Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

E-commerce Marketing › E-commerce Retention

Subscribe-and-Save Programmes for Online Stores

How online stores run subscribe-and-save for consumables: which products suit it, the offer, cadence and skips, clear terms and easy cancellation, and churn.
Guideintermediate11 min readUpdated

When a subscription beats a reminder

The repeat purchase and loyalty guide maps the paths from a first order to a second, and the first of them is replenishment: the product runs out and is bought again. Its design task is to learn the re-order cycle and prompt the customer just before it ends, and the e-commerce email and SMS flows guide builds the replenishment flow that does the prompting. A subscription is the other answer to the same problem. Instead of reminding the customer, the store agrees the cycle with them once and sends the product without being asked.

The two answers suit different products and different customers. A reminder costs nothing per order, leaves the customer in charge of each purchase and tolerates cycles that vary from person to person. A subscription removes the effort of re-ordering, gives the store a forecast of demand and keeps the customer away from the moment when a competitor's advert might catch them, but it usually costs a standing discount and it creates an obligation on both sides. The retention hub describes subscriptions as a retention product in their own right, with their own metrics, rather than a checkbox on the product page; that is the right frame.

Row labelReplenishment reminderSubscribe-and-save
Who triggers the orderThe customer, after a promptThe schedule the customer agreed
Cost per orderNothing beyond the messageThe standing discount or perk, on every delivery
SuitsCycles that vary; customers who like to chooseSteady cycles; customers who would rather not think about it
Main riskA prompt that arrives too early or too latePaying a discount on orders that would have come anyway; churn
What the store learnsWhich prompts bring ordersA forecast of demand and a clear churn signal
What it demandsGood timing in the flowClear terms, easy changes and easy cancellation

Most stores that run subscriptions run both. One-off buyers get the reminder flow; customers who have re-ordered on a steady rhythm are invited to subscribe, because their own behaviour shows the cycle is real. Where a points or tier scheme is the other option on the table, the comparison of loyalty programmes and subscribe-and-save sets out which products suit each and how the two can run side by side.

Which products suit subscribe-and-save

The products that suit a subscription share three traits. They are used up at a steady rate, so a fixed cycle matches the need. Running out is a nuisance, so not having to remember has value. And the customer is unlikely to want a different product each time, so the same item can arrive again without a decision. Pet food, coffee, razor blades, filters, supplements and skincare basics fit. Seasonal items, products bought for occasions and anything whose use varies sharply from month to month do not.

The store's own order data shows which lines qualify. For each consumable, look at customers who bought it more than once: how long they waited between orders, how much that gap varies from one customer to the next, and what share of them re-ordered at all. A line whose re-order gaps cluster tightly is a candidate; a line where gaps are scattered is better served by reminders. Read small groups with care, because a pattern across a few dozen customers can move a lot from month to month.

Two more checks belong before launch. The product page has to explain the subscription where the decision is made, with both prices visible and the cycle stated, which the product page optimisation guide treats as part of price clarity. And the store has to be able to supply every scheduled delivery: a subscription that runs out of stock breaks the promise that made it attractive, so stock for subscriptions belongs in the planning conversation the capacity and stock guide describes.

The offer: discount, perks and what it costs

The usual offer is a standing percentage off every delivery. It is easy to explain and expensive to keep, because it is paid on every subscription order for as long as the customer stays, including the orders the customer would have placed at full price through a reminder. Before choosing a figure, work out what each delivery leaves after product cost, packing, delivery and the discount, using the method in the contribution margin and break-even guide, and compare it with what the same customers bring in through reminders. The break-even calculator for subscription businesses makes the arithmetic explicit.

A discount is not the only thing a subscription can offer. Free delivery on subscription orders, first access to limited stock, a small gift at a milestone, or simply the convenience of not running out can carry much of the value at a lower cost. The useful question is what the customer is really buying: for many replenishment products it is the certainty of never running out, and that costs the store less to provide than a permanent reduction.

Whatever the offer, it has to stay honest over time. A low introductory price that rises after the first deliveries is a price change, and the guide to communicating a price change covers notice, reasons and options for existing customers. The same guide applies when costs force the subscription price up later: subscribers should learn about it before they are charged, not from a bank statement.

