Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Comparisons

Abandoned Cart Emails vs Remarketing Ads

Abandoned cart emails and remarketing ads compared: who each reaches, what permission each needs, what each costs and how to read the sales each recovers.
Comparisonintermediate8 min readUpdated

Abandoned cart emails and remarketing ads at a glance

The abandoned cart flows tutorial builds the email side: identify the shopper, trigger when an item is added and no order follows within a set wait, send a short sequence that reminds, reassures and asks once more, exit everyone the moment an order arrives, and measure against a group that is eligible but receives nothing. The flow can only reach shoppers the store knows, logged-in customers and guests who typed an address before leaving, and only those with a recorded basis for marketing. The ecommerce email and SMS flows guide places it among the other automated flows a store runs.

Remarketing ads reach shoppers through an ad platform instead. On Meta, a website Custom Audience is built from the events the pixel and Conversions API send, and Meta's help page on Custom Audiences describes audiences built from website activity, customer lists, catalogue interactions and engagement. The custom audiences guide covers how those audiences are matched and expire, and the catalog ads guide covers the retargeting ladder that shows each person the items they viewed or added to the basket. A shopper does not need to be identified to the store to enter such an audience; they need to send events Meta can tie to an account.

So the two reach overlapping but different groups. Email reaches the identified and permissioned; ads reach the matched and tracked. A store that runs only one of them leaves part of its abandoners unprompted, and a store that runs both without coordination prompts the same shopper twice.

Compare table

Abandoned cart emails vs Remarketing ads

Row labelAbandoned cart emailsRemarketing ads
Who can be reachedShoppers the store has identified, by account or a typed addressVisitors whose events reach the ad platform and can be matched to an account
Permission neededA recorded basis to send marketing email; an address typed at checkout is identity, not consentTracking consent where consent rules apply; visitors who decline do not enter website audiences
Cost per messageAlmost nothing beyond the sending platformPaid for every impression or click in the auction
Timing controlExact: the store sets the wait, the gaps and the sending windowLoose: the platform delivers within the window when the person is on its apps
ContentThe exact cart, objections answered, an incentive only where policy allowsProducts from the catalogue the person viewed or added, in a template
Frequency controlA fixed sequence with a cap and exits checked before each sendA frequency cap and audience window, enforced by the platform
What is measuredOpens, clicks and orders from entrants, read against a held-out groupImpressions, clicks and platform-attributed purchases
Attribution riskTakes credit for shoppers who were coming back anywayThe same, plus credit for any purchase after a view within the window
Setup effortShop events, identity, consent records, templates and exitsPixel and Conversions API events matched to the catalogue, audiences and a campaign
What stops itAn order, an unsubscribe, an emptied cart, the end of the sequenceAn order event that reaches the platform, or the person ageing out of the window

The first two rows decide who belongs in which channel. The third and fourth decide which channel should go first: email is precise and nearly free, so it is the default for every shopper it may reach. Ads earn their place with the shoppers email cannot reach, and with any extra orders a holdout shows they add on top of email.

When to choose abandoned cart emails

Choose the email flow first, for every abandoner the store can identify and has a basis to contact. It reaches the person directly, shows the exact items with a button that restores the basket, answers the obstacles that usually stop a purchase, and stops the moment an order arrives. Each further message costs next to nothing, so the flow's economics depend only on whether it changes behaviour, which a holdout shows.

Its limit is the permission it needs. The tutorial treats cart reminders as marketing email in most readings, so the flow needs a consent basis, the full footer and an unsubscribe link. The list building and consent guide explains, from the UK regulator's direct marketing guidance, when consent is needed, when existing customers can be contacted about similar products under the soft opt-in, and why every message must offer a way out; other markets have their own rules, and this is general practice, not legal advice. Capturing the address early in checkout, with a clear choice about marketing, is what makes the flow larger.

When to choose remarketing ads

Choose remarketing ads for abandoners email cannot reach: guests who left before typing an address, shoppers who gave an address without a basis for marketing, and returning visitors the store cannot recognise. They are also the route for people who browsed and never added anything, at a lighter weight, and for a store with no email programme at all.

Ads come with costs email does not have. Every impression is paid for, delivery timing belongs to the platform, and an audience full of people already on their way back reports a return the ads did not cause. The comparison of prospecting and remarketing explains why remarketing should be a capped, frequency-controlled layer judged by holdouts, and the diagnosis page for retargeting that gets all the credit shows how a last-touch report hands it sales other work created. The ROAS calculator is useful for the arithmetic once it is run on incremental revenue, as the comparison of iROAS and ROAS explains.

