What an advisory board is for, and what it is not
The customer references and advocacy guide describes advisory groups in a paragraph: a small group of customers who meet periodically to discuss the roadmap and the market, a source of product and messaging input first, not a sales event, with recognition through thanks and access rather than payment. This guide turns that paragraph into a programme.
A board earns its place by answering questions that other inputs cannot. Surveys, covered in the voice of the customer guide, measure how many customers feel something. One-to-one research, covered in the customer interviews guide, explains why an individual behaved as they did. A board adds something different: a group of informed customers who see work in progress, argue about it with each other, and tell the business what a market of people like them is likely to think. It is most useful for questions of direction, such as which problem to lead with, how a new package would land with a buying committeeThe group of people in an organisation who influence, evaluate and approve a purchase., or which planned capability matters most, and least useful for questions that need numbers.
It is worth being clear about what a board is not. It is not a research study with a representative sample, so its views are input to a decision, never proof that the market agrees. It is not a user group, which helps customers use the product and meet each other. It is not a reference programme, although members often become references. And it is not a sales event: once members suspect the meetings exist to sell them more, the advice stops being candid and attendance falls. When a question needs fresh reactions from people with no standing relationship to the business, the tutorial on running a focus group covers recruiting, moderating and analysing a one-off group instead.
A charter on one page
Write the charter before inviting anyone, and share it with every member. A page is enough.
| Section | What it says |
|---|---|
| Purpose | The decisions the board advises on, such as positioning, messaging, packaging and roadmap priorities |
| What it is not | Not a sales forum, not a support channel, not a decision-making body |
| Membership | Who is invited and why, the mix sought, how long membership lasts and how members leave |
| Commitment | What is asked of members: meetings, preparation, occasional questions between meetings |
| What members receive | Recognition, early sight of plans, access to the team and to peers; no payment for advice |
| Confidentiality | What is shared in confidence by both sides, and how members' contributions are recorded and used |
| Owner | The person who runs the board and the executive who sponsors it |
| Reporting back | How and when members are told what changed because of their advice |
Two lines in the charter deserve care. The first is confidentiality. Members will see plans that are not public, and the business will hear about members' own operations. Say plainly what is shared in confidence and ask members to respect it; if the business wants a formal agreement, that is a matter for legal advice, not for this guide. The second is how contributions are recorded. Notes that name members and record what they said are personal dataAny information relating to an identified or identifiable living person, such as a name, email address, location data or an online identifier., and the product-qualified leads guide summarises the GDPR's position that using personal data needs a lawful basis decided with whoever owns compliance and that data kept should be minimal. Tell members what is recorded, who sees it and how long it is kept, and share findings by role rather than by name unless a member agrees otherwise.
Choosing members
Members are chosen against the positioning's target segment and the ideal customer profileA description of the type of organisation most likely to buy, succeed with the product and stay, used to choose target accounts., not from the list of customers who like the business most. The guide to building an ideal customer profile compares accounts that stayed with those that left, and the same thinking applies here: a board of advocates tells the business what it wants to hear.
A useful board mixes several kinds of customer:
- Customers who match the target segment closely, since the board's main job is to advise on how that segment thinks.
- Different roles from the buying committee. The person who signs, the person who uses the product daily and the person who has to make it work with everything else see different problems.
- A customer who nearly left. An account that came close to cancelling, or one from a segment whose churn rateShare of customers at the start of a period who left during it. is rising, knows what the product fails to do and is usually willing to say so. Choose one whose problem was resolved, so that the relationship can bear the candour.
- A customer at the edge of the segment, where the business hopes to grow, to test whether the positioning travels.
Leave out accounts in an open dispute, which need a different conversation, and avoid filling places with whoever the largest accounts nominate, which can turn the board into an escalation channel. Invite named people rather than companies, because the value is in the individual's judgement and continuity, and decide in the charter what happens when a member changes job.
The invitation says why this person was chosen, what the board is for, what it asks of them and what it does not, with the charter attached. The customer interviews guide states, from the MRS's professional codes, that research participants should know who is asking and why and that a research session is never followed by selling. A board meeting is not a research study, but the same principles apply in spirit: members know exactly what they are being asked and why, and the board is never a disguise for selling.
What members give and what they get
Members give their time, their candour and their judgement. That is a lot to ask of senior people, and a board has to be worth their while.
What they get should be valuable but not payment. The references guide recommends recognition through thanks, access and visibility rather than payment, because paying for advocacy changes what the advocate says. For a board, that usually means early sight of plans, direct access to the people making product and market decisions, time with peers in similar roles who face the same problems, and visible evidence that their advice changed something. Some businesses add hospitality around meetings or early access to new capabilities. Whatever is given, record it.
