Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

International Marketing › International Operations

Building a Contribution View for Each Market

How to build a contribution view for each market: assign orders to a market, subtract its own costs, show shared costs apart and read it by the market's role.
Tutorialintermediate16 min readUpdated

Why a market's profit is not its return on ad spend

The measuring and reporting guide builds a consolidated report that leads with a row per market: its role, its headline measure, the target and the actual. For an established market the headline it names is contribution or profit from marketing, and the guide stops at the name. A return on ad spend per market answers a narrower question, whether the advertising clears the break-even return (Break-even ROAS) that the market's own margin implies, and the ROAS calculator page for international markets shows how to read it. Neither adds the rest of what a market costs: the local agency, the adaptation of its campaign assets, the support cover its customers need, the reviewers who keep its pages in step with the source, and its share of the team and tools that sit at the centre.

The finance reporting guides stop one step short as well. The marketing P&L guide works out what marketing leaves after its own cost, for the function as a whole. The allocating shared marketing costs guide shares costs across channels or products and says the same choice applies where marketing reports across countries or regions, without building that report. This tutorial builds it, market by market, from the same bases so that it reconciles with the consolidated report and with finance's own figures.

The reason to build it is the decision it feeds. The guide on pausing or closing a market puts the decision at a gate, against figures on shared definitions, and the multi-market operations playbook asks for a recorded decision on every market once a year, as a starting rhythm. Without a view of what a market earns and what it costs, that conversation can run on revenue, or on a return that leaves out part of the cost.

The view informs the decision and does not make it. It is also not accounting: how costs are classified, how revenue is recognised and anything touching tax or transfer between companies belong to finance and to local advisers, and nothing here is advice on them.

Before you start

  • The measurement bases. The reporting currency, the year's budget rate, the period and the definition of revenue, as the measuring guide sets them. Use the same ones the consolidated report uses.
  • Each market's role and target. Written down in the plan before the period began, as the measuring guide asks.
  • Each market's own margin. Built from the costs that market's orders carry, as the guide on setting and showing prices across markets does when it judges a price by the contribution it leaves in the market.
  • Order data with a market on every order. The market recorded where the order was placed, with delivery country and billing country kept apart.
  • Costs coded to markets. Campaign names with a market code and spend booked to cost centres and codes that can be read by market.
  • Your finance business partner. Finance decides classification, the people-cost convention and how the view is used. Agree the bases with them before the first figure goes in.

The steps

Where a step gives advice that none of the guides it names states, the advice is general practice and this tutorial's own method, and finance decides whether the business adopts it.

  1. Write down the decision the view serves and the markets it covers

    Name the decision first: each market's place at the next gate or yearly review, whether it carries on, changes course, moves to a partner, pauses or closes, and the budget conversation that follows. List the markets covered with the role each holds. A pilot is included, but it is read against the proof conditions written before it launched; a market sold through a distributor is included on its own footing, which the step on which orders belong to which market explains.

    Then name the readers (the market owner, the budget holder and the finance partner) and write down what the view will not do. It will not decide on its own, and no market owner will be given a target against the allocated line. Goodhart's law warns that once a measure becomes a target it stops describing what it was meant to describe, and an allocated figure made into a target gives its owner every reason to push cost elsewhere.

  2. Agree the bases with finance before any number goes in

    Write one page of bases and apply it to every market. It holds the reporting currency, the budget rate for the year and the period; revenue taken from backend orders, net of returns and discounts, with the tax treatment that local advisers confirm for each market; the way contribution margin is worked out; which marketing costs count and the people-cost convention, which the marketing P&L guide says must stay the same from one year to the next, or the trends become meaningless; and who classifies what.

    Classification stays with finance. Where finance books a cost under cost of sales or against revenue, such as a partner commission or a discount code, the view follows finance's map of it rather than a new one. The same page should match the consolidated report line for line, so that a reader moving between the two meets the same definition of revenue in both. The guide on working with a finance business partner explains how to share margin data and definitions in a form finance can use.

  3. Decide which orders belong to which market

    Revenue has to land in one market, and the rule for where is a decision, not a lookup. The localising guide separates editions by market where the offer differs, so the natural rule is that an order belongs to the market whose edition and price list it was placed on, with the market code carried from the campaign link to the order record. Visitor location is not the rule: the measuring guide points to travellers, people shopping across borders and VPN users when it calls location a poor proxy for the market.