Decision table

SituationChooseWhy
Identified shopper with a basis for marketing emailEmail flow firstPrecise, timely and nearly free per message
Guest who left before typing an addressRemarketing adsEmail has no one to send to
Shopper already in the email flowEmail, with ads suppressed for the first part of the sequenceTwo prompts at once spend money on the same decision
Small store with no email programme yetBuild the email flow; use ads meanwhileThe flow is the cheaper long-term channel
Both running and both reporting strong returnsA holdout on eachEach report credits sales that would have happened
Browse without a basketA light email to known contacts, or a low-weight ad rungWeaker intent calls for fewer, later prompts

One recovery plan: suppression, timing and a shared holdout

Running both well means treating them as one plan with three rules.

Suppress across channels. A shopper who is identified and in the email flow does not also need a cart ad an hour after leaving. Exclude them from the cart ad audience for the first part of the sequence, or keep them in only where a test shows the ads add orders. The tutorial's advice that paid remarketing should share the purchase exit and frequency logic applies in both directions: an order has to end both, which means the purchase event must reach the ad platform as reliably as it reaches the email platform.

Sequence the timing. Email goes first because it is cheapest and most precise. Ads follow for the shoppers email cannot reach, and if they are used for identified shoppers at all, after the email sequence has run. Short audience windows for basket abandoners and longer ones for viewers keep the ads in proportion to the intent, as the catalog ads guide's ladder sets out.

Hold out together. Each channel's own report credits it with shoppers who were returning anyway. The honest reading randomly withholds a share of abandoners from email, a share from ads and a share from both, using a Holdout Group for each, and compares order rates. That shows the Incrementality of each channel and of the two together, and whether the ads add anything on top of the email for the shoppers who receive both. The comparison of email and SMS covers the separate choice of whether a text belongs in the cart sequence.

Illustrative example — not a real result

A yarn shop splits cart recovery between email and ads

Quilvexa Yarns, an invented online yarn shop, records 9,000 abandoned baskets above its floor over 90 days. Of these, 4,800 belong to shoppers it can email; it splits them at random into four cells. The 3,600 who get both the email flow and catalogue remarketing order at 13.0%; the 400 who get email only order at 12.5%; the 400 who get ads only at 9.0%; and the 400 who get neither at 8.0%. Email alone adds about 4.5 points, ads alone about 1.0, and ads on top of email about 0.5, around 18 orders across the 3,600, though cells of 400 leave wide intervals. For the 4,200 abandoners it cannot email, ads reach 3,570 and 630 are held back: 6.2% against 5.0%, about 43 extra orders. Meta reports 410 purchases from £2,700 of remarketing spend, £18,860 of revenue at an average order of £46 and a reported return of about 7.0. The holdouts imply about 61 extra orders, £2,806 of revenue, an incremental return of about 1.04, well below the 2.0 a 50% margin needs to break even. The shop keeps the email flow for everyone it can contact, removes them from cart ads, and keeps a smaller, capped ad budget for the shoppers email cannot reach, with the holdout running again next quarter.

Common mistakes

  • Running both channels at full weight on the same shopper. Two prompts for one decision double the cost, not the recovery.
  • Emailing every typed address. An address in a checkout field is identity, not a basis for marketing.
  • Reading either channel's own report as its contribution. Both credit shoppers who were already coming back; hold out a share of each.
  • Forgetting the purchase exit on the ads. If the order event does not reach the platform, buyers keep seeing the basket they bought.
  • A discount in the ads that the email policy refuses. One incentive policy, read from the customer record, must govern both channels.
  • No frequency cap on cart ads. A small audience of warm shoppers is easily shown the same products far too often.
  • Treating the two as rivals. They reach different abandoners; the comparison library lists other pairs that are easy to confuse.

Frequently asked questions

If I already send cart emails, do I need remarketing ads as well?

Only if a holdout shows they add orders the emails do not. The ads matter most for abandoners the store cannot email: guests who left before typing an address, and shoppers with no basis to receive marketing. For shoppers already in the email flow, ads often reach the same people who were going to return through the email or on their own, so suppress them from the ads for the first part of the email sequence and test whether adding ads back changes the order rate.

Is an abandoned cart email a service message or a marketing message?

In most readings it is marketing, because the shopper has not bought anything and the email asks them to. That means it needs a basis to contact the person, the full footer and an unsubscribe link in every message. An email address typed into a checkout form identifies the shopper but is not consent to marketing on its own. Rules differ by jurisdiction, and the UK regulator's direct marketing guidance is one reference; none of this is legal advice.

Why does remarketing report so many recovered carts?

Because the people in a cart audience are the store's warmest visitors, and many of them return and buy whatever happens. If one of them saw an ad before buying, the platform's report can credit the ad with the sale. The cart flow's own report has the same weakness. Holding back a random share of abandoners from each channel, and comparing their order rate with the rest, is the only way to see how many baskets either one actually recovered.

Terms used on this page

Tools to try

Also related

Sources

  1. Direct marketing guidance — Information Commissioner's Office (UK)
  2. About Custom Audiences — Meta Business Help Centre

Related