Why packaging drifts between reviews
The pricing and packaging guide designs plans once: tiers built from segments, fences that follow value, a metric the buyer can predict and a page that shows the complete cost. After launch, the design meets a stream of small decisions: a seller needs an inclusion to close a deal, a new capability has to land in some plan, a new segment starts to buy, a plan is retired. Each is sensible alone, and as general practice nothing reads them together unless a review does. The placement guide for new features ends where this tutorial begins: placements made one at a time can pull plans away from their segments, and its remedy is a look at the whole, not another placement.
The pricing guide wants price levels reviewed on a planned rhythm, drawing on lost deals, the discounts given and research into what buyers would pay, and for packaging to be looked at again after a significant capability arrives or a new segment starts to buy, but it does not walk the review. The discount rules tutorial builds one evidence stream, the record of what sellers concede and for what, and the good-better-best framework reads the tier mix. This tutorial is the sequence around them.
Product marketing runs the review as it runs the pricing group the pricing guide describes: finance can block what the economics do not support, one named executive approves, and product management, or, in a service business and as this tutorial's addition, whoever scopes the service, says what can be built or delivered. This tutorial is not legal advice.
Before you start
Agree what the review decides: whether the packaging still fits its segments and, if not, which small thing to change first. Save the current plans, prices and inclusions from the pricing page and proposal template as dated copies, the baseline the last step reads against. Collect the discount record, built as the discount rules tutorial's step on reading the discounts already given describes, and treat any gap as a finding. Add finance's view of each plan's economics, the lost-deal notes, the questions buyers asked about plans and price, and from billing the plan each customer chose, when and through which source.
Fix two things in advance: one list of segments, taken from the positioning, that all the streams are cut by, and one window of time for all of them, noting any packaging change, promotion or price move inside it.
The steps
Set the trigger and name who can block
A review starts because it is planned or because something has fired. The planned one follows the rhythm the pricing guide describes for price levels, which the pricing group puts in its calendar. The triggers are the ones the guides name or imply: a significant capability added, a new segment buying, a run of one-off placements, a discount record whose reasons keep pointing at one plan and, as general practice, a plan retired. Write them down, and as general practice note which one fired, because it sets the question the pack answers: a new segment calls for the pack to be cut by that segment first, a drifting discount record for the discount stream first.
Then name who can block, using the pricing guide's arrangement, and agree what a block means before the evidence arrives. This tutorial's own choice, not the guide's: a block stops the review at that option and sends the group back to a smaller one in step four.
Assemble one pack cut by segment and source
The pack is one document built from evidence the guides already describe: the pricing guide's section on researching willingness to pay lists the behavioural evidence and the good-better-best framework reads the tier mix, and the Stream column below only names those streams so that each can be given the same cuts. It adds what makes separate reports a pack: the same segment labels, the same window, an acquisition source on each line that has one and the count beside each rate.
Stream Where it lives Cut it by Write beside it Discounts and concessions The deal record from the discount rules tutorial Segment, plan, reason, trade The count of won deals behind the figure Lost and undecided deals Win-loss notes and the sales record Segment, plan shown, reason in the buyer's words Whether the buyer or the seller gave the reason Plan chosen, upgrades and downgrades Billing Segment, acquisition source, plan at purchase The campaigns running in the window Buyer questions about plans and price Sales and support records Segment, plan, topic How they were tagged For buyer questions, the sales cycle diagnosis already asks for pricing questions to be recorded on the opportunity and reviewed with product marketing; as general practice, support tickets serve self-serve buyers.
Handle any stated evidence as the stated and revealed preference framework advises, as a hypothesis to check against the four streams. For new stated evidence, see the survey and questionnaire design guide on wording the questions.
Keep the count beside each figure and read thin cells with caution, pooling only similar segments, as the reading small numbers guide advises.
Read discounts, losses, tier mix and buyer questions together, segment by segment
Take one segment at a time and read the four streams side by side: discounts show what sellers conceded, lost deals what buyers declined, the tier mix what buyers chose and the questions what confused them. Where several streams agree there is a finding; a pattern in one stream alone is carried to the next review as a question. Read the win rateShare of closed sales opportunities that were won. beside the discount record too: a segment that wins only with a concession is a different case from one that wins at list price.
The combinations below are general practice. No guide states them, and they prompt the group's judgement rather than diagnose.
