, creative and measures. Make two campaigns with separate objectives: prospecting judged on the demand it creates, retargeting on the actions it recovers. Then the weak job becomes visible.
  4. PPC now, SEO started now. Paid search (SEM) delivers within days and can be turned up or down; organic search (SEO) takes months and then compounds. Start both: paid to meet this quarter's target, content and technical work so that next year's cost per sale is lower. Paid query data also shows which topics to write first.
  5. The mix has drifted too far towards capture. The business is harvesting a pool it no longer refills. Rebalance some budget towards demand creation and watch Share of Voice in the category, brand search volume and the share of new customers. The channel mix guide lists these as the signs.
  6. A distribution plan. Publishing is not distributing. The distribution channels guide treats search and email as the base: a guide built for a query it can rank for, sent to the list, then pushed through communities, partners or paid promotion chosen for that piece.
  7. Demand created with nothing to catch it. The video will prompt searches, and without paid search live the clicks go to competitors bidding on the category. Capture channels go live first, so the sequence is capture ready, then awareness.
  8. Self-competition. The two campaigns bid against each other and raise each other's prices. Coordinate the calendar and add audience exclusions so each audience is bought once, by the campaign whose job it matches.

Your rule of thumb. Write it as a sentence you could say in a planning meeting. For example: "No awareness spend goes live until the capture channels can catch what it creates."

Where to go next

The final module ties the mix to objectives, budget and measurement. After its reading, start the KPI tree exercise for a subscription box, or return to the intermediate level overview.

Pages this lesson applies

Terms used on this page

Also related

Related