    Keep delivery country and billing country apart, as the tutorial on reading demand from other countries does. An order billed at home and delivered abroad comes from a home customer and may be a gift, and the rule should say where gifts go. Write the rule for each awkward case, such as a customer who buys from more than one edition or a market served from another market's edition, and test it on a sample of orders before it is applied to the year.

    A market sold through a distributor has a different shape. The business's revenue there is what the distributor pays, and the market's marketing cost is the share the business funds under the joint plan, as the distributor guide describes. Build that market's view on those lines, agreed with finance, rather than on retail orders the business does not see.

  4. Take net revenue in local currency and in the reporting currency

    For each market, take net revenue in the market's currency from the order system and convert it at the budget rate. Show both columns. The measuring guide gives the reason for the budget rate.

    Put the difference between the budget-rate result and the actual-rate result on a line of its own beneath the view, as a currency effect. The pricing guide's rule for exchange-rate moves is the same one: while the rate stays inside the band agreed with finance, what it gains or loses is shown as currency and not as marketing performance. Take revenue from the order system and not from analytics, because each property and each ad account carries a currency and a time zone setting of its own, as the measuring guide notes from Google Analytics Help, so their totals can differ from the orders.

  5. Subtract the market's own variable costs to reach its contribution

    The contribution margin guide lists what each order carries: the product, packing and delivery, payment fees, the cost of handling returns and the customer service an order generates. For each market, use that market's own figures: what delivery to it costs the business, how many orders come back and what each return costs, the fees on its payment methods and the support its customers need in their language. Borrowing the home margin hands a market a contribution it does not have.

    A new market may have too few orders to show these costs. Use the assumptions the pilot was planned on, label them as assumptions in the view and replace them with records as orders accumulate. Show the result as an amount and as a share of net revenue. What remains is the contribution margin the market leaves before any marketing is paid for.

  6. Subtract the marketing cost that can be traced to the market

    Direct marketing cost is whatever the invoices show belongs to the market alone, for example media in its ad accounts or in campaigns coded to it, as the media and channels guide sets up; local agency and partner fees; the production and adaptation of its campaign assets; market events; funding a distributor under the joint plan; and in-market people where the company convention counts people. The test is the allocation guide's own: can the cost be traced to the market from the invoice.

    Coding makes this easy or impossible. When each invoice carries a cost centre and a campaign code that name the market, each cost can be read as direct at source, as the mapping marketing spend to finance codes tutorial shows; a cost that serves several markets is shared and waits for the step on sharing the central costs. Show contribution after direct marketing cost as its own line.

  7. Add what the market costs to keep open

    Some costs are neither variable by order nor media, and exist because the market exists. The upkeep of its localised content is one, as the guide on keeping localised content in step describes; the reviewers' time is another; support cover for the market's languages and hours is a third, at the level chosen in the support guide. Add any local compliance review the market needs and, where the convention counts it, the market owner's time.

    Whether these sit in marketing's budget or in another department's is finance's classification. Show them in their own column either way, so the reader sees what the market costs the business to keep open, including any part that does not appear in marketing's line. The column is this tutorial's own method: the upkeep, reviewer and support costs in it are named by the guides linked above, none of which puts them in a market's view, and finance decides whether the business carries the column in its own reports. For a pilot, these costs are part of what it must prove it can carry.

  8. Share the central costs in a column of their own

    The centre carries costs that serve every market: the central team, tools, global creative and brand activity, and any network agency fee. Share them with a rule agreed with finance, choosing the base for each shared cost from the allocation guide's table of bases and reading what that base misleads about before it is applied to a market.

    Write the method down and keep it stable, as the allocation guide's closing section describes. Then show contribution after the market's own costs and contribution after its allocated share as separate lines, never as one fully loaded figure on its own. This is not a rule for charging one company in a group for another's costs; that is for finance.

  9. Read each market by its role, with its counts

    Start from the headline measure the measuring guide's table of roles gives each market, and read a pilot against the proof conditions written before it launched. This tutorial adds a second reading of its own for a growth market: whether contribution after direct marketing cost is moving the way its plan said. Where the market is established, the marginal returns guide sets out how its next unit of spend is read.

