Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Product Marketing

Product Positioning

Positioning is the decision about who a product is for, what it replaces and why it wins, and every other product marketing deliverable expresses that decision. This hub treats positioning as the input, introduces the core guides that turn it into messaging and into pricing, adds further guides on running a customer advisory board, packaging a service as a product, deciding which plans get a new feature, setting discount rules for sellers and running a pricing and packaging review, and covers how messages are tested and how positioning is kept current.
SectionintermediateUpdated

Learn this as a path

Prefer a guided order? These learning paths read pages from this section in sequence, with exercises and checkpoints.

In this section

Positioning before messaging, messaging before campaigns

Most product marketing problems trace back to work done in the wrong order. A team writes website copy, then builds a deck that says something slightly different, then runs adverts written by an agency that read neither. Each piece was reasonable on its own; together they describe a product nobody can quite place. The fix is a sequence. Positioning is decided first, as a short written statement that product, marketing and sales have agreed. Messaging is derived from it, as a hierarchy of pillars with proof. Pricing and packaging are set to match the segment and value the positioning names. Only then do campaigns, pages and sales content get written, and each one draws from the same source.

The method for arriving at the positioning decision, from segmentation through targeting to the choice of frame of reference and point of difference, belongs to the positioning guide in the strategy section, and the positioning statement framework gives the template for writing it down. The value proposition canvas is the usual intermediate tool when the fit between what customers are trying to do and what the product offers has not yet been worked out. This section assumes a positioning decision exists, or is close to existing, and covers what a product marketer does with it. The wider product marketing hub places positioning within the role as a whole.

Inputs, messaging, pricing

Positioning draws on a set of inputs, and produces the deliverables that the rest of the company uses.

ElementWhat it containsWhere it comes fromWho uses it
Customer inputsWho buys, what they were trying to do, what they compared, why they choseInterviews with recent customers and recent losses, win-loss notes, support themes, a customer advisory boardProduct marketing, product management
Competitive inputsThe alternatives buyers consider, including doing nothing, and how each is positionedCompetitive intelligence, sales feedback, public materialsProduct marketing, sales
Positioning statementTarget segment, category, point of difference, reason to believeAgreed by product, marketing and salesEveryone who writes about the product
Messaging hierarchyValue pillars, the message for each, the proof behind each, segment variantsDerived from the positioningMarketing, sales, agencies, support
Pricing and packagingPricing model and metric, tiers, bundles, how prices are presentedDerived from the positioning and willingness-to-pay researchSales, finance, the website

The inputs are shared with other functions. Customer research methods belong to the marketing research root and competitive analysis to the strategy section; product marketing's contribution is to ask the positioning questions of that research rather than to run every study itself. The deliverables are product marketing's own, and the core guides below cover each.

The core guides

Messaging hierarchy and proof points covers the move from a positioning decision to messaging that can be used: the messaging house of pillars, messages and proof, how claims are substantiated so they survive scrutiny from buyers and regulators, how messages vary by segment, persona and stage of the Funnel, how they adapt by channel without losing their meaning, and how they are tested before and after launch.

Pricing and packaging covers pricing as positioning made concrete: choosing a pricing model and the metric the price is charged on, designing tiers, bundles and add-ons so that each segment has a natural fit, researching willingness to pay rather than guessing it, presenting prices on the page so that the intended tier is the obvious choice, and governing discounts and promotions within the rules on price claims. For a services business, packaging a service as a product applies the same thinking to a defined outcome sold at a stated price.

The core guides are read together because they constrain each other. A pillar that promises enterprise-grade control is contradicted by a package that hides the control features behind an add-on. A tier named for a segment the positioning does not target invites the wrong buyers. The good-better-best pattern for three-tier offers keeps each tier tied to a segment the positioning names. When messaging and pricing come from the same decision, the pricing page reads as a continuation of the home page rather than a surprise at the end of it.

