What these methods can and cannot earn
Some sites keep pages whose whole purpose is linking out: a collectors' club page of restoration guides, an association's list of reference material, a library's subject guide, a teacher's page of reading for a course. A place on one of them is a BacklinkA link from another site to yours. chosen by a person who looked at the page and decided it helps their readers, which is the editorial kind of reference the link quality and anchor text guide describes. That guide also names what matters to a link's weight, among them the linking site's standing, how relevant it is, where the link sits on the page and the state of the linking page itself. A list that nobody visits is weak on the last of those.
The link building methods guide names resource pages and broken link building in a few sentences each. Two other guides on this site work nearby but in different directions. The link reclamation tutorial recovers links that point at your own dead or moved pages and mentions that never linked; this tutorial deals with other people's lists and the dead entries on them. The outbound links guide looks at broken citations from the maintainer's side, which is worth reading before writing to one.
| Method | What you ask for | Who decides | What it cannot do |
|---|---|---|---|
| Resource page outreach | That a page be considered for a list on its subject | The person who keeps the list | Earn a place on a list the page does not fit |
| Broken link outreach | That dead entries be fixed, with your page offered where it truly replaces one | The person who keeps the list | Turn a dead link into a reason to list a page that does a different job |
| Either method | Nothing beyond the listing itself | The maintainer, including any attribute on the link | Guarantee a reply, a listing or any change in rankings |
Journalists and publications are a different audience with different rules: the digital PR guide and the guide to media relations and pitching cover them. Where a step below goes beyond what the linked guides state, such as reading an archived copy of a dead resource, improving your page before writing, or reporting every dead link you found rather than only the one you could replace, it is general practice rather than search engine documentation.
Before you start
- A short list of candidate pages on the site: guides, reference pages, tools or data that someone outside the business might recommend to a beginner, a student or a fellow enthusiast.
- Someone who knows the subject and can say whether a page is accurate, complete and better than what the lists already carry.
- A way to request a list of addresses and record the status code each returns, such as a link checker or a crawler set to fetch a supplied URL list without following links.
- A record, started before the first message, in the form the reclamation tutorial uses.
- Agreed scoring criteria for judging lists, written down before any list is found.
- Time to improve a page before it is offered, because a page that falls short of a dead resource is not a replacement.
The steps
Choose the pages that deserve a place on a list
Start from the reader of the list, not from the pages you want links to. A list compiled for restorers, students or members recommends pages that teach, explain or save effort; product and category pages do not fit that purpose, and offering them wastes the maintainer's time. For each candidate, ask whether a knowledgeable person would recommend it over the alternatives. The E-E-A-T guide sets out what makes a page trustworthy enough to cite: a named author with relevant experience, evidence of first-hand work, sources for its claims, visible dates and corrections, and honesty about where the advice stops. Pages that fall short go back to the editor before anyone is contacted.
Find pages that list resources on those subjects
Search for lists on each subject your chosen pages cover, using the searches set out in the prospecting section of the link building methods guide, which also explains how to keep a prospect list from one asset to the next. Look beyond the obvious: clubs, societies, museums, libraries, schools and hobby forums that keep a links page, and the pages that already link to resources like yours. Note each list's address, its owner and its subject, and drop pages that only look like lists, such as directories that sell places or pages assembled to host links.
Judge each list before contacting anyone
Score every list against the criteria you agreed before the search, with a weighted scoring matrix: the weights fixed in advance, must-haves treated as gates rather than points, and a check that the ranking holds when the weights shift. Useful criteria include upkeep (recent changes, a visible date, a named maintainer), readership (whether the list is linked from the rest of its own site and used by its community), and fit (how closely its subject matches your page). Gates come first: a list that charges for places, swaps links or exists to collect them is left alone whatever its score. Only lists that pass the gates and score well go forward.
Check each list for dead entries
Links on a list break as sources move, sites close and organisations rename their pages. To find out which entries still work, copy the addresses the list links to into a URL list and request each of them once, recording the HTTP Status CodeThe numeric code a web server returns with every response, saying whether the request succeeded, was redirected or failed and why. that comes back. Request only those addresses; never crawl the maintainer's own site, which nobody has agreed to. Read the results as the outbound links guide describes for a site's own citations, and remember that a page whose content has changed or a domain that has changed hands can still answer with success, so open every address that answers with success and compare it with the list's description.
Find out what each dead resource offered
Before offering anything, establish what the dead entry gave the list's readers. Start with what the list itself says: the entry's title, the description beside it and the words around the link. As general practice, an archived copy of the dead page, where one exists, shows what it covered, how deep it went and who published it. Write down the subject, the level, the format and anything distinctive, such as diagrams, measurements or a step that no other resource explained. That note is the standard your page has to meet.
Decide honestly whether your page replaces it
Compare your page with the note, section by section. The link building methods guide accepts a replacement only where it truly helps the people who use the list and calls the method a nuisance where the dead link is just an excuse to write. If your page covers the same ground at the same level, it is a candidate. If it covers part of it, improve the page first, as general practice, adding what the dead resource explained and your page does not. If it is a different kind of thing, such as a shop page in place of a free manual, it is not a replacement, and the honest message reports the dead link and offers nothing.