Cadence, skips, swaps and pauses

The cycle is the heart of the programme. Offer cycles that match the re-order gaps found in the order data, and let customers pick, because a household with two large dogs and a household with one small cat do not run out on the same day. A sensible default is the cycle most repeat buyers of that product already follow.

Most subscribers leave for a reason other than dissatisfaction: they have too much stock, they are going away, their needs changed for a while. A programme that only offers cancellation turns each of those moments into a lost customer. Give every subscriber four controls, each reachable in one or two steps from the account and from the reminder before each delivery:

  • Skip the next delivery without changing anything else.
  • Change the date or cycle, earlier or later.
  • Swap to a different size, flavour or variant.
  • Pause for a period the customer chooses.

These controls are not a way to keep people who want to leave. They are the way to keep people who only wanted a change, and they sit alongside an easy cancel button, not in front of it.

Subscriptions take payment repeatedly without a fresh decision from the customer, which is why they draw regulators' attention. The sign-up flows guide notes that regulators treat clear terms and easy cancellation for subscriptions as consumer protection matters, and the cancellation save offer test records that regulators such as the Competition and Markets Authority and the Federal Trade Commission treat easy cancellation of subscriptions in this way. Their published guidance on clear terms, consent to charges and easy cancellation is useful general direction; it is not legal advice, rules differ by country, and the design should be checked by someone qualified before launch.

In practice, that direction becomes a short list of design rules:

  • State the terms before sign-up, next to the button that starts the subscription: the price of each delivery, the cycle, when the first and later charges happen and how to cancel. The same principle appears on the pricing page guide, which holds renewal terms equally clear in every version of a page rather than treating clarity as something to test.
  • Make subscribing a choice. Show the one-off price and the subscription price side by side, with neither pre-selected. The honest persuasion guide treats a pre-ticked recurring charge as the pressure version of a default.
  • Make cancelling as easy as joining. Online sign-up should mean online cancellation, without a call or a hidden page. The honest persuasion guide's section on leaving and cancelling applies the rule.
  • Keep any save offer declinable in one action. The cancellation save offer test shows how to judge a pause or discount offer at the cancel step while ease of cancelling stays a guardrail, not a variable.

This page states no reminder period, notice period or renewal rule, because the sources it relies on state none. Find out what applies in each market where the store sells before the programme goes live. For the rest of the leaving experience, from the confirmation and final charge to one optional exit question and what marketing may still send, the guide to designing the cancellation experience covers memberships, service plans and accounts as well as subscriptions.

Messages that run the subscription

A subscription generates messages of two kinds, and keeping them apart protects both. Some are part of running the service the customer signed up for: the reminder that a delivery is coming with the controls to change it, dispatch and delivery updates, a failed payment, a change to the price or the product. Others promote: an offer on another product, a newsletter, a seasonal campaign. The promotional versus transactional guide explains why the first kind is sent as part of the service and the second needs a lawful basis for marketing, as the direct marketing guidance published by regulators such as the UK's ICO treats it, and why loading service messages with promotion can pull them under the marketing rules.

The upcoming-delivery reminder is the most important service message. It tells the subscriber what is coming, when and at what price, and puts skip, change and pause one tap away. A subscriber who can adjust easily from the reminder rarely needs to cancel to solve a temporary problem. The first delivery deserves a message of its own as well, which the post-purchase email flow tutorial covers for any first order: what to expect, how to use the product and where the controls are.

Promotional messages to subscribers follow the same consent and frequency rules as any other marketing, and the governance section of the flows guide sets the priority between them. A subscriber who receives a campaign offering the same product at a lower one-off price than their subscription has been given a reason to cancel.

Measuring subscribers by cohort

A subscription programme is judged on how long subscribers stay and what they are worth, not on how many sign up. Group subscribers by the month they joined and read each Cohort at fixed ages, as the cohort analysis tutorial shows: how many are still active after each delivery, how many skipped or paused, and how many cancelled. The churn and retention metrics guide defines churn and its variants; use one definition and keep it.