Discounts Lost deals Tier mix Buyer questions May point to Thin, reasons vary Confusion, or a comparison the buyer could not make Buyers split across plans for no visible reason Which plan fits, what is included Presentation A bigger plan's inclusion conceded to buyers on a smaller one Plans described as not for them A segment on a plan named for another Who a plan is for A plan name One inclusion conceded on one plan across several deals Paying for a capability not needed, or lacking one that was Buyers choosing a plan for one capability, or moving soon after Whether a capability or limit belongs to a plan A fence in the wrong place An add-on given away to close A capability missing that a higher plan holds Thin on the plan that holds it How to get it without the plan Placement Caps, locks or custom quotes requested A bill the buyer could not predict or an approver could not follow Buyers choosing by a unit the plans do not price on How to stay under a limit, how the bill grows The pricing metric Spread across plans and segments, trades recorded Price named although the plan fitted Intended plans chosen, upgrades as designed Whether the price is worth it The price level, once the others are ruled out Read the tier mix as the good-better-best framework's section on reading the tier mix after launch sets out, using the segment and source labels fixed in the pack, and treat behaviour as a response to what was offered: a plan shown as the default draws buyers partly for that reason. The price level is the last row because it changes what customers see and pay, so reach it only when the others are ruled out, and then with the willingness-to-pay research the pricing guide describes.
List the options from smallest to largest
Turn each finding into options and order them by how visible the change is to existing customers and how hard it is to undo. The smallest is to hold: leave the packaging alone, record why and say what would reopen the question.
Option What it changes Who feels it Handled in Hold and watch Nothing; the record says what would reopen it Nobody Step six Presentation How the same plans and quote are shown Prospects first, and any existing customers who use the page The pricing pageThe page where buyers compare plans and prices, treated as a conversion step that shows who each plan is for, the complete cost and the next step. itself: see the pricing page design guide Plan names and descriptions What a plan says about who it is for Prospects, sellers, customers on a renamed plan The pricing guide's rule on names Placement Which plan or add-on holds a capability, alone or in a bundleSeveral products sold together as one item at a single price, used to raise order value; a kit is a bundle designed as a starting point for new customers. Customers on plans that gain or lose it The placement guide Fence Where the line between two plans sits Customers on both sides The placement guide's tests Pricing metric What the bill scales with Customers whose bills grow with it The pricing guide's metric section Price level The number itself Anyone who pays or compares The price change routine Presentation coming before price, and price being the heaviest option, follow what the sources say; the order of the rungs between them is general practice. The pricing guide points to testing packaging and presentation before price, because testing price raises fairness and trust questions. And the doors framework judges a decision by how costly it is to reverse: its answer on price calls a visible price move a one-way door, and so is a change to how pricing works, a new tier structure for instance. As general practice, the lower rungs are two-way doors for prospects but harder to undo for customers on the plan they change; the placement guide treats narrowing a plan they already pay for as a retirement and a price change.
Check the economics and choose what to test first
Short-list what the cross-reading supports, then check the economics with finance, as the pricing guide asks. Ask for the contribution marginRevenue left after every cost that varies with each sale. of each plan as it would stand under each option and for what the option does to customers who could move up or down: a moved fence can pull buyers down from a dearer plan, and a change that sells below what the economics allow is better found here than after launch. This tutorial names no tool for the arithmetic, because it rests on the business's own costs.
Then choose what to test first by reversibility. A presentation change is a two-way door: act, watch on a set date and reverse if the result misses. The pricing page layout test sets out how to run that test with prices untouched. Where traffic cannot carry a test, the pricing page guide offers a bolder research-led change or a judgement recorded as such. Showing different visitors different prices raises the fairness question the pricing guide describes, so make a smaller reversible version of the upper rungs first, such as the doors framework's pilot in one place or a commitment with an end date, and as general practice show a pricing pilot to whoever handles compliance.
Decide and record the change
Bring the group the kind of short proposal the placement guide describes, with the review's own additions: the trigger, what the pack showed by segment and finance's reading of the economics. Finance can block, the named executive approves and product management or the service lead confirms it can be built or delivered. A decision to hold is a decision: record it with what would reopen it.
Keep the record in a decision logA running record, one row per decision, of what changed and why, what was expected, who decided and when the result will be checked.. The marketing decision log template supplies the columns. A pricing review adds what the template does not ask: the options set aside and why, the segments touched, the dated copy of the packaging and what existing customers and sellers will be told.
Write the guardrail before the change ships. The sources use several for plan changes: refunds, downgrades and revenue per account in the layout test, and support contacts about billing in the guide to upgrade paths. Choose those the decision could harm, set the level from the measure's own history, as the template advises, and say who reads it and when.
Carry the change to existing customers, sellers and every page
Work in the price change routine's order, teams before customers.
Sellers and support come first: what changed, why and what to say to a buyer still using the old names. Then the discount rules, whose menu and floors name the old plans; the discount rules tutorial asks for the rule to be revisited when a price changes or a plan is added or withdrawn, and as general practice a rename or a moved fence is reason enough.
