Why this matters
A product campaign has no keywords: the feed decides which searches a product matches, what the ad says and whether it may enter an auction at all. The product feeds guide covers each attribute, and the shopping and catalogue ads guide explains why feed work is marketing work. The skill practised here is ordering: an audit that lists every flaw at equal weight is barely better than none.
The feed extract
Stridewell Sportswear is an invented online store selling running shoes and training clothing. Its feed is exported nightly, and its Shopping campaign uses one return target for the whole catalogue. The extract shows each product's feed data beside its live page on the morning of the audit, and its Shopping revenue.
Stridewell Sportswear: feed extract and page check
| id | title | brand | gtin | category | colour, size, gender, age group | item group | price feed / page | stock feed / page | revenue last month |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SW-101 | RUNNER X PRO – SALE!! | Stridewell | - | Shoes | black, 9, male, adult | - | £95 / £95 | in / in | £6,840 |
| SW-102 | Item 4471-BLK | Kestrel | yes | Apparel & Accessories | black, -, -, - | - | £32 / £32 | in / in | £410 |
| SW-103 | Stridewell Tempo Women's Running Tights – Navy | Stridewell | yes | Activewear Pants | navy, M, female, adult | SW-TEMPO | £45 / £36 | in / in | £5,220 |
| SW-104 | Kestrel Trail Shoe | Kestrel | - | Athletic Shoes | grey, 8, male, adult | - | £110 / £110 | in / in | £1,980 |
| SW-105 | Training Top | Stridewell | yes | Apparel & Accessories | -, -, -, - | - | £28 / £28 | in / in | £260 |
| SW-106 | Stridewell Pacer Running Shorts – Black – M | Stridewell | yes | Activewear Shorts | black, M, male, adult | - | £24 / £24 | in / in | £1,150 |
| SW-107 | Stridewell Pacer Running Shorts – Black – L | Stridewell | yes | Activewear Shorts | black, L, male, adult | - | £24 / £24 | in / in | £980 |
| SW-108 | Kestrel Glide Women's Road Running Shoes – White | Kestrel | yes | Running Shoes | white, 6, female, adult | - | £120 / £120 | in / out | £3,600 |
A dash means the attribute is empty. SW-104 has identifier_exists set to no. SW-105's image is a lifestyle shot with the product small; SW-107's carries a "FREE DELIVERY" text overlay; the rest are clean packshots. No product has a custom label. Every product, own-brand Stridewell and supplier Kestrel alike, carries a barcode.
Checking attributes and titles
Work in the order the guides set. Eligibility first: price or availability mismatches and image policy breaches that disapprove products. Then limited eligibility: missing or wrongly declared identifiers, missing variant and apparel attributes. Then matching: weak titles and vague categories. Then segmentation: whether the feed lets the campaign treat products differently. Within each tier, order by revenue at risk.
Apparel and footwear titles run brand, gender, product type, key attribute, colour, with size left to its attribute and no promotional words or capitals.
Task
- List every issue, product by product, labelled as a disapproval risk, limited eligibility, matching or segmentation.
- Rewrite the titles of the three products with the weakest titles, following the category pattern.
- Say which issues need fixing at source and which a feed rule or supplemental feed can handle.
- Put the fixes in priority order and give the reason for the order.
- Name the custom label you would add first and the campaign decision it allows.
Worked answer
Stridewell's issues and fix list
Issues found:
- SW-103: feed £45 against page £36; the sale never reached the feed. Disapproval risk on £5,220 a month.
- SW-108: in stock in the feed, out of stock on the page. Disapproval risk on £3,600 a month.
- SW-107: text overlay on the main image. Image policy risk on £980 a month.
- SW-101: no GTIN despite a barcode; promotional, capitalised title; generic category. The best-seller, £6,840.
- SW-104: identifier_exists set to no on a barcoded shoe, suppressing the catalogue match silently. £1,980.
- SW-106 and SW-107: size variants without an item group, competing as separate products.
- SW-102 and SW-105: internal-code and bare titles, missing apparel attributes, broad category; SW-105's image shows the product small.
- All products: no custom labels, so one target covers every margin.
Rewritten titles (gender and colour confirmed from each product page):
- SW-101: Stridewell Runner X Pro Men's Road Running Shoes – Black
- SW-102: Kestrel Men's Running T-Shirt – Black
- SW-105: Stridewell Women's Training Top – Grey
Priority order:
- SW-103 price, fixed at source with the sale price attribute and a shorter refresh.
- SW-108 availability, synced at the same cadence as price.
- SW-107 image, replaced with a clean packshot.
- SW-101 identifier, title and category.
- SW-104 identifiers.
- SW-106 and SW-107 item group, then SW-102 and SW-105 titles and attributes.
- Custom labels, margin band first.
Why this order. The mismatches and the overlay can remove products from every auction, and the price mismatch sits on the second-highest earner. The best-seller's identifier and title come next: it serves, but on fewer searches than it should. The weakest titles sit on the lowest-revenue lines, so they wait.
Source, rule or supplemental feed. Price, availability and identifiers are fixed at source, because a patched price is wrong again at the next sale. Titles, categories and custom labels can live in a supplemental feed keyed on id.
The first custom label. A margin band label allows separate ROASRevenue generated per unit of ad spend. targets, so a low-margin supplier shoe is not held to an own-brand top's target. A price tier label comes second, because cheap tops and expensive shoes produce very different average order values (AOVAverage revenue per order.). The Performance Max structure guide shows how labels become campaigns.
Common mistakes
- Starting with titles because they are the most visible flaw. Disapprovals remove products from every auction.
- Ordering by number of issues, not revenue at risk. Four flaws on a slow line wait behind one on a best-seller.
- Overwriting the price with the sale price. The price is wrong once the sale ends.
- Putting size in variant titles instead of grouping variants. The item group does that job.
- Leaving identifier_exists false on barcoded products. No error appears, so diagnostics-only audits miss it.
Next, take the feeds, Performance Max and video checkpoint, which also covers YouTube ad formats, or return to the intermediate Google Ads level.
