Why this matters
A business that relies on one paid channel has handed its growth to someone else's auction: when costs rise, nothing underneath absorbs the shock. This exercise applies the method in the channel mix guide to a lopsided starting point and a small team.
The app and its current mix
Everything about Lingopath is invented for the exercise.
Lingopath: last quarter's position
Lingopath is a subscription app teaching conversational German, Spanish and Dutch, sold in the UK. It has a free trial and a monthly plan. Research last quarter found its best subscribers are adults preparing to move abroad for work, who need everyday language for their first months in a new country. Its position: "the app that gets you through your first month abroad". The team is three people: a marketer, a content writer and a lifecycle specialist shared with product.
| Channel | Last quarter's spend | Share of spend | What it was doing |
|---|---|---|---|
| Paid social | £51,000 | 85% | Everything: prospecting, retargeting and trial offers in one campaign |
| App-store search ads | £6,000 | 10% | Bidding on the brand name only |
| Email and in-app messages | £3,000 | 5% | A single welcome email |
| Blog | £0 media | — | Forty posts on grammar topics, little traffic |
Signals from the data:
- Cost to acquire a paying subscriber through paid social rose from £14 to £23 over three quarters.
- Trial-to-paid rate is 18%; most trials that lapse never open the app after day two.
- Search Console shows the site appears for queries such as "German phrases for a job interview" and "how to open a bank account in the Netherlands" but ranks too low to be clicked.
- Keyword research shows steady demand for relocation-language queries in all three languages; competitors' pages for them are thin.
- Finance has capped next quarter's media at £60,000 and asked for a lower cost per paying subscriber.
Giving each channel a job
Lingopath's problem is not paid social itself but one campaign doing every job against one number, so nobody can tell which job is failing. Write a job sentence per channel: stage, segment and success measure. Use the stages of the RACE framework (reach, act, convert, engage) to check coverage, because Lingopath has almost nothing in act or engage.
Then decide the balance between search channels. The SEO versus PPC comparison is the reference: paid search (SEMPaid search advertising (sometimes used to include SEO).) captures existing demand within days and stops when spending stops; organic search (SEOImproving visibility in unpaid search results.) takes months and compounds. The question is which queries each covers, and when. A content programme costs writer time even when its media cost is nil.
Task
- Write a job sentence for every channel you keep or add, naming the RACE stage, the segment and the success measure.
- Build a channel mix table with the columns channel, role, stage, success metric and share of effort.
- Split paid social into separate campaigns where it currently does more than one job.
- Decide which search queries paid search covers now and which organic content should take over, and when you would test pausing paid on them.
- Write a short rationale explaining how search and content reduce Lingopath's dependence on paid social and what you expect to happen to the cost per paying subscriber (CACCost to acquire one new customer.) over the next few quarters.
- Note one sequencing rule and one risk.
Worked answer
Lingopath: next quarter's channel mix
| Channel | Role | RACE stage | Success metric | Share of effort |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Paid social, prospecting | Create demand among people planning a move | Reach | Cost per trial; brand search lift | 45% of media |
| Paid social, retargeting | Bring back site visitors who did not start a trial | Act | Trials from retargeted visitors | 8% of media |
| Non-brand paid search and app-store search ads | Capture relocation-language searches | Convert | Cost per paying subscriber at or below £18 | 25% of media |
| Brand app-store search ads | Defend the brand name | Convert | Cost per paying subscriber | 5% of media |
| Organic content: relocation guides | Rank for the same queries; offer a trial | Reach and act | Organic trials | Half the writer's time; no media |
| Email and in-app lifecycle | Turn trials into subscribers; reduce early lapse | Convert and engage | Trial-to-paid rate up from 18% | 7% of media; the lifecycle specialist |
| Relocation partners | Reach people at the decision to move | Reach | Referred trials | 5% of media |
| Testing reserve | New creative and query tests | All | Decision per test | 5% of media |
Paid social falls from 85% to 53% of media; total media stays at £60,000.
Search and content. Paid search goes live first on relocation queries: it captures existing demand and shows which topics convert. The writer turns the best-converting queries into guides (job interviews, renting, banking) instead of grammar posts. As each guide ranks, a pause test on the matching paid queries frees money for queries the site does not yet rank for. The distribution channels guide adds the other half: each guide also goes to the email list and to partners, so it earns visits before search picks it up.
Expected effect. The blended cost per paying subscriber should fall as organic trials grow at no media cost and lifecycle work lifts trial-to-paid. Paid social is now judged on the demand it creates, not on last-click sales.
Sequencing rule and risk. Capture channels go live before the prospecting campaign changes, so the demand it creates is caught. The risk is the writer's capacity: if guides slip, organic never takes over and paid search cost rises with volume.
Common mistakes
- Moving budget from one paid channel to another and calling it diversification. Dependence on any single auction is the same risk.
- Giving content a share of media but no time. Content is mostly effort, so record it as effort.
- Judging prospecting on last-click sales. It will look worse than capture channels on that measure by design.
- Leaving engage empty. The early lapse after a trial starts is the biggest leak in Lingopath's data.
When the table is done, test yourself with the channel mix checkpoint, or return to the intermediate level overview.