Existing customers come next. The guide to communicating a price change owns that plan, from grouping customers by impact to the watch on cancellations; this review hands over to it even where price levels hold, since a renamed plan or a moved fence changes what customers on it are called or can do. Where a plan now includes less than customers pay for, their entitlement turns on the terms they signed, so read the contracts and, if the position is unclear, take advice.
Then the pages. The placement guide's table of the surfaces that describe plans is the starting list. Use the dated copy as the checklist of where old names, limits and prices appear and change them all on one date, removing old prices wherever they were quoted. Check the pillars and proof points in the messaging hierarchy guide against the new names too, since the pricing guide warns that buyers believe the pricing when it contradicts the positioning.
Anything that compares the new prices with the old, shows a former price or sets a deadline makes a price claim of the sort the pricing guide discusses. It records the UK's Competition and Markets Authority as acting against misleading pricing, including a former price that was never really charged, a deadline that is not real and fees disclosed late, and says the Advertising Standards Authority's advertising codes reach price statements made in adverts. Have whoever handles compliance review such material first; this is not legal advice.
Read the result against the guardrail
On the check date in the log, read the guardrail first, then the pack's streams cut as before, against the dated copy of the old packaging. Keep upgrades on a line of their own, separate from new buyers, beside the downgrades, as the upgrade paths guide advises. Where the history exists, group customers by the cohortA group of customers who share a starting event and period, tracked together over time. in which they joined, as the cohort analysis tutorial does, so that customers of the same age are compared, and read cancellations in the same cohorts as the churn rateShare of customers at the start of a period who left during it..
Then read what the change was meant to move: the concessions, the questions about which plan fits and the reasons on lost deals, with outside events from the window listed in the log. Where counts are small, write the count next to each figure, as the small numbers guide advises, say direction, not trend, and keep the guardrail running for another read.
Write the verdict in the log: stands, reversed or changed, with a change entered as a new decision.
A pipe organ servicing firm reviews its plans (illustrative)
Solefosk Organ Care reads its year of exceptions
Solefosk Organ Care, an invented subscription service that tunes and maintains pipe organs for churches, schools and concert halls, sells three plans named for the building: Parish at £90 a month covers tuning for one organ, School at £140 adds repairs cover for up to two organs, and Hall at £240 adds priority call-outs for any number. After a year of one-off exceptions to what a plan covered, its pricing group (the finance lead, the head of tuning teams and the product marketer, with the managing director as the named executive) held a review.
The pack covered 41 won deals and 19 lost ones, cut by church, school and hall. The 41 won deals split 10 on Parish, 25 on School and 6 on Hall. Churches made up 24 of the won deals: 9 on Parish, 14 on School and 1 on Hall. Of the 17 deals with a concession, 8 were Parish deals for churches given a second organ at no charge, and 6 of the lost deals were churches wanting tuning only for a main organ and a small chamber organ, who found School dearer than a local tuner's quote. Of 31 questions logged about plans, 14 asked which plan covers a second organ, and schools and halls chose the plan named for them in 12 of 17 deals. The streams agreed that buyers chose by the number of organs while the plans were named by building type, and nothing pointed at the price levels.
The group held all three prices, moved the fence so that Parish covers up to two organs for tuning, the widening direction the placement guide calls easy, left repairs cover as School's fence and renamed Parish as Tuning and School as Tuning and Repairs. Hall kept its name, since 5 of its 6 buyers had chosen it as designed. Sellers and support were briefed first, the discount rules were revisited for the new names, existing customers went to the price change routine because a School subscriber needing only tuning could now move down, and the pages changed on one date. The guardrail was written beforehand: monthly revenue per new account at list prices no lower than £120, the lowest month of the pack year, against about £142 across it, and no more than 5 existing subscribers moving down, the most in any quarter of the pack year.
Two quarters later there were 22 won deals: 12 on Tuning, 7 on Tuning and Repairs and 3 on Hall, averaging about £126 at list prices. Four existing subscribers had moved down, 3 had moved up and second-organ questions numbered 3. The decision stood; 22 deals and 4 downgrades are too few to call a trend.
The product positioning hub lists the work that follows from the positioning, and, as general practice, a review is where that work is checked against what buyers have actually chosen.
Common mistakes
- Starting from the price. Read the evidence first and let it choose the rung; the number is the last option, not the first.
- Reading one stream alone. A pattern means something once lost deals, the tier mix and the questions agree with the discounts.
- Blending the segments. A plan mix across all buyers hides the segment the plans were built for.
- Splitting prices between visitors. Test presentation, and make smaller reversible versions of the rest.
- Skipping finance's check. A change that wins deals while selling below what the economics allow is a loss with a better headline.
- Telling sellers and customers late. A renamed plan or a moved fence reaches them anyway, and the old names keep being quoted.
- Shipping without a guardrail or a check date. A change with neither cannot be judged or reversed.
- Reading small counts as a trend. A few deals are a direction; say so and keep reading.