Three comparisons make the reading honest:

  • Subscribers against regular re-orderers. Customers who already re-ordered steadily before subscribing would have bought much of their volume anyway. Compare their value with similar customers who stayed on reminders, so the discount is weighed against the orders it actually added.
  • Contribution, not revenue. Lifetime value (LTV) for subscribers is the margin left after the discount and delivery, read the way the retention and payback guide reads payback.
  • Reasons for leaving. Record a reason at cancellation and read it by cohort. Reasons such as too much stock or a change of need point to the cycle and the controls; reasons about the product or delivery point elsewhere.

Purchase frequency is worth watching too. If subscribers end up ordering less often than they did before subscribing, the chosen cycle is too slow or the default was set from the wrong customers. The data that joins orders, payments and customers for this reading sits in more than one system, and the subscription measurement guide covers how to connect them.

A pet food shop designs its subscription (illustrative)

Illustrative example — not a real result

Chowbristle Pet Pantry sets its subscription from its own re-order data

Chowbristle Pet Pantry is an invented online pet food shop. Before launching a subscription, it looks at 1,400 customers who bought the same dry food more than once in a year. For its small bags, re-order gaps cluster between four and six weeks; for large bags, between seven and nine weeks. Treats show no pattern at all, so they stay on reminders.

A competitor offers 15% off every subscription delivery. Chowbristle works out that on a £30 large bag with a contribution of £9 before any discount, 15% would leave £4.50 per delivery, and that most of its steady re-orderers would buy anyway. It offers 5% off plus free delivery on subscription orders instead: £1.50 of discount and the £1.20 share of the delivery charge it would otherwise have collected leave £6.30 per delivery. It sets the default cycle to five weeks for small bags and eight for large ones.

The reminder sent three days before each delivery carries skip, change date and pause buttons. Terms are shown beside the subscribe button, and cancelling takes two clicks in the account. After six months, 62% of the first monthly cohort are still active. Subscribers who skipped at least once are still active at a higher rate than those who never touched their settings, which the team reads as a reason to keep the controls prominent, not as proof that skipping causes loyalty. Cancellation reasons are mostly "too much food at home", so the shop adds a nine-week cycle for large bags.

Common mistakes

  • Pre-selecting the subscription. A recurring charge the customer did not actively choose produces refunds, disputes and complaints rather than loyal subscribers.
  • Setting the discount by copying a competitor. The standing discount is paid on every delivery for as long as the customer stays; set it from the store's own contribution per delivery.
  • Offering only cancel. Without skip, change and pause, every temporary problem becomes a lost subscriber.
  • Hiding the cancel button. Cancelling should be as easy as joining; a save offer, if any, is declinable in one action.
  • Counting sign-ups as success. Read cohorts at fixed ages, net of churn and of orders that would have come anyway.
  • Promoting a cheaper one-off price to subscribers. A campaign that undercuts the subscription price gives subscribers a reason to leave.
  • Letting stock run out. A subscription is a promise of supply; plan stock for scheduled deliveries before promoting the programme.

Frequently asked questions

How big should a subscribe-and-save discount be?

There is no right size to copy, and the site cites no benchmark. The discount is paid on every delivery for as long as the customer stays, including deliveries they would have ordered anyway, so set it from the contribution each delivery leaves after product, packing, delivery and the discount, and compare that with what the store earns from the same customers through reminders. Many stores find that convenience, priority stock or free delivery on subscription orders do more of the work than the percentage.

Should a store make subscribing the default option on the product page?

No. A pre-selected subscription turns a one-off purchase into a recurring charge the customer did not choose, which is the pressure version of a default that the site's honest persuasion guide warns against. Show both options side by side with the price of each, and let the customer pick. Regulators such as the CMA and the FTC treat clear terms and easy cancellation of subscriptions as consumer protection matters; their guidance is general direction, and the design should be checked with someone qualified.

Is a subscription better than a replenishment reminder email?

Not always. A reminder costs no discount and leaves the customer in control, so it suits products whose cycle varies from person to person or customers who like to choose each time. A subscription suits products with a steady cycle and customers who would rather not think about re-ordering. Many stores run both: a reminder for one-off buyers and an invitation to subscribe for customers who have re-ordered on a regular rhythm.

Terms used on this page

Tools to try

Where this page is used

Also related

Sources

  1. Competition and Markets Authority — GOV.UK
  2. FTC business guidance — Federal Trade Commission
  3. Direct marketing guidance — Information Commissioner's Office (UK)

Related