Further guides

Further guides cover a standing source of customer input, the packaging of work that is sold as a service, the plan each new feature joins, the rules sellers discount by and the review that keeps plans and prices honest:

  • Running a customer advisory board — its purpose and charter, choosing members, agendas that ask rather than sell, and turning members' advice into decisions.
  • Packaging a service as a product — choosing the outcome, fixing the scope and exclusions, naming it plainly, pricing the package and presenting it honestly on the page.
  • Deciding which plans get a new feature — every plan, a higher plan, an add-on or a product of its own, the evidence by segment, existing customers and every surface that changes.
  • Setting discount rules for sellers — a tutorial for reading the discounts already given, the trades and the options that avoid a price cut, an approval ladder by size and reversibility, an exception route and a regular read of the pattern.
  • Running a pricing and packaging review — a tutorial for the trigger and who can block, one evidence pack cut by segment, discounts, losses, tier mix and buyer questions read together, the options from smallest to largest, the decision record and carrying the decision to customers, sellers and every page.

Testing messages before launch

A message that sounds right in a meeting may not land with a buyer. Testing is cheap relative to a launch built on the wrong message, and it has a few standard forms. Qualitative tests put candidate messages in front of a small number of target buyers, in interviews or during sales calls, and ask what they understood, what they doubted and what they would want to know next. Comprehension matters more than preference at this stage: a message that buyers like but misread is worse than one they find plain but understand. Quantitative tests run candidate messages as advert variants or landing page variants and read click-through and conversion rate (CVR), which tells you which message draws the right people, not just more people. Sales tests are the simplest: give two representatives different framings for a fortnight and listen to the calls.

Whatever the method, test messages against each other rather than against nothing, keep the proof constant so the test reads the message, and record what was learned where the next person can find it. The messaging guide covers the designs in detail.

Keeping positioning current

Positioning decays. Competitors move into the space the product claimed, the product gains capabilities the positioning never anticipated, the segment that bought first turns out not to be the segment that buys most, and a message that was distinctive becomes the category default. The signs are visible if anyone looks: sales reporting that a pillar no longer comes up, win-loss notes citing reasons the messaging does not address, average order value (AOV) drifting as a different kind of customer buys, and campaign performance declining on the same message that once worked.

The practical rhythm is a positioning review at a fixed interval, usually tied to planning, plus a trigger review whenever a major release, a new competitor or a change in the target segment occurs. The review asks the same questions the original decision answered and checks whether the evidence still supports the answers. Most reviews change little. The ones that change a lot are the ones that were overdue.

Illustrative example — not a real result

An analytics tool repositions after a year of sales calls

Oakhurst Analytics launched a reporting product positioned for marketing teams at mid-sized companies. After a year, the product marketer reviewed 48 won deals and 31 losses and found that 29 of the wins were accountancy practices using the product for client reporting, a segment the positioning never mentioned, while marketing teams lost to a larger competitor 22 times out of 31. The positioning was rewritten around accountancy practices, the messaging hierarchy rebuilt with a pillar on multi-client reporting, and a practice tier added to the pricing page. Two quarters later, trial sign-ups from accountancy firms made up 61% of the total, up from 34%, and the pricing page's visit-to-trial rate had risen from 2.8% to 4.1%.

Common positioning problems

ProblemUsual causeGuide
Every page describes the product differentlyNo messaging hierarchy, or one that is not usedMessaging hierarchy and proof points
Claims that sales cannot back up in a callPillars written without proof pointsMessaging hierarchy and proof points
Buyers like the product and then stall at the pricePricing metric or tiers mismatched to perceived valuePricing and packaging
The middle tier is never chosenTier design and page presentation steer to the wrong optionPricing and packaging
A new feature lands in a plan by default and customers on other plans complainPlacement left to the release settings or to a request for an upgrade reasonDeciding which plans get a new feature
Deals close at whatever discount the seller negotiates and the list price means littleNo written limits, trades or options for sellersSetting discount rules for sellers
Plans and prices have drifted from the segments after many one-off changesPackaging and price levels never reviewed as a wholeRunning a pricing and packaging review
The positioning statement fits the product but not the marketSegmentation and competitive frame not testedPositioning in the strategy section
A message that once worked has stopped workingPositioning never reviewed; the market movedThis hub, under keeping positioning current

Terms used on this page

Frameworks

Sources

  1. Product Marketing Alliance — Product Marketing Alliance

Related