Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Comparisons

Retail Media vs Shopping Ads

Retail media and Shopping ads compared: where each ad appears, whose data and reports it rests on, who can buy it and how to judge what each one returns.
Comparisonintermediate9 min readUpdated

Retail media and Shopping ads at a glance

Retail media, as the retail media guide describes it, covers four broad kinds of placement: sponsored listings in the retailer's search results, placements on product and category pages, display and homepage slots, and off-site audiences built from the retailer's shopper data. It is bought self-serve in the retailer's own interface, as a negotiated package, or through a demand-side platform where the retailer offers that route. Its reports come from the retailer's own sales, which is both its appeal and its weakness: the seller defines what counts as an attributed sale, one retailer at a time. The guide names no retailer, network or ad product, and neither does this page.

Shopping ads are built from a feed submitted to Google Merchant Center, whose product data specification documents the attributes each item needs: title, description, link, image, price, availability and the rest. The platform decides from the feed which searches each product matches, assembles the ad from the image, title and price, and sends the click to the product's link. Standard Shopping shows these listings on search results and the Shopping tab with the advertiser controlling product groups and bids; Google's help page on Performance Max describes a campaign that uses the same feed, with asset groups and audience signals, across Google's inventory towards a conversion or value goal. The shopping and catalogue ads guide and the Shopping and Performance Max hub cover how to run them, and the product feed guide covers the feed; this page does not repeat either.

Compare table

Retail media vs Shopping ads

Row labelRetail mediaShopping ads
Where the ad appearsOn the retailer's site and app, and on other sites using its shopper dataOn Google's search results and Shopping tab, and across Google's inventory with Performance Max
Who sells itThe retailer, self-serve or as a negotiated packageGoogle, through Google Ads
Who can buy itUsually brands whose products the retailer stocksA business with a product feed and pages where the products can be bought
Whose data targets itThe retailer's: what its shoppers search for, view and buyThe brand's feed, matched by the platform to searches, plus any audience signals supplied
Where the click landsThe retailer's product page; the retailer makes the saleThe product page named in the feed, usually the brand's own store
Who defines a saleThe retailer, including whether other products from the brand countThe brand, through its own conversion tracking
Reporting windowSet by the retailer; ask for it before reading any figureSet in the brand's own conversion settings
Customer data keptAggregated reports under the retailer's rules; the customer stays the retailer'sThe order and the customer record, in the brand's own systems
Creative neededThe product as the retailer lists it, plus banners for display placementsThe feed's image, title and price; asset groups as well for Performance Max
How to read its returnAgainst a holdout by region, store group or audience; never on the reported figure aloneAgainst break-even return from margin, and a holdout before scaling

The third and fifth rows decide most cases. Retail media is open to brands the retailer stocks and leads to the retailer's checkout. Shopping ads need a feed of products the advertiser sells and lead to the advertiser's own pages. So for many product brands the choice is not between two ads for the same sale. It is between the sale that happens in someone else's shop and the sale that happens in the brand's own.

When to choose retail media

Choose retail media when most of your sales happen on retailers' sites and shoppers search there rather than on the web. The FMCG marketing guide explains why that holds for everyday products: people choose between brands on a retailer's results page, influenced by what they remember and what is visible, and the brand rarely sees who bought. Sponsored listings and product page placements sit exactly there. They suit a new product with no reviews or organic position on the retailer's site, and a brand whose rivals are taking the sponsored positions on its category searches.

Choose it knowing what you are buying. The reports come from the seller of the product being evaluated, the customer stays with the retailer, and paid listings on searches where the product already ranks may move sales from organic to paid without adding any. The retail media guide's questions for any proposal, starting with how an attributed sale is defined and whether a holdout can be run, are the price of entry. Where the brand also lists its own products on a marketplace, the marketplace channel page covers sponsored placements from the seller's side, bid against break-even after fees.

When to choose Shopping ads

Choose Shopping ads when you sell from your own store and people look for your kind of product on the web. The ad is built from data you control, the click lands on your page, the order and the customer are yours, and the margin is the whole retail margin rather than what is left after a retailer's share. Targets can be set from that margin: the break-even calculator gives the return an order must reach to pay its costs, and the ROAS calculator checks a campaign against it. Standard Shopping gives the most control over which products compete and what each bids; Performance Max takes the same feed further across Google's inventory, and the comparison of Performance Max and Standard Shopping covers that choice.

Shopping ads are a weak substitute for retail media when the buyer will not leave the retailer. Someone doing a weekly grocery shop on a grocer's app is not searching the web for a sauce. For a brand in that position, more Shopping ads will reach people looking for the product online, which is a different audience from the one choosing at the grocer's shelf.