Write to the person who keeps the list
Find the maintainer by name where the list or its site gives one. Keep the note short and specific: which list, which entries no longer work and what each now returns, and, where you have one, the page that covers what a dead entry covered, with its address and a sentence on why it serves the list's readers. As general practice, report every dead link you found, not only the one you can replace, because that is useful to the maintainer whatever they decide about your page. For the wording, follow the request step of the reclamation tutorial, which covers the Anchor TextThe visible, clickable words of a link. and why nothing is offered in return; the link spam policy behind that rule is described in the guide to Google's spam policies. If the maintainer adds the link with a nofollowA link attribute asking search engines not to treat the link as an editorial endorsement. value, that is their decision, as the outbound links guide makes clear; the listing still reaches the list's readers.
Log each list, its maintainer and the reply
Keep the record the reclamation tutorial sets out, and add the details this method needs on each row: the list's address, its score, the dead entries you reported and the page you offered, if any. Record refusals and silences as carefully as listings, because the next round depends on knowing who has already been asked and what they said. As that tutorial advises, do not keep chasing a maintainer who has not replied; treat no reply as the reply. Give each row a date to recheck the list, both to confirm a listing is still there and to see whether the dead entries were fixed.
Keep your own listed pages alive
Once a page is listed, other people's readers depend on it, and a dead page on someone else's list is exactly what this tutorial looks for. Keep each listed page at its address; if it must move, move it by the procedure for changing a page URL, which writes a permanent redirect and lists the places an old address is used, and tell the maintainers whose lists carry it. Keep the content current and its own citations working, so the page goes on earning its place. As general practice, mark listed pages in the content inventory so that nobody retires or rewrites one without checking who links to it.
When to leave a list alone
Not every list deserves a message, and some messages do harm. Leave a list alone when:
- It sells places or asks for something in return. A paid or traded listing is advertising at best and link spam at worst; it falls outside this method.
- It is not maintained. A list with no visible owner and no sign of recent upkeep gives your message nobody to reach.
- Your page does not fit it. A good page on the wrong list is still the wrong page; fit is a gate, not a point.
- The list is a page of links on a site that exists to host them. Low-quality directory and bookmark links are among the link spam policy's examples, and such a page is not a resource.
- The maintainer has already said no. The record exists so that nobody asks twice.
- The subject is news rather than reference. Coverage by journalists is earned through the press, not through resource lists.
A typewriter parts supplier gets its restoration guide listed (illustrative)
Pilzevruk Typewriter Supplies offers its cleaning guide to restoration lists
Pilzevruk Typewriter Supplies, an invented supplier of typewriter restoration parts and inks, publishes a free illustrated guide to cleaning a manual typewriter, written by its restorer and updated twice a year. Its subject expert confirms the guide is complete except for one gap: it says little about replacing feed rollers.
Searches turn up 26 pages that list restoration resources: collectors' clubs, a museum's learning page, hobby sites and a college course page on mechanical design. The team scores each on upkeep (weight 40), readership (30) and fit (30), with 2 gates: the list must have a named maintainer and must not charge for places. 3 lists fail the gates and 12 score above the agreed cut-off of 60 out of 100 and stay above it when the weights are shifted.
The 12 lists link to 214 addresses in all. Requested once each, 19 return not found, 7 redirect to unrelated home pages and 2 sit on domains that have lapsed and now carry advertising. 9 of the dead entries, on 8 lists, pointed at pages of a retired online repair manual. An archived copy shows those pages covered cleaning and feed roller replacement in detail, so the restorer adds a feed roller section with photographs to the guide before anyone is contacted.
Pilzevruk sends 12 short notes, one per list, each naming every dead link found on that list and what it returns. On the 8 lists with repair manual entries, the note offers the guide as a replacement for the feed roller and cleaning pages; on the other 4 it reports the dead links and offers nothing. Over the following weeks, 5 maintainers list the guide, 1 of them with a nofollow value, 2 fix their dead links without listing it, 1 declines and 4 do not reply. Every list goes into the record with its outcome and a recheck date 6 months ahead, and the guide is marked as a listed page in the content inventory.
The off-page SEO hub places these methods beside the other ways a site earns references from people who chose to make them.
Common mistakes
- Offering a page that does not match the list. A good page on the wrong subject is a request the maintainer can only refuse.
- Crawling the maintainer's site. Request only the addresses the list links to; nobody agreed to anything more.
- Trusting a success status. A page can load and still have changed, or sit on a domain that changed hands.
- Offering a replacement that covers less. If the dead resource explained more, improve your page first or offer nothing.
- Reporting only the link you can replace. The maintainer needs to know about every dead entry, and the full report is what makes the note useful.
- Offering something in return or asking for anchor words. Either turns a recommendation into a trade.
- Chasing silence. The reclamation tutorial advises against repeated follow-ups; record the silence and move on.
- Moving a listed page without telling anyone. Your page becomes the dead entry someone else reports.