    Set each market beside its own plan before setting it beside any other, and where a figure looks wrong, restate it on shared definitions first, as the troubleshooting page for campaigns that miss in some markets does. Put the count next to every rate, and give any figure the decision turns on a range, as reading small numbers advises; a small market's order count is small. A new market's cost can land before its orders do, so read it across the periods it spans, and read its customers by cohort with the cohort analysis guide, not by one period's first orders.

  10. Take it to the gate, compare what would change, then record it and keep the method steady

    At the gate, the phase-gate reviews framework asks for a decision against criteria written beforehand. For a market that does not cover its costs, the question that matters is what would actually change if it paused or closed. Its contribution would stop. The direct marketing and running costs that can end would end, at the pace the guide to cutting a marketing budget describes. The allocated costs would usually stay, and would be carried by the markets that remain.

    So the comparison for the decision sets the market's contribution against the costs that would end, and the allocated line informs a separate conversation about whether the centre is the right size for the markets it serves. The pausing guide sorts pausing, handing over and closing by their reversibility, and that belongs in the same discussion. Put the decision into the decision log, with its evidence, the review date and what would make the business reconsider it, and keep the bases and the allocation method unchanged for the next period so that the next view reads against this one. Ask the finance partner to confirm both before the view is shared beyond marketing.

The lines of a market's contribution view: a table

Each market takes the same lines, in the same order. A reader should be able to read left to right, from what the market sells to what it leaves after its own costs and then after its share of the centre.

LineWhat it holdsWhere it comes fromWho agrees it
Net revenue, local currencyOrders assigned to the market, net of returns, discounts and tax as agreedThe order system, by the market ruleFinance
Net revenue, reporting currencyThe same figure at the year's budget rateThe bases pageFinance
Variable costsProduct, delivery, returns, payment fees and support per order, that market's ownThe market's own records, or the pilot's labelled assumptionsFinance
Market contributionNet revenue less variable costs, as an amount and a shareCalculatedFinance
Direct marketing costMedia, local agency and partners, adaptation, events, distributor fundingInvoices coded to the marketMarketing with finance
Contribution after direct marketingContribution less direct marketing costCalculatedFinance
Costs of keeping the market openContent upkeep, reviewers, support cover, local compliance reviewLedger and the market's plansFinance classifies
Contribution after those costsThe line before any share of the centreCalculatedFinance
Central costs allocatedThe market's share, with the base written beside itThe allocation methodFinance
Contribution after allocated costsWhat remains once the centre is sharedCalculatedFinance
Currency effectBudget-rate result against actual-rate result, below the lineFinance's actual-rate figuresFinance
CountsOrders, new customers, returns and the plan beside each figureThe order system and the roadmapMarket owner

What the view can and cannot say

It can say whether a market covers what it alone causes, how far its contribution reaches into the shared costs, where its margin is thinner than home's and by how much, and how the markets compare when every one is on the same bases. It gives the gate a record that the decision log can cite.

It cannot see the value of customers who buy again after the period; the ROAS calculator page says the same of the calculator, and the cohort view and the market notes carry that. It cannot see what a market does for the others, such as brand reach or partner relationships, or what closing it does to a later return, which the market entry guide warns can leave a later entry facing partners, media and customers who remember the first. It cannot size the opportunity, give a benchmark for what a market should earn (none is stated here) or replace the proof conditions a pilot was set up to meet. It is management reporting agreed with finance, not an accounting statement.

A picture frame maker reads its markets side by side (illustrative)

Illustrative example — not a real result

Wadrulis Frames reads Markets A, B and C

Wadrulis Frames, an invented maker of hand-finished wooden picture frames, sells through its own site at home and in three other markets. Finance agrees the bases: one reporting currency, a budget rate for each market's currency, revenue from the order system net of returns, discounts and tax, and a people-cost convention that excludes salaries. Market B's local revenue converts at a budget rate of 5 local units to 1 reporting unit. The market rule is the edition an order was placed on; 62 orders placed on the home edition, billed at home and delivered to Market A, are counted to home.