Decision table

SituationChooseWhy
Sold mainly through retailers, shoppers search the retailer's siteRetail media, with a holdoutThe ads sit where the choice is made
Sold mainly from your own online storeShopping adsYour data, your margin, your customer
Sold both ways, with an own store that is growingShopping ads first, retail media testedOwn-store sales keep the customer; retail media must prove it adds sales
A launch at one retailer with no reviews or organic rankRetail media for a periodSponsored placement gives visibility until the product earns its rank
A retailer's package arrives with a projected returnA pilot with a holdout before signingThe projection is the seller's figure
A brand with no product pages of its ownRetail media and the retailers' listingsShopping ads need pages where the product can be bought
Both running and reporting returns above targetHoldouts on each, then compare incremental return with marginReported returns follow different rules

Running both: one product range, two buyers' journeys

A brand sold through retailers and from its own store has two kinds of buyer. One searches the web, sees a Shopping ad and buys direct. The other opens a retailer's app, searches the category and adds the product to a basket with everything else. Retail media and Shopping ads can run side by side because they meet those two journeys at different points; trouble starts when they are judged as if they met the same one.

Three rules keep the pair honest. First, keep the budgets and targets apart: retail media's return is the retailer's figure on the retailer's sales, Shopping ads' return is the brand's figure on its own orders, and a single blended return mixes two definitions. Second, read each against what it caused, using a Holdout Group rather than the platform's credit. The comparison of iROAS and ROAS explains why only the return measured against a holdout can justify a budget line, and the incrementality testing guide sets out the designs, regional for retail media where the retailer allows it, and a geography or campaign holdout for Shopping ads. Third, set each target from the margin that channel actually earns. A sale through a retailer earns the brand its wholesale margin; a sale in its own store earns the retail margin less fulfilment. The comparison of marketplaces and your own store sets out the wider trade between selling through someone else's shop and your own, which is where the budget split between the two ad types finally comes from.

Illustrative example — not a real result

A sauce brand weighs a grocer's package against its own Shopping ads

Glomvaris Sauces, an invented sauce brand, sells through two grocers and its own online shop. The larger grocer offers a retail media package of £40,000 over three months, projecting £4.50 of attributed sales for every £1. The brand's own Shopping ads spend £8,000 a month at a reported return of 4.5. Before deciding, it asks the grocer for a one-month pilot of £12,000 with placements shown in six regions and withheld in three similar ones. The grocer reports £54,000 of attributed sales, a return of 4.5. Against the holdout regions, sales grew 3%, which implies £21,600 of extra sales, an incremental return of 1.8. Glomvaris earns 30% on each pound of grocer sales, so the extra sales bring £6,480 of margin against £12,000 of spend; at that margin the incremental return would need to reach 3.33 to break even. In the same month it adds £4,000 to Shopping ads and holds out two regions; the extra spend brings £11,200 of additional own-store orders, an incremental return of 2.8, against a break-even return of 1.82 on its 55% margin, so the extra spend earns £6,160 of margin. Glomvaris moves the extra money into Shopping ads and offers the grocer a smaller test limited to sponsored listings for a new flavour's launch.

To check a retailer pilot at the wholesale margin rather than the own-store one, the ROAS calculator tutorial for retail media enters the lift and reads it against that higher break-even.

Common mistakes

  • Comparing the two reported returns. Each follows its own definition of a sale and its own window.
  • Judging retail media on the retailer's figure. The seller marks its own work; only a holdout shows what the ads caused.
  • Expecting Shopping ads to reach the retailer's shoppers. People buying inside a retailer's app are not searching the web for the product.
  • Setting one return target for both. A retailer sale and an own-store sale earn the brand different margins.
  • Running Shopping ads on a weak feed. The feed is the campaign; fix titles, prices and availability before adding budget.
  • Paying for searches on your own name without testing. Sponsored listings on terms where the product already ranks often buy sales the organic listing would have made; ask the same question of Shopping ads shown to people searching for the brand.
  • Signing a package without a pilot. A short test with a holdout costs less than a quarter of spend that cannot be judged; the comparison library lists other pairs that are easy to confuse.

Frequently asked questions

Are sponsored listings on a retailer's site the same thing as Shopping ads?

They look alike, a product with an image and a price shown when someone searches, but they are sold by different parties and send the buyer to different places. A sponsored listing is sold by the retailer, appears in the retailer's own search results and leads to the retailer's product page, where the retailer makes the sale. A Shopping ad is bought in Google Ads, built from the brand's own product feed and leads to the product page the feed names, which for a brand selling direct is its own store.

Can a brand that only sells through retailers use Shopping ads?

Shopping ads are built from a product feed whose items link to pages where those products can be bought, so they suit a business that sells the product online itself. A brand whose products are sold only on retailers' sites has no such page of its own to send buyers to, which is why retail media and the retailer's own listings are usually its route to shoppers at the point of choice. A brand that also runs its own shop can use both, and should judge each on the sales it causes.

Why does retail media often report a higher return than Shopping ads?

Because the two are counted differently, not necessarily because one works better. The retailer decides what counts as an attributed sale and over what window, and its reports often include purchases from shoppers who were going to buy the brand anyway. Shopping ads are reported through the brand's own conversion tracking, with the settings the brand chose. Comparing the two reported returns side by side compares two sets of rules; a holdout on each shows what each one caused.

Terms used on this page

Tools to try

Where this page is used

Also related

Sources

  1. Product data specification — Google Merchant Center Help
  2. About Performance Max campaigns — Google Ads Help

Related