Brief
Spraycliff Swimwear is an invented swimwear brand selling swimsuits, bikinis, kids' swimwear, cover-ups and a small wetsuit range. It is highly seasonal, discounts heavily at the end of each summer and sells on its own store and two marketplaces. Revenue grew last year while profit fell. Returns are high on some ranges, every channel runs one target, and the founder wants to know where to grow and what to stop.
Core colours carry over from one season to the next; seasonal prints that do not sell by the end of summer are written down. Stock for the season is bought before the plan starts, so the plan has to sell what exists.
Inputs and constraints
Spraycliff Swimwear: per-order economics on the own store
| Range | Price paid | Cost of goods | Packing and delivery | Payment fees | Expected returns cost | Return rate | Share of revenue |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Swimsuits | £60 | £21 | £6 | £1.20 | £12 | 30% | 40% |
| Bikinis | £45 | £15 | £5 | £0.90 | £8 | 25% | 25% |
| Kids' swimwear | £25 | £11 | £4 | £0.50 | £1 | 8% | 15% |
| Cover-ups and accessories | £30 | £9 | £4 | £0.60 | £1.50 | 10% | 10% |
| Wetsuits | £140 | £70 | £9 | £2.80 | £8 | 12% | 10% |
Marketplaces list swimsuits, kids' swimwear and cover-ups. They charge a 15% referral fee and £3.50 per order for fulfilment in place of own delivery, and take payment themselves. Returns cost the same as on the own store. The founder wants 8 points of revenue kept as profit after ad cost on every range and channel.
Spraycliff Swimwear: last season's promotions, channels and cohorts
| Promotion | Discount | Length | Orders | What followed |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Launch code for subscribers | 15% | One week | 1,800 | Orders the next week in line with the week before |
| Mid-season bikini event | 25% off bikinis | Two weeks | 2,600 | Bikini orders in the next two weeks 35% below the same weeks a year earlier |
| End-of-season sale | 40% sitewide | Four weeks | 5,200 | 60% of buyers were existing customers |
| Channel | Spend | Attributed revenue | Reported ROAS | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Performance Max, one campaign | £90,000 | £405,000 | 4.5 | No brand exclusion; brand terms about 30% of value |
| Meta catalogue ads, one ad set | £70,000 | £245,000 | 3.5 | Prospecting and retargeting mixed |
| Brand search | £8,000 | £96,000 | 12.0 | Impression share fell during the season |
| Marketplace sponsored listings | £30,000 | £96,000 | 3.2 | Bid to a revenue target |
| Customers acquired through | First-order contribution | Twelve-month cumulative contribution | Acquisition cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Non-brand Google | £15 | £27 | £24 |
| Meta prospecting | £13 | £19 | £27 |
| End-of-season sale, all channels | £2 | £8 | £14 |
| Organic and brand search | £18 | £34 | Not paid |
Constraints:
- A founder, an e-commerce manager and one in-house marketer, with one agency running paid media.
- Next season's paid budget is no larger than last season's; any growth comes from moving money.
- No tests across the peak summer weeks, when a stalled change costs most.
- The founder will not drop a marketplace this season, but will change what is listed there.
Task
Write one plan with the sections below, in this order. State expected effects as directions with a way to check them; do not invent uplifts.
- Profit targets. Build contribution margin per order for each range, on the own store and on the marketplaces, following the contribution margin and break-even guide. Derive the break-even return (Break-even ROASMinimum ROAS to avoid a loss.) and a target with the founder's profit buffer for each, using the break-even calculator and the ROAS calculator. Say which ranges belong on which marketplace, as the marketplace selling guide describes.
- Promotion policy. Write rules for depth, ranges and timing. Separate seasonal prints, whose cost is sunk once they would be written down, from core colours that carry over. Set the sale-period targets with the ROAS calculator walkthrough for discount promotions, and say how pulled-forward demand will be measured after each promotion.