Market B is established, Market A is in its growth phase with a plan written before the year, and Market C is a pilot with a fixed test budget and a written proof condition of 500 orders. Each market's margin comes from its own records, and Market A's longer deliveries leave it a thinner one. Central costs allocated to the three markets (tools, global creative and the network agency fee, with no salaries in the pool) are shared with a base chosen for each cost: the network agency fee and the global creative by the time the central team logs to each market, and the tools by usage. All figures are in thousands of the reporting currency.

LineMarket BMarket AMarket CThree markets
Net revenue1,200500601,760
Variable costs720340441,104
Market contribution48016016656
Direct marketing cost25821070538
After direct marketing222-50-54118
Costs of keeping the market open604814122
After those costs162-98-68-4
Central costs allocated844812144
After allocated costs78-146-80-148

The counts beside the figures are 6,000 orders in Market B, 2,500 in Market A and 400 in Market C. At an actual average rate of 5.4, Market B's local revenue comes to 89 less in the reporting currency than at the budget rate; finance shows that on the currency line beneath the table and Market B's own result is left as it was.

The team reads each market by its role. Market B covers its own costs and carries its allocated share of the centre, and its marginal return is checked before any budget is added. Market A's plan expected -80 after direct marketing and it reached -50, so it ran ahead of plan, and its cost per new customer is read against its own target, not against Market B. Market C reached 400 of its 500 orders, a count the team shows with its range and compares with Market C's own plan; the pilot's gate decides what the gap means.

At the gate the team asks what a pause in Market A would change. Its 160 of contribution would stop, 210 of direct marketing and up to 48 of running costs could end, depending on the agency retainer's notice period and the content commitments, and the 48 of allocated cost would land on Markets B and C. On those numbers alone, a pause would leave the business 50 to 98 better off once those costs had ended, and worse off while they run on; but the view cannot see whether Market A's first-time buyers reorder. The team asks for the cohort table, writes the decision to continue to the next gate into the decision log with that table as its condition, and asks finance to review the size of the central pool before any market is judged on its allocated line.

Common mistakes

  • Reading return on ad spend as a market's profit. It leaves out the agency, the adaptation, the support cover and the centre. Build the contribution view and read the ad return inside it.
  • Using the home margin for a market. Delivery, returns, payment fees and support cost each market differently. Work the contribution on that market's records, or on labelled assumptions for a new one.
  • Assigning orders by visitor location. Travellers, cross-border shoppers and VPN users blur it. Record the market where the order is placed and write the rule for gifts and other awkward cases.
  • Folding the central costs into the market's number. A single fully loaded figure hides what the market controls. Show the allocated share in a separate column, with its base.
  • Letting the allocated line decide. Allocated costs usually stay when a market stops. Compare contribution with the costs that would end, and use the allocation for the conversation about the centre.
  • Judging a pilot or a growth market as an established one. Read each by its role and its own plan, with the count beside every rate.
  • Changing the method between periods. A new base or a new market rule makes the trend meaningless; record any change.

The international operations hub places this view beside the guides on media, measurement, the shared calendar, rollouts and customer support.

Frequently asked questions

Should every market be expected to show a profit?

No. The site's cross-market measurement guide gives each market a role and a headline measure to match. This view adds a reading of its own, whether a growth market's contribution after direct marketing cost is moving the way its plan said. It shows every market on one basis, so a loss in a pilot or a growth market is read against its own plan rather than against the established markets.

Do the shared central costs belong in a market's number?

They belong beside it, in a column of their own, and not inside it. Allocated costs usually stay put when spend rises or falls and when a market stops, so the contribution view shows what the market earns after its own costs first and after its share of the centre second. A market that covers its own costs but not its share of the centre still adds to the business, and closing it would usually leave its share to be carried by the markets that remain. The allocation informs a conversation about overhead; it never decides where money goes.

Can the view be built from the ad platforms' own revenue figures?

It should be built from the business's own order records. The measurement guide compares markets on backend data because platform and analytics conversion counts reflect each region's consent setup, and so they are not comparable between regions. Platform figures remain useful for steering campaigns inside a market, and the view takes its revenue, returns and costs from the order system and the ledger, agreed with finance.

Terms used on this page

Tools to try

Frameworks

Sources

  1. Google Analytics Help — Google Analytics Help

Related