That record matters if a member later speaks publicly. Many board members become references, speakers or case study subjects, which is a welcome side effect. The references guide summarises, from the FTC's endorsement guidance, that endorsements must reflect the endorser's genuine experience and that a material connection between the endorser and the business should be disclosed clearly. Early access, gifts and hospitality can all be such a connection, so a member who later gives a quote or writes a review has their board membership and anything they received disclosed with it. Ask for public endorsement separately from board membership, and never make membership depend on it. This is educational guidance, not legal advice.
Agendas that ask rather than present
The commonest way a board fails is that the meetings become presentations. The business has a lot to show and the members are polite, so the time fills with slides and the members leave having listened rather than advised.
Build each agenda around a small number of questions the business genuinely needs answered, and give most of the time to discussion. A pattern that works is one positioning or market question and one product or roadmap question per meeting, each introduced briefly and then opened to the room. Send the questions and any material in advance, so members arrive with a view.
Frame questions in terms of the customer's work. The jobs-to-be-done framework reframes the question from who buys to what progress the customer is trying to make in a particular situation, which produces better discussion than asking members to rate features. Ask what they were trying to get done when they last looked for a product like this, what nearly stopped them, and what they would do if the product disappeared. When the question is whether an offer fits, the value proposition canvas puts what customers are trying to do on one side and what the product offers on the other; walking members through a draft canvas and asking where it is wrong is a fast way to find the gaps. As the framework's page notes, fit on paper is the start, not the proof.
| Agenda item | Weak version | Stronger version |
|---|---|---|
| Positioning | A presentation of the new messaging, followed by "any thoughts?" | Two draft statements of the problem, and the question which one describes members' situation and why |
| Pricing and packaging | A preview of the new plans | The question how each member's organisation would decide between two packages, and who would object |
| Roadmap | A slide of upcoming features | Three problems the team could solve next, and the question which would change members' work most |
| Market | The company's view of the market | The question what has changed in members' own businesses since the last meeting |
Sellers can attend as listeners, but no seller follows up on what a member said in the room, and the people running the meeting keep any pitch out of it. The roundtables and customer events guide covers running the room without a pitch, the guest list and the follow-up, and those habits apply to every board meeting.
Turning advice into decisions, and telling members
Advice that goes nowhere ends the board. After each meeting, write a short note of what members said on each question, attributed by role rather than by name, and give it to the people who own the decisions: the positioning and messaging owner, the pricing owner and product management. Board input is one input among several; it is weighed alongside research, usage data and win-loss evidence, never treated as a vote.
Where advice touches positioning, the guide to refreshing a positioning covers deciding whether the position needs to change and rolling a change out. Where it touches messaging, the messaging hierarchy and proof points guide is where a pillar or proof point is revised, and where it touches packaging, the pricing and packaging guide covers the decision.
Then close the loop. At the start of every meeting, report what changed since the last one because of the board's advice, what the business decided not to do and why, and what is still under consideration. Members who can see their influence keep coming and keep being candid; members who hear nothing conclude the board is for show. A short written update between meetings does the same job for anything decided in the meantime.
A veterinary software's advisory board (illustrative)
Dewbrask Practice Systems forms an advisory board
Dewbrask Practice Systems, an invented practice-management software for veterinary clinics, formed a board of 9 members: 4 practice owners, 3 head nurses and 2 practice managers, drawn from clinics matching its target segment of independent practices with two to five sites. One was the owner of a clinic that had nearly cancelled the previous year over appointment reminders. The charter set three meetings a year, recognition through early sight of plans and a dinner after each meeting, and no payment. Each meeting asked one positioning question and one roadmap question. At the first, the positioning question asked whether clinics chose software to save reception time or to keep clients coming back; 7 of the 9 said the second, and the head nurses described the job as making sure no pet missed a vaccination. The messaging hierarchy was revised to lead with client retention. The roadmap question showed that the reminder problem the nearly-lost clinic had raised was shared by most members, and product management moved it up the plan. At the second meeting, the first ten minutes reported both changes back to members. A year later, 3 members had agreed to public quotes, each published with a line disclosing their board membership.
Common mistakes
- Filling the board with advocates. Happy customers confirm what the business already believes; include customers who nearly left and roles that object.
- Presenting instead of asking. A meeting full of slides produces polite listeners, not advice.
- Selling in the room. Members who feel they are being sold to stop being candid and then stop attending.
- Treating the board as the market. It is a small group of informed customers, not a representative sample.
- Never reporting back. Members who cannot see what their advice changed conclude the board is for show.
- Leaving confidentiality and notes unclear. Say what is shared in confidence, what is recorded and who sees it; take legal advice on any formal agreement.
- Paying for advice, or for endorsement. Recognition through access and thanks keeps advice candid, and any benefit a member received is disclosed if they later endorse publicly.
- No owner. A board without a named owner and sponsor drifts and is quietly abandoned.