- Catalogue structure. Give each range and stock type a role, then map it to Performance Max campaigns and listing groups following the Performance Max structure guide, to Meta product sets for prospecting, retargeting and cross-sell, and to indexable category and filter pages. Check the feed and labels against the shopping and catalogue ads guide. Include the brand exclusion and how brand search is restored.
- Customer value. Set an acquisition cost limit per channel from cohort value on margin, using the cohort analysis tutorial to define how the table is refreshed. State what lifetime value (LTVTotal value a customer brings over time.) you use, over what horizon, and what you will not project.
- Retention and loyalty. Decide whether Spraycliff needs a loyalty programme, a lighter mechanic aimed at the second season, or neither, using the repeat purchase and loyalty guide. Cost any option, including breakage, and name the comparison group.
- Tests and review. Name the tests behind the biggest choices: a remarketing holdout for Meta retargeting, a budget increase incrementality test for any channel you scale, and the account-level read of the brand exclusion. Write each in the experiment hypothesis template, place them around the peak, and set spend steps and stop rules from the marginal returns and forecasting guide.
- Plan on a page. Summarise the season in the one-page marketing plan: what changes, in what order, how each change is judged and what result would change the plan.
Evaluation criteria
| Criterion | What a strong answer shows | Common gap |
|---|---|---|
| Profit targets | Derives targets by range from contribution margin, returns and fees | Keeps one revenue target across ranges and channels |
| Promotion policy | Sets discount rules on margin and pulled-forward demand | Repeats last season's sale calendar |
| Catalogue structure | Groups products by margin and role across campaigns, product sets and indexable pages | Runs the whole range in one campaign |
| Customer value | Sets acquisition cost limits from cohort value on margin | Uses average order value as lifetime value |
| Tests and review | Names the tests behind the biggest choices and when results change the plan | Treats the plan as fixed for the season |
A strong plan also sequences its parts. Targets come first, because structure, promotions and acquisition limits all rest on them. The promotion policy treats sunk-cost stock differently from stock that carries over, rather than discounting everything to the same depth. The plan reads Performance Max ROASRevenue generated per unit of ad spend. only after removing brand traffic, judges Meta prospecting on new-customer cost against cohort value, and treats retargeting as unproven until a holdout measures its IncrementalityConversions caused by marketing.. It moves money between channels on marginal evidence, and it says in advance which test results would change the plan mid-season.
Check your arithmetic against the reference figures after working them out yourself.
Reference figures for self-checking
- Own-store contribution per order: swimsuits £19.80 (33%, break-even ≈ 3.0); bikinis £16.10 (36%, ≈ 2.8); kids' £8.50 (34%, ≈ 2.9); cover-ups £14.90 (50%, ≈ 2.0); wetsuits £50.20 (36%, ≈ 2.8).
- Marketplace contribution: swimsuits £60 − £21 − £9 − £3.50 − £12 = £14.50 (24%, break-even ≈ 4.1); kids' £5.75 (23%, ≈ 4.3); cover-ups £11.50 (38%, ≈ 2.6). Sponsored listings at 3.2 lose money on the first two.
- A 40% discount on a core-colour swimsuit, with returns cost scaled to the £36 price (about £7.20), leaves about £1 of contribution; on a seasonal print that would be written down, with cost of goods sunk, about £22.
- Performance Max without brand: about £283,500 of value. At brand search's own efficiency, brand cost about £10,000, leaving roughly 3.5 on about £80,000 of non-brand spend.
- Twelve-month value against acquisition cost: non-brand Google £27 against £24; Meta prospecting £19 against £27; end-of-season sale customers £8 against £14.
Submission checklist
When you have finished, compare your targets and promotion rules with the homeware store sale exercise, your structure with the sports nutrition catalogue exercise and your acquisition limits with the house plant cohort exercise. For the plan the level builds on, revisit the intermediate e-commerce